Jump to content
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!) ×
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!)
In the Name of God بسم الله

humanbeing101

Advanced Member
  • Posts

    740
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    1

Reputation Activity

  1. Like
    humanbeing101 got a reaction from Ali.Isa in What does this quote from Imam Ali(AS) mean?   
    thank you brother for the clarification.
  2. Like
    humanbeing101 reacted to Ali.Isa in What does this quote from Imam Ali(AS) mean?   
    I do not care about arguing with you, i just found a good opportunity to present my thoughts regarding this matter for public awareness, and siblings can agree or disagree if my posts has common sense in it.
    This is no excuse enough to not put the arabic text with the english translation, but instead translate the english into arabic. Even if a person has years of experience into translating works from english into arabic and vice versa, and he is spiritually a great scholar, that his translation would be correct of the two hadith you put specially the first one. Because the words Imams use necessary does not mean an expert translator will use. So it is no hadith if translated from english into arabic, as it goes more away from the truth.
    One should ask the scholar that said, in this case the sayed about its source. The Nahjul Balagha is mostly only let us say 99.99 percent authentic hadiths. And the ahadith from Imam Ali Peace upon Him is not only the size of Nahjul Balagha but volumes it would take but all is not authentic-strong source -. If it is not in Nahjul Balagha than it could be in another book. Am not looking too much into it, am just polishing the surface of the ice so it looks shiny and people pay attention to such matters.
  3. Like
    humanbeing101 got a reaction from Ali al-Abdullah in 72 Virgins Shia Hadiths   
    This is the point I'm trying to send across, that some people fail to fathom. Sex on this material world is in two categories. First as a need and a means of reproduction. Second as a means of pleasing your lustful desires(being a want). 
  4. Like
    humanbeing101 got a reaction from Muslim2010 in If Imamat is not Divine   
    @Fahad Sani
    Brother you are once again not providing proof from the Quran of the concept of a 'caliphate'. Instead you've now decided to pin it on a single ayah that isn't clearly defining the concept of a caliphate in regards to "Ulil Amr".
    Do you admit you don't have the quranic ayah to back it up? 
  5. Like
    humanbeing101 reacted to _Fatima in Hadith Of The Day   
    The greatness of what is hidden from us of creation
    "Glory be to you! How great is Your creation that we see! But how small is every greatness when compared to Your power! How awe-striking is what we see from Your kingdom! But how low this is when compared to what is hidden from us by Your authority."
    الإمامُ عليٌّ عليه السلام : سُبحانَكَ ما أعْظَمَ ما نَرى‏ مِن خَلْقِكَ ! وما أصْغَرَ كُلَّ عَظيمةٍ في جَنْبِ قُدْرَتِكَ ! وما أهْوَلَ ما نَرى‏ مِن مَلَكوتِكَ ! وما أحْقَرَ ذلكَ فيما غابَ عَنّا مِن سُلطانِكَ ! وما أسْبَغَ نِعَمَكَ في الدُّنيا ! وما أصْغَرَها في نِعَمِ الآخِرَةِ !
    - Imam Ali [as] - Nahjul Balagha, sermon 109
  6. Like
    humanbeing101 reacted to hasanhh in 72 Virgins Shia Hadiths   
    Let me insert a question --that l thought of a couple of hours ago:
    Do you think there is something as mundane as sex in Jenna or there is something far more emotionally satisfying ---question assumes we are still 'burdened' with emotion in Jenna.
     
