Jump to content
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!) ×
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!)
In the Name of God بسم الله

humanbeing101

Advanced Member
  • Posts

    740
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    1

Reputation Activity

  1. Like
    humanbeing101 reacted to sefket83 in Knowing which religion is true thru history?   
    No he was not possesed. He was a very pious man and very gifted. I meant that Christian historians find secular historians who wrote this or that in favor of Christianity around the time when Jesus Christ (a.s) lived so they think it is proof for their claims or Muslim historians or what ever. We know that Hitler existed and that Germans faught a war against Russia based on millions of testimonies but it is something else when you only have maybe 100 testimonies and it happened 2000 years ago. I do not know but I have not seen anyone take the possibility of blackmagic or satan influence as a factor. I still think it is possible to know because I think God does not care if we eat pork, have wudu or not rather if we did more good deeds then bad based on our ability is Gods will.
  2. Like
    humanbeing101 reacted to Sirius_Bright in Ghadir was not about caliphate or leadership   
    Your Logic fails at the moment when we realize that Hazrat Moosa (a.s.) didn't left his ummat to decide his successor instead he himself assigned his cousin Haroon (a.s.) for the task by the permission of Allah (swt).
    Hazrat Sulaiman (a.s.) appointed Asif bin Barkhiyah as his successor.
    Hazrat Isa (a.s.) has disciples one after the other.
    And others..
    All these religion (Shariat) were to be abrogated and all these prophets were not as high in position as our Holy Prophet (sawa) still their successors were announced by their respective prophets.
    But Rasoollallah (sawa), being the most elite prophet in status, having his shariat till the day of judgement for the whole world didn't appoint his successor??.....Because your logic says 'mawla means friend'...
  3. Like
    humanbeing101 got a reaction from Hayy ibn Yaqzan in how do you imagine the future of iraq ?   
    @Hayy ibn Yaqzan I agree with your observation. 
    I have to say from my personal experience and obersvations living and travelling in Iraqi and Iranian Kurdistan. I've noticed that even religious Kurds be it Shia or Sunni tend to be secular orientated. Also as you rightly pointed out the Kurdish identity is an ethnic identity. It is true in the past Kurds have never been united under the name "Kurd". However we still have a common culture that gives us that uniting identity. Even though there are 4 or 5 Kurdish major sub-groups: Kurmanji, Sorani, Hewrami, Zazaki, Badhini and Feyli. 
  4. Like
    humanbeing101 reacted to BornShia in Prophet Muhammad Getting Bewitched??   
    1. We reject it.
    2. It goes against the Holy Quran.
    3. A narration has two things:
    Matn: What is the gist of the Hadith, which should agree with the Holy Quran. Sanad: The chain of narrators. Matn takes precedent over Sanad.
    Now, a question for you. Why did the first three Caliph burned their books of Hadiths and issued commands for everyone to do so?
    Why didn't they preserve the Hadiths?
     
