Jump to content
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!) ×
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!)
In the Name of God بسم الله

Skanderbeg

Advanced Members
  • Content Count

    926
  • Joined

  • Last visited


Reputation Activity

  1. Like
    Skanderbeg reacted to A true Sunni in Shia Sunni Difference: Lineage Vs Character   
    You say you was raised as a 12er but your words betray your origins. I would have called you a liar but the moderators dont like my straight talking 
  2. Like
    Skanderbeg got a reaction from Ali_ in Isis Destroys Assad's Main Arsenal.   
    Are you going to tell me that the region of the takfiri opposition is a Paradise compared with the regime of Assad? Are you an ISIL fan?
  3. Like
    Skanderbeg reacted to Martyrdom in Halal Tacos   
    bro i would love to support him but thats like 500 miles from where im at.
  4. Like
    Skanderbeg reacted to Abu'l Khattab in Zoological Error In Nahj Al-Balagha   
    It is very clear that the Imam (as) is talking about how illumination hides/manifests the appearance of creatures, and not if they are nocturnal or not. 
  5. Like
    Skanderbeg reacted to Abu-Jafar Herz in Bukhari And Al-Kafi   
    This hadith is not found in the 4 books, nor does it have a authentic chain in our books. 
     
    Actually if you look in man la yahduruhu you'll see that Imam jafar [as] rejects this hadith.
     
    You on the other hand have a multitude of these in bukhari and muslim.
  6. Like
    Skanderbeg reacted to Abu-Jafar Herz in Bukhari And Al-Kafi   
    Asalamu Alaykum, we as Shia believe that hadith go through multiple tests before they are accepted. One of the biggest things that we look at as rational Muslims is to the matn of the hadith because as anyone who studied usul knows ahaad hadith(not taking into account external proofs) are not by themselves authoritative in belief (this principle is found in both Sunni and Shia schools) thus sometimes we also look at the matn to see if the hadith is valid.
     
     
    So if I wanted to take in a hadith and accept it as belief  it would need contextual proofs to establish it as acceptable, these contextual proofs can be tawatur, or the companions of the Imams were united upon it, or the matn can logically be proven, or maybe even perhaps the hadith's meaning is confirmed in the Qur'an,etc. These are just some of many ways that allows a hadith to be accepted into our belief structure, it is rather a rigorous standard. This is why you'll see Shia many times have no issues at all with discussing hadith, you'll see them finding enjoyment in such discussions since they don't have a rope around their neck being threatened to be labeled a fasiq or kafir for rejecting a hadith that is obviously wrong.
     
     
    So let us start with the first hadith.
     
     
    It was narrated from the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) that women will form the majority of the people of Hell. It was narrated from ‘Imran ibn Husayn that the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) said: “I looked into Paradise and I saw that the majority of its people were the poor. And I looked into Hell and I saw that the majority of its people are women.” (Narrated by al-Bukhari, 3241; Muslim, 2737)   Also we see that they also form the minority in heaven . Imran b. Husain reported that Allaah's Messenger (sallAllaahu alayhi wa sallam) said: Amongst the inmates of Paradise the women would form a minority.(No. 6600 Sahih Bukhari  These ahadith are obviously wrong for 2 reasons. 1- It contradicts other established reports in the Sunni books that each Muslim will have 2 wives from earth.  If every man on earth is going to have 2 wives then how can the women be the minority in heaven and majority in hell? 2- There is no rational reason to believe that Women are inherently more evil than men, nor is there any reason to believe that Allah [swt] just happen to create the souls who made make bad decisions as women.  This tells me a number of things.. 1- Bukhari is a fairy tale book.2- These hadith reflect the common view of women during 8th/9th century Arabia that was obviously fabricated and placed inside their hadith works.    Our hadith on the subject: Imam alSadiq said to Fudail who had asked the Imam regarding this matter: “Is it true that most of the inhabitants of Hell are women?” The Imam said, “and how is that so, if its possible for a man in the afterlife (paradise) to marry a thousand of these worldly women in a castle of pearl?” (man la yahdarahu alfaqih V3 p295)   I'll be posting more hadith over time to this thread, please respond and add what you find in their works, but please be sure to include a comparison from our books to maintain the intent of the thread.
  7. Like
    Skanderbeg reacted to Muhammed Ali in Banned Members   
    Khalilallah banned for disparaging the character of a member's mother. He also has a very long list of warnings.
    However, it must be added that he was unlike most of the other members with a similarly long list of warnings. He did not consider his rule breaking to be appropriate, and he has apologised for it a number of times in the past.
  8. Like
  9. Like
    Skanderbeg reacted to Darth Vader in Possible Most Companions Turn On Their Back?   
    You be the judge:
     