  7. Like
    humanbeing101 reacted to uveys in Introduce yourself here.   
    Salams. I'm not Shia, but I believe that Ali and his family were wronged and robbed of their right as successors of Muhammad SAW. I've been Muslim for over a dozen years now. There are some things that make me uncomfortable with your practices and my background as a Sunni, otherwise I'd probably identify myself as a Shia already.  I look forward to learning more about Shia Islam, and becoming more comfortable with it.
  8. Like
    humanbeing101 reacted to habibii-zahra in the miracle of Ali Bin Abi Taleb   
    The miracle of Al-Imam Ali. Indeed he is as what prophet Mohammad said: “I am the city of knowledge and Ali is its gate”… In the early Islamic era ,there was a historical story of two pregnant ladies were
    delivered in the same place, during night, one lady gave birth to a male baby and the
    other gave birth to a female baby and each lady claimed that the male baby was her son
    . They came to omar and asked him to resolve this issue. Omar said there is no one who may resolve it but Al-Imam Ali bin Abi Taleb. They invited Imam Ali to come. Imam Ali said, let us take from the milk of each lady and measuring the weight of it. Thus, they did it. Then Imam Ali said: the Quran says: “Allah commands you as regards your children's ; to the male, a portion equal to that of two females”. Thus, the milk of the lady who gave birth to the male weights double then the lady who gave birth to the female. They measured the weight and then they gave each lady her own baby
  9. Like
    humanbeing101 got a reaction from yusur317 in 72 Virgins Shia Hadiths   
    You never addressed any single point I raised. You decided to latch onto this notion I'm a heretic and declare takfir on me. I never name called you a name or disrespected you, nor will I. Please address my points. 
    It appears the part where I stated there is an immaterial nature to us physical beings went over your head. 
    You also ignored where descriptions of heaven in the Quran are allegorical and used in order for our feable minds to conceptualize heaven and hell. 
    Plus you never provide references of evidence for any claim or statement you make. 
  10. Like
    humanbeing101 got a reaction from yusur317 in 72 Virgins Shia Hadiths   
    Are we physical beings with a metaphysical aspect to us? If you accept this, then it cannot be hard to comprehend the fact our immaterial aspect is the one thing that will trascend. I'm not sure where you get "heretical" from. I never mentioned anything in regards to Plato, you did. Second you are talking about heaven as if you've been there, with such certainty. I'm sure you probably have conceptualized heaven in your head. This is clearly what the Quran aimed to do for the Arabs at the time. Why? Since they had no concept of heaven. Whence the Quran related heaven to the pleasures Arabs were familar with. All the descriptions the Quran provides are allegorical in regards to heaven.
     
  11. Like
    humanbeing101 got a reaction from Son of Placid in 72 Virgins Shia Hadiths   
    You have to remember though the things you state are an entirely materialistic way of thinking. When we die, we will transcend. Not just physically but also metaphysically. We probably won't even think in such terms, because such terms are thought of from negative emotions like lust. 
  12. Like
    humanbeing101 got a reaction from Ali al-Abdullah in [TRASH PIT]Iranian Youth Abandoning Islam by the Millions   
    Firstly there aren't even "millions" of Iranians in the west to begin with. Second most of these irreligious diaspora Iranians are all Shahists/pahlavists. They just hate the Islamic Republic of Iran.
  13. Like
    humanbeing101 got a reaction from Son of Placid in 72 Virgins Shia Hadiths   
    Honestly I don't see why 
    This is because such a notion is a feable way on man's sexual desires and lusts. It is a worldy thing and the reality is heaven is beyond this material world. We cannot comprehend heaven or fathom what is it in, so the quran quantifies it in a human way. 
  14. Like
    humanbeing101 got a reaction from Hameedeh in [TRASH PIT]Iranian Youth Abandoning Islam by the Millions   
    Sister re-read what I said. I didn't say "most iranians" I said 
    I meant specifically in regards to Iranians who are irreligious. Although I agree with you on the rest of your points. 
  15. Like
    humanbeing101 got a reaction from Ali al-Abdullah in 72 Virgins Shia Hadiths   
    There is no contridiction, I will explain as clearly as I can. 
    Firstly to avoid semantics, here is the definition of 'transcend':
    Now when resurrection occurs we our physical bodies are revived. However the day of judgement isn't revolved around your body but the actions of yourself. Your mind(the immaterial aspect of you) is/was responsible for your actions in the material world. Sure the body can lust and hate but you have intellect to act upon and restrain yourself from these things. Whence the my point in saying there is no contridiction in what I stated is a reference to the fact your soul(spirtual aspect) is the thing that transcends in the sense of being the source of reward or punishment.
    This isn't my opinion, this is an islamic stance:
    Can I ask do you concede on the point of allegory in the quran? 
    By the way I do not mean any of this in a rude way, I am sorry if it comes across that way in my writing. I just strongly need to clarify my position and statement in regards to how you percieve them to be.
  16. Like
    humanbeing101 reacted to notme in Astronomy Appreciation Thread   
    @Aladin from Azra tribe does it not seem arrogant to claim to know more than thousands of people who have spent their entire lives studying? Doubt is healthy, but should be presented in a more humble fashion. 
    My personal belief, based on observer accounts, mathematical evidence, and on logic, is that the earth and other planets go around the sun and the moon goes around the earth, but it isn't a tenet of our religion. If it is disproven, my belief in Islam won't be shaken. 
    I'm not a physicist, but find astronomy fascinating, especially the study of objects in our own solar system. 
    Earth is my favorite planet, followed by Jupiter, then Mars, then Saturn (the most beautiful by telescope). Europa is my favorite moon to study, though earth's moon is very dear to me. And Pluto is my favorite named kuiper belt object. I don't have a favorite comet or asteroid. 
  17. Like
    humanbeing101 reacted to Ali al-Abdullah in 72 Virgins Shia Hadiths   
    Wa alaikom. Can you please reference as to where you got this from? As in that its wrong that only our souls will transcend. I myself am not clear on this subject and im trying to find out. But do you have any proof of this? Also maybe we will have new bodies.
    You wrote this: 72 white grapes not 72 wives sufi version of heaven, then you can. The Qur'an is very clear.  And I apologize, maybe I mistook it. So I thought you meant that. My bad. And yes houris are mentioned in the Quran.
  18. Like
    humanbeing101 got a reaction from Ya_isa (as) in 72 Virgins Shia Hadiths   
    I can read inbewteen the lines, you are telling me I'm not a muslim. This literally has nothing to do with resurrection or Barzakh, do not change the topic please. 
    Can you quote me on that? You seem spew things which I made no mention of. 
    What our imams say are here:
    Now to your point about resurrection:
    Now onto my point of allegory in the Quran and in referencing heaven in regards to the quranic description of it:
    As you can see there is no contridiction in what I stated. 
  19. Like
    humanbeing101 reacted to Ali al-Abdullah in 72 Virgins Shia Hadiths   
    @Abu-Jafar Herz Bro what? He never said that only our souls will be Resurrected. Also you keep claiming that this is in the Holy Quran, but you have yet to provide any reference. (i.e we will be 30 years old). Also correct me if I'm wrong, but 72 wives is not mentioned in Quran? I know Houris are, but not "72 wives" as far as I know. Correct me if I'm wrong though.
  20. Like
    humanbeing101 got a reaction from Ali al-Abdullah in 72 Virgins Shia Hadiths   
    You never addressed any single point I raised. You decided to latch onto this notion I'm a heretic and declare takfir on me. I never name called you a name or disrespected you, nor will I. Please address my points. 
    It appears the part where I stated there is an immaterial nature to us physical beings went over your head. 
    You also ignored where descriptions of heaven in the Quran are allegorical and used in order for our feable minds to conceptualize heaven and hell. 
    Plus you never provide references of evidence for any claim or statement you make. 
  21. Like
    humanbeing101 got a reaction from hasanhh in 72 Virgins Shia Hadiths   
    Are we physical beings with a metaphysical aspect to us? If you accept this, then it cannot be hard to comprehend the fact our immaterial aspect is the one thing that will trascend. I'm not sure where you get "heretical" from. I never mentioned anything in regards to Plato, you did. Second you are talking about heaven as if you've been there, with such certainty. I'm sure you probably have conceptualized heaven in your head. This is clearly what the Quran aimed to do for the Arabs at the time. Why? Since they had no concept of heaven. Whence the Quran related heaven to the pleasures Arabs were familar with. All the descriptions the Quran provides are allegorical in regards to heaven.
     