  5. Like
    humanbeing101 got a reaction from Hayy ibn Yaqzan in how do you imagine the future of iraq ?   
    @Dhulfikar  The only concern I have is that since Syrian Kurds in Minbij have made advances and liberated the city from ISIS. I fear Turkey is planning a military invasion on Syrian Kurdistan. Although Erdogan in the past has already made threats regarding an invasion on Syrian Kurdistan. I think he fears if the Kurds in Syria are successful, then Turkish Kurds would rise up and revolt.  If you notice the map, the Afrin Kurdish canton is close to connectining to the main Kurdish syrian canton. Turkey won't allow that, since it will ensure it cannot funnel weapons to "moderate" rebels. 
  6. Like
    humanbeing101 got a reaction from Abu Nur in how do you imagine the future of iraq ?   
    I think you are right.
    However to clarify there are around 40 million Kurds, 4 to 6 million of which as Faylis(a Kurdish clan who are predominantly Shia). That makes 10-15% of Kurds shia. I would say Kurdish nationalism in the shia Kurdish areas have made some encroachments over the past few years. I think mainly this is due to unemployment in places like Kirmanshan and Ilam. I myself personally know Kurdish fighters in Peshmerga who are shia Kurds from Kirmanshan and Ilam. 
    Anyway as for relations with Iraqi Kurdistan and Iran, I think it is partially dependant upon Barzani. Barzani is known by the Kurdish opposition groups, namely the PUK to be pro-Turkey. He has had dealings with Erdogan. Though we Kurds aren't all supporters of Barzani, since technically he isn't the legal president anymore as he has extended his mandate unlawfully according to the KRG. 
    Yeh Iraqi Kurdistan will be a secular state, which I prefer. Since there are some Salafis in Iraqi Kurdistan, although Asayish(Kurdish security forces) monitor them. 
  7. Like
    humanbeing101 got a reaction from Hayy ibn Yaqzan in how do you imagine the future of iraq ?   
    I find it quite strange how proponents who are against an independant Kurdish state always claim "It will de-stabilize the MENA".
    Firstly this is a mere hypothesis and there is no evidence to support that. 
    Secondly Iraqi Kurdistan already operates like a mini-state to begin with, it has its own government, its own economy(kirkuk oil), it has its own culture, language and military. It is only not a state on paper. The reality is the Central Iraqi government has little power on the ground to impose its will on the KRG. 
    Thirdly why is it not permissible that Kurds get an independant state when there are 23 Arabic speaking independant nation states and 5 Turkish speaking states. I think it is only fair Kurds be atleast a chance to vote on the issue in a democratic referendum in regards to this matter. 
    Fourthly the middle-east is already destabilized, so it is illogical to make a claim an independant Kurdistan would destabilize it to begin with. I suspect if anything an independant Kurdistan can actually act as a buffer in the region. Peshmerga in Iraq have already been effective against ISIS, along with the YPG forces in Syria. 
  8. Like
    humanbeing101 got a reaction from Hayy ibn Yaqzan in how do you imagine the future of iraq ?   
    I think you are right.
    However to clarify there are around 40 million Kurds, 4 to 6 million of which as Faylis(a Kurdish clan who are predominantly Shia). That makes 10-15% of Kurds shia. I would say Kurdish nationalism in the shia Kurdish areas have made some encroachments over the past few years. I think mainly this is due to unemployment in places like Kirmanshan and Ilam. I myself personally know Kurdish fighters in Peshmerga who are shia Kurds from Kirmanshan and Ilam. 
    Anyway as for relations with Iraqi Kurdistan and Iran, I think it is partially dependant upon Barzani. Barzani is known by the Kurdish opposition groups, namely the PUK to be pro-Turkey. He has had dealings with Erdogan. Though we Kurds aren't all supporters of Barzani, since technically he isn't the legal president anymore as he has extended his mandate unlawfully according to the KRG. 
    Yeh Iraqi Kurdistan will be a secular state, which I prefer. Since there are some Salafis in Iraqi Kurdistan, although Asayish(Kurdish security forces) monitor them. 
  9. Like
    humanbeing101 reacted to Ali al-Abdullah in how do you imagine the future of iraq ?   
    Thats good. And  I don't like Erdogan.
  10. Like
    humanbeing101 got a reaction from Ali al-Abdullah in how do you imagine the future of iraq ?   
