Jump to content
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!) ×
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!)
In the Name of God بسم الله

Cyrax

Advanced Members
  • Content Count

    191
  • Joined

  • Last visited


Reputation Activity

  1. Like
    Cyrax reacted to 786:) in What shia lake in.   
    Good luck. I see why Shias leave the dawah to Sunnis now.
  2. Like
    Cyrax reacted to 786:) in Combination of Prayers   
    Imams did not normalize combination prayer. This was the method of exception not standard. Ask even Agha Khamenei and/or Agha Sistani and they will admit praying separate is better.
    You were misleading by saying “we try to follow the ways of our Imams” hence why we combine prayers. The fact is the way of the Imams is to pray 5 distinct times.
  3. Haha
    Cyrax got a reaction from AmirioTheMuzzy in Exposing Yassir Al-Habib   
    I was obviously being sarcastic.  I'm not only surprised that you didn't see that, but that TWO regular posters also didn't get the reference.
  4. Haha
    Cyrax got a reaction from Moalfas in Exposing Yassir Al-Habib   
    I was obviously being sarcastic.  I'm not only surprised that you didn't see that, but that TWO regular posters also didn't get the reference.
  5. Disagree
    Cyrax got a reaction from Anonymous-Male in Shia female perspective on Mutah & Nikah (permanent marriage)   
    Not true, the Muslims, Sunni and Shi'a alike report with mutawatir chains that the Messenger صلى الله عليه وسلم banned Mutah.  12er Shi'as take the position of a handful of Companions (which is perfectly legit) which didn't know the prohibition.  I don't have a problem with the brothers here following the position of a Companion, but the reality is, the tawatur nature of the reports, combined with the fact that they come from every Islamic sect (except the 12ers) should be more than enough evidence to dispel the myth the Umar banned Mutah.
  6. Completely Agree
    Cyrax got a reaction from habib e najjaar in Shia female perspective on Mutah & Nikah (permanent marriage)   
    Dude, do you seriously believe that?  People committed Zina during Jahiliyyah, the time of the Messenger صلى الله عليه وسلم and during the rule of Abu Bakr, why didn't Mut'ah prevent it then?
    I seriously don't know how you can possibly belief this.  It is in fact the opposite, the only way any one can accept this is if they are a 12er Shi'I and believe it to be a Sunnah.
    I would love for the some of the women on this forum to comment on this: do you seriously believe that Mut'ah has less of a harm on the woman who is practicing it, or whose husband is practicing it then it does for a man to not have his desires fulfilled even if he is riding on a camels back?  There is no way you'll even get 10% of 12er women to agree to that, let alone any tangible percentage from a non-12er women, Muslim or otherwise.
  7. Completely Agree
    Cyrax got a reaction from habib e najjaar in Shia female perspective on Mutah & Nikah (permanent marriage)   
    I can guarantee you that the depression and hopelessness that the women who practice Mut'ah or have their spouses practice Mut'ah FAR outweighs any supposed hopelessness that may appear in a man if a woman doesn't satisfy him even "when she's riding on a camel's back."
  8. Like
    Cyrax got a reaction from Ashvazdanghe in Exposing Yassir Al-Habib   
    I was obviously being sarcastic.  I'm not only surprised that you didn't see that, but that TWO regular posters also didn't get the reference.
  9. Disagree
    Cyrax got a reaction from Ashvazdanghe in Shia female perspective on Mutah & Nikah (permanent marriage)   
    إن شاء الله، تفضل
    https://alkazemalzaidy2013.wordpress.com/tag/قول-أئمة-الزيدية-في-زواج-المُتعة/
    Now I was wondering, does that mean you accept that the hadeeth the Messenger صلى الله عليه وسلم banned Mut'ah is mutawatir in Sunni sources?
  10. Disagree
    Cyrax got a reaction from Ashvazdanghe in Shia female perspective on Mutah & Nikah (permanent marriage)   