  22. Like
    humanbeing101 reacted to realizm in Palestian views on shias   
    u
    God, this girl in the shop is one clueless girl.
    This video shows one thing, all the people (except one who contradicted his own speech) replied shiites were muslims but had a wrong version of islam. Exactly what you would hear if the poll was done in a shia country about sunnis. Only difference would be that shiites could have more diplomacy, and above all, more arguments since we shias are used to learning and discussing our differences in beliefs. Many of the people asked admitted they did not know much about shiites. 
    A note to the brothers on SC who always depict palestinians as shia-blood-thirsty salafist takfiris...
  23. Like
    humanbeing101 got a reaction from Ali al-Abdullah in 72 Virgins Shia Hadiths   
    Are we physical beings with a metaphysical aspect to us? If you accept this, then it cannot be hard to comprehend the fact our immaterial aspect is the one thing that will trascend. I'm not sure where you get "heretical" from. I never mentioned anything in regards to Plato, you did. Second you are talking about heaven as if you've been there, with such certainty. I'm sure you probably have conceptualized heaven in your head. This is clearly what the Quran aimed to do for the Arabs at the time. Why? Since they had no concept of heaven. Whence the Quran related heaven to the pleasures Arabs were familar with. All the descriptions the Quran provides are allegorical in regards to heaven.
     
  24. Like
    humanbeing101 got a reaction from Ali al-Abdullah in 72 Virgins Shia Hadiths   
    Can you actually back up anything you stated? You don't seem to understand what I said. You're taking an ultra-literalistic approach to the quran. I'm not talking platonic love. I'm talking about lust. There is a clear difference bewteen Lust of 72 unknown women who you want to use for sexual pleasure and love of one woman. 
  25. Like
    humanbeing101 got a reaction from yusur317 in 72 Virgins Shia Hadiths   
    You have to remember though the things you state are an entirely materialistic way of thinking. When we die, we will transcend. Not just physically but also metaphysically. We probably won't even think in such terms, because such terms are thought of from negative emotions like lust. 
×
×
  • Create New...