    I have yet to see any proof brother that it would. I'm not proposing Kurdistan becomes independant immediately or anytime soon. I'm only really referring to Iraqi Kurdistan, the KRG has no love for ISIS. It will maintain good relations with both Turkey and Iran.
  11. Like
    humanbeing101 reacted to Hayy ibn Yaqzan in how do you imagine the future of iraq ?   
    My friend,
    I think that this comes down to a question of what people decide to do, with their time and energy.
    Ultimately, a country is just a piece of land,
    and a nation is a collection of people and their ideas of how to share what resources they have,
    and a state is what happens when the leaders of communities exert their strength to create some kind of order (could be good, could be bad) over a nation.
    I hope and pray that the violence will stop. I can't say I know that it will.
    I believe that it's more likely that the violence will stop, if people from our generation, and generations to come are able to bridge the gaps between communities, who are carrying anger, and resentment and feelings of hurt, from the past.
    People often use the phrase "Education is most important, because it will save us and give us a good future"-
    The important factor in that is that education is much wider than just academic discipline, it includes travel, understanding different cultures, being able to communicate effectively and critically analyse events.
    I wrote this post in such a rush, please excuse me - there's plenty more to discuss on this matter.
    Keep hope, and may you find peace in your heart and your life,
    for family, friends and faith,
    Insha'Allah.
  12. Like
    humanbeing101 reacted to Haimi in i have been suffering from social anxiety   
    Assalam.
    Like i said in the other thread, it's all because of our mistakes sadly by not praying to Allah or even talking with Allah swt, the answer is very simple:
    الرعد
    الَّذِينَ آمَنُوا وَتَطْمَئِنُّ قُلُوبُهُم بِذِكْرِ اللَّهِ أَلَا بِذِكْرِ اللَّهِ تَطْمَئِنُّ الْقُلُوبُ
    [ The guided ones are: ]Those who    Believe and whose hearts find tranquility And confidence in Allah's    Remembrance.[ O, People ]Be sure That real tranquility for the hearts rests In    Allah's Remembrance,[ regarding    one's Intention and action ](28) 
    الأنفال
    إِنَّمَا الْمُؤْمِنُونَ الَّذِينَ إِذَا ذُكِرَ اللَّهُ وَجِلَتْ قُلُوبُهُمْ وَإِذَا تُلِيَتْ عَلَيْهِمْ آيَاتُهُ زَادَتْهُمْ إِيمَانًا وَعَلَىٰ رَبِّهِمْ يَتَوَكَّلُونَ
    [ The believers are: ]Those who feel awe And trembling in their hearts when Allah's Name is mentioned; and when Words of Revelation are recited to Them, their Faith increases; and they are Those who put all their trust in their Creator and Nurturer;(2) 
  13. Like
    humanbeing101 got a reaction from Faruk in How do shia feel about Attaturk   
    As a Kurd I dislike him strongly, to put it mildy. 
  14. Like
    humanbeing101 reacted to celestial in How do shia feel about Attaturk   
    Stockholm syndrome.
  15. Like
    humanbeing101 reacted to ShiaMan14 in Does Islam accept non trianitarian Chrsitians?   
    I suppose Shias are catching this disease of labeling anyone and everyone kafir as if there is a great big reward for it.
    Unless you are top of the notch A+ Muslim, leave the name-calling alone and concentrate on improving yourself.
  16. Like
    humanbeing101 reacted to Muslimthought97 in Does Islam accept non trianitarian Chrsitians?   
    couldnt have been said better
  17. Like
    humanbeing101 got a reaction from Hayy ibn Yaqzan in Why did Muhammed saw not declare Ali as at Makkah?   
    Why do you engage in passive-aggresiveness? An emotional response automatically gets hold of you in relation to this topic. If you have nothing regarding the actual topic, then personally I would just say nothing. 
  18. Like
    humanbeing101 got a reaction from hasanhh in Introduce yourself here.   
    Salam/Roj bash,
    I am a Kurd and a muslim and just joined shiachat as a resource for shia islam and as a means of understanding certain religious/theological topics. 
  19. Like
    humanbeing101 got a reaction from Raven in [LAWS]Is Music Haram   
    Thank you for the response. Well I don't listen to music that instill negative moral values. Such as encouragement of violence, drugs, sex etc...
    However yes I do listen to western music, but not the "mainstream" type of music.
×
×
  • Create New...