    Yes I did, بارك الله فيك, but I didn't see anything regarding the mutawatir reports found in Sunni and Shia sources banning it and why the Shi'as reject the mutawatir corroborated reports for an opinion of a Sahabi.
    I noticed you like AStrugglers post, do you also believe that Mut'ah isn't a pre-Islamic practice?
  11. Like
    Cyrax got a reaction from Panzerwaffe in Why do most reverts choose Sunni Islam   
    A lot of reasons really:
    1) No Da'wah obviously.
    2) Centers are empty.
    3) Centers are divided by culture.
    4) Lack of connection the Qur'an.
    5) Lack of connection to the Arabic language.
    6) Lack of clear evidence for the 12er concept of Imamah in the Qur'an (remember, most converts start out anti-Hadeeth).
    7) Mutah.
    8) Tatbeer.
    9) Support of Bashar al-Assad and other dictators when it suits them.
    10) Lack of focus on the Prophet صلى الله عليه وسلم.
    11) Ritual cursing.
    12) What they see of Sunni and Shi'a debates.
    13) Too much focus on shrines.
    14) Combining Dhuhur/Asr and Maghrib/Isha even at the mosque.
    That's all I can think of off the top of my head.
  12. Disagree
    Cyrax got a reaction from The Green Knight in Shia female perspective on Mutah & Nikah (permanent marriage)   
    I can guarantee you that the depression and hopelessness that the women who practice Mut'ah or have their spouses practice Mut'ah FAR outweighs any supposed hopelessness that may appear in a man if a woman doesn't satisfy him even "when she's riding on a camel's back."
  13. My Prayers
    Cyrax got a reaction from The Green Knight in Shia female perspective on Mutah & Nikah (permanent marriage)   
    السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته
    Akhi, this is well known among everybody, do you believe the Mutah was introduced by the Messenger صلى الله عليه وسلم?  Like the Messenger صلى الله عليه وسلم says, "البينة على المدعي واليمين على من أنكر".  Please provide your evidence, as of right now, there is no evidence to suggest that Mut'ah was introduced by the Messenger صلى الله عليه وسلم.  Here is a quote from al-Islam.org
    Akhi, I'm not trying to be a jerk, but this is like ABCs of this topic, أحسن الله إليك.
    Actually, I didn't use it to invalidate your practice, and in fact I even said that you taking the position of a Sahaabi on this issue is completely legit.  I was just pointing out to the people here that this isn't a Sunni vs Shi'a issue, its a 12er versus the rest of the Muslim issue.
    I believe that yes, the Messenger صلى الله عليه وسلم left the religion in the hands of the "Greatest Ummah that was brought forth to the people" (3:110).  You make takfeer of them and call them clueless, I confirm what Allah said about them.
    Would you like me to list them or are links fine?
  14. Like
    Cyrax reacted to Warilla in Why do most reverts choose Sunni Islam   
    1)Because Sunni do dawah.
    2) Sunni system is more transparent 
    3) less on a clergy and centralised system. Giving local centers and individuals more independence.
    4) majority so ease of access
    Also imagine being a someone interested in Islam go to a Sunni mosque all year round it's pretty much prayer and Qur'an. Go to a Shia centre and show them mass gatherings of crying, alot harder to explain. And Google Shia you  get alot of pics of mataam and zanjeer
  15. Disagree
    Cyrax reacted to Ashvazdanghe in Why do most reverts choose Sunni Islam   
    2.Sunni System is completly obscure all tat all Dawah men & women just force pople to become Muslim without giving warning about punishment of living Islam &  etc
    3.they are not independent majority of Sunni centers are linked with KSA or Turkey but except few cases about Turkish centers they don't face trouble from westerner countries but Shia centers are always accusing that are Iranian centers that they are trying to show themselves independent from Iran.
     