    Personally I feel the saddest and undeniable mass U turn of "companions" is to be found in the numbers and the names of the handful of people who prayed the funeral of the holy Prophet, peace be upon him, and buried him. What happened to so-called companions and friends then I wonder, especially the allegedly immaculate best three Sunni companions? They were all doing jalsa at saqeefa for worldly gain -- what they always wanted. Just like 21st century "friends" and "companions" most of whom disappear at times of need.
     
    Its true what someone said that "Man will always be man".
  10. Like
    Skanderbeg got a reaction from Ali-F in Inside Prophet(s)'s Grave   
    Wow! Good argument! Bye ..
  11. Like
    Skanderbeg got a reaction from mina in Blatant Hypocricy Of Tayyip Erdogan   
    This Erdogan is just a power-hungry man who wants to restore the glory of the Ottomans with Islam as the classical tool.
  12. Like
    Skanderbeg got a reaction from Muslim2010 in What Evidence Do The Shia Have For The Existence..   
    If Muhammad s.a.w. was infallible how could his successor be fallible?

    What kind of succession is that?

    The prophets and kings in the Holy Quran who succeeded eachother were though they had difirent ranks all infallible and real guides.

    When the blind lead the blind .. That's when ya' lost!

     
  13. Like
    Skanderbeg got a reaction from Muslim2010 in Inside Prophet(s)'s Grave   
    Your two idols were ready and willing to kill those who are in the heart of the Prophet s.a.w.

    You mix falsehood with truth.

    Don't talk such nonsense. 
  14. Like
    Skanderbeg got a reaction from The Light in Inside Prophet(s)'s Grave   
    Your two idols were ready and willing to kill those who are in the heart of the Prophet s.a.w.

    You mix falsehood with truth.

    Don't talk such nonsense. 
  15. Like
    Skanderbeg got a reaction from Abu-Jafar Herz in The Clear Refutation Of Fadak   
    I find this knowledge as inheritance idea really silly. As if they wanted to have male offspring so that their knowledge would be saved?

    Their knowledge came from Allah and if He want to teach His Knowledge to somebody else He is capable of doing that,

    Not depending on offspring from the Prophets a.s. to save His (Allah's) Knowledge unless He wants it that way and even then it destroys the concept of Khalifa because who else then those with knowledge do we want to have as our leaders.

    In short. It's about property and nothing less.
  16. Like
    Skanderbeg got a reaction from Abu-Jafar Herz in The Clear Refutation Of Fadak   
    Second of all, 

    This inheritance thing. If I have the responsibility over a car that the owner wanted to keep in my garage, my only duty is to be sure that nothing happens with that car until the owner asks it back but if the owner dies and his son claims his car then what should I do?

    Should I tell him that he doesn't have the right over that car because maybe he will use it for other purposes than driving only or maybe makes an accident with it?

    What a stupid arguments do they fabricate in the sunni camp.
  17. Like
    Skanderbeg got a reaction from Goswami in I Refuse To Pray With Sunni Muslims Anymore   
    Salam, 

    It just doesn't feel good to pray together with sunni muslims in a state of taqqiyah.

    Their wudu feels fake their way of praying feels fake and I get the feeling as if I am wasting my time and effort with their prayer as it is not going to be accepted anyway. 

    What should I do?
×
×
  • Create New...