  16. Like
    Cyrax reacted to Warilla in Why do most reverts choose Sunni Islam   
    At an introductory level it's straight forward 4 schools hadith and rijal books available. Read a Sunni book or ask a local Imam they often take a hadith go through chains etc. Go to translated Shia books. How often do they go through chains of hadith from Al kafi. Ask a question Von fiqh you get the opinion of a marha with no explanation big how the ruling was achieved.
    Financially I can't comment as I don't know. But in Europe most centres are run by locals there is no larger clergy system they are connected to. Eg my local mosque as Sunni brelwi, diobandi, and salafi speakers. Normally organised independently by members. Also the bigger centers have more racial diversity showing a independence to specific nations.
  17. Thanks
    Cyrax got a reaction from habib e najjaar in Shia female perspective on Mutah & Nikah (permanent marriage)   
    Let me get this straight:
    1) You didn't know that Mut'ah was a practice that was pre-Islamic, and thought the Messenger صلى الله عليه وسلم introduced it.
    2) You admit that you to learn more about this, yet you say to me "do not be so quick to jump to" my "delusions."
    3) You criticize Umar for changing the ruling on Mut'ah (despite the overwhelming evidence the Mut'ah was banned by the Messenger صلى الله عليه وسلم) but then find the idea that the Imams would "seem to have changed" the ruling on Mut'ah just to oppose Sunnis a completely valid position.
    Just as an addition: why do you suppose the other Shi'a sects decided to support Umar's position here, when they oppose him on other issues like Taraweeh and Tathweeb, بارك الله فيك
  18. Thanks
    Cyrax got a reaction from Abu Nur in Shia female perspective on Mutah & Nikah (permanent marriage)   
    إن شاء الله، تفضل
    https://alkazemalzaidy2013.wordpress.com/tag/قول-أئمة-الزيدية-في-زواج-المُتعة/
    Now I was wondering, does that mean you accept that the hadeeth the Messenger صلى الله عليه وسلم banned Mut'ah is mutawatir in Sunni sources?
  19. Disagree
    Cyrax got a reaction from Ashvazdanghe in Shia female perspective on Mutah & Nikah (permanent marriage)   
    Not true, the Muslims, Sunni and Shi'a alike report with mutawatir chains that the Messenger صلى الله عليه وسلم banned Mutah.  12er Shi'as take the position of a handful of Companions (which is perfectly legit) which didn't know the prohibition.  I don't have a problem with the brothers here following the position of a Companion, but the reality is, the tawatur nature of the reports, combined with the fact that they come from every Islamic sect (except the 12ers) should be more than enough evidence to dispel the myth the Umar banned Mutah.
  20. Disagree
    Cyrax got a reaction from Ashvazdanghe in Shia female perspective on Mutah & Nikah (permanent marriage)   
    Actually, it is the 12er Shi'as who follow the opinion of a Sahabi while ignoring the clear prohibition of the Messenger صلى الله عليه وسلم.  The Sunnis, Zaydis, and Ismailis and the rest of the Muslims reject the positions that a Sahaabi here and there had.  In fact, there are literally thousands of things that Muslims disagree with a companion here and there.
    And of course I'll compare Mutah to alcohol, because:
    Do you sincerely believe that Mut'ah is a special ruling that Arabs weren't practicing before?  That seems to be your source of confusion.  The reality is, Mutah is exactly like alcohol, a habit that pre-Islamic Arabs engaged in until Islam prohibited it.
    And do you sincerely believe that the Zaydis and the Ismailis take the ruling of the prohibition of Mutah from "certain individual of the time who managed to gain popularity?"  LOL, that's almost as hard to believe as an infallible Imam changing the rulings of the religions just to "oppose the Sunnis."
  21. Disagree
    Cyrax got a reaction from Diaz in Shia female perspective on Mutah & Nikah (permanent marriage)   
    Not true, the Muslims, Sunni and Shi'a alike report with mutawatir chains that the Messenger صلى الله عليه وسلم banned Mutah.  12er Shi'as take the position of a handful of Companions (which is perfectly legit) which didn't know the prohibition.  I don't have a problem with the brothers here following the position of a Companion, but the reality is, the tawatur nature of the reports, combined with the fact that they come from every Islamic sect (except the 12ers) should be more than enough evidence to dispel the myth the Umar banned Mutah.
  22. Disagree
    Cyrax got a reaction from Diaz in Shia female perspective on Mutah & Nikah (permanent marriage)   
    Actually, it is the 12er Shi'as who follow the opinion of a Sahabi while ignoring the clear prohibition of the Messenger صلى الله عليه وسلم.  The Sunnis, Zaydis, and Ismailis and the rest of the Muslims reject the positions that a Sahaabi here and there had.  In fact, there are literally thousands of things that Muslims disagree with a companion here and there.
    And of course I'll compare Mutah to alcohol, because:
    Do you sincerely believe that Mut'ah is a special ruling that Arabs weren't practicing before?  That seems to be your source of confusion.  The reality is, Mutah is exactly like alcohol, a habit that pre-Islamic Arabs engaged in until Islam prohibited it.
    And do you sincerely believe that the Zaydis and the Ismailis take the ruling of the prohibition of Mutah from "certain individual of the time who managed to gain popularity?"  LOL, that's almost as hard to believe as an infallible Imam changing the rulings of the religions just to "oppose the Sunnis."
  23. Disagree
    Cyrax got a reaction from Aale Mohammad in Shia female perspective on Mutah & Nikah (permanent marriage)   
    Actually, it is the 12er Shi'as who follow the opinion of a Sahabi while ignoring the clear prohibition of the Messenger صلى الله عليه وسلم.  The Sunnis, Zaydis, and Ismailis and the rest of the Muslims reject the positions that a Sahaabi here and there had.  In fact, there are literally thousands of things that Muslims disagree with a companion here and there.
    And of course I'll compare Mutah to alcohol, because:
    Do you sincerely believe that Mut'ah is a special ruling that Arabs weren't practicing before?  That seems to be your source of confusion.  The reality is, Mutah is exactly like alcohol, a habit that pre-Islamic Arabs engaged in until Islam prohibited it.
    And do you sincerely believe that the Zaydis and the Ismailis take the ruling of the prohibition of Mutah from "certain individual of the time who managed to gain popularity?"  LOL, that's almost as hard to believe as an infallible Imam changing the rulings of the religions just to "oppose the Sunnis."
  24. Disagree
    Cyrax got a reaction from Muslim2010 in Imam Mahdi (عليه السلام) 's Father Abdullah or Imam Hassan?   
    And the ones quoted by ibn Taymiyah, which the author of the article attempted to refute, do.  There are even other versions which neither Ibn Taymiyah nor the author of the article mentioned, such as the one I quoted from ibn Hibban.
    As far as I know, there isn't a single authentic hadeeth which mentions all the details of the Mahdi, they are all found in various solitary reports, which give us insights on who he might end up being in the future, such as his name, where he might come from, who he might fight etc.
    Most of these reports, such as the ones that mention his name and his father's name, are Hassan at best, and mawoo3 at worst
  25. Like
    Cyrax got a reaction from Sirius_Bright in Have Iran spoken against genocide of Uyghur Muslims   
    السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته
    I apologize, I thought when you said "confrontations" and "taking actions against" that you meant going to war.  So if it doesn't mean war, then why is it so hard to speak out against China?
    If the fear is that if Iran speaks out against China then China will respond by cutting off trade to Iran, then why doesn't Iran try to also come to terms with the US in order to lift the trade sanctions?  The irony, of course, is that one of the reasons the US imposes sanctions against Iran is because of their "support for terrorism", the same justification the Chinese government for doing what its doing to the Uyghur people.
    1) It is not the only the "West" that is saying that, it is the Uyghur people that are saying it.  In reality, there is so much evidence to what is going on, that I am appalled by your attempt to white wash this and pretend like its some how the "West" who is only saying this.  There are also countries such as Saudi and the UAE who say nothing is going on.  The Uyghur people on the other hand, said a very different thing.
    2) Implying that I don't care about the people of Iran and the Shi'a people in general is a bunch of hogwash.  I think the sanctions against Iran are a horrible practice of punishing the whole for the crimes of a few.  I hate what is happening to Iran and speak out against it.  In fact, if you go back to my original post, I mentioned how I speak out against the Saudis war crimes in Yemen and how I send money to the Yemeni people despite the fact, that as far as I know, they are most Shi'a.
    3) The only Muslims that "don't mean anything special" to anyone are the Uyghur people to you, who you are quick to turn a blind eye to the crimes committed against them.
    What I have been told has been told to me by the Uyghur people, but maybe they are all Western puppets who are want the downfall of China.
    The reality is, I am much more likely to trust the collective "West" than I am to trust the government of China.  The collective "West" has show itself to be far more just and open than the oppressive Chinese government.  When it comes to the collective "West" versus the Chinese government, the Saudis, and the UAE (and Iran), I'm going to take the collective "West"s narrative any day of the week.  Sorry.
    How much do you suppose I need to read and how long did I need to know about the Uyghur people before I am able to call out the hypocritical position of the UAE, Saudi (and Iran) regarding the Uyghur people.  If I told you I learned about the Uyghur people 13 months ago, would that be enough?
    The Uyghur people are getting oppressed on some level (no matter how much you want to deny it) and the UAE, Saudi (and Iran) are all, not only staying quite, but are in fact OPENLY SUPPORTING THE CHINESE GOVERNMENT.  You can justify that to yourself as much as you want, I'm just going to always side with the people against these oppressive governments.  Sorry
×
×
  • Create New...