Jump to content
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!) ×
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!)
In the Name of God بسم الله

_twelver

Advanced Member
  • Posts

    128
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Reputation Activity

  1. Like
    _twelver reacted to Ahlulbayt_110 in Is Ali Beyond Criticism?   
    Personally I believe that Imam Ali (a.s.) is not open to criticism. I may be new to all of this but I know my fair share in Islamic history and Inshallah it is growing. When the Prophet (p.b.u.h) passed away he left behind two things; the Quran and the Ahlulbayt. The Quran is a segment all Muslims follow where as the Ahlulbayt is something not all Muslims seem to keen about. The Ahlulbayt consists of Imam Ali (and other individuals) and there is a hadith that states that one day the Prophet (p.b.u.h) lifted up Ali's hand and said 'Ali is the mawla, of whom I am mawla'. The Prophet himself said that if you believe in him then you must believe in Ali. Jihaad is hating people who hate the family of the prophet-so if you hate Ali then you are hating on the Prophet. I understand that Ali is not an angel or a prophet however he is part of the 'panchtan paak' and after the Prophets death continued to deliever the message of Islam. Sunni's believe in the Sunnah very much so is it not then Sunnah to love Ali?
  2. Like
    _twelver reacted to Abul Hussain Hassani in Debate On Tahrif Al-Quran Between Shia & Sunni   
    (bismillah)
    (salam)
    Agreed! Thank you brothers. Since brother Nader is also active on the other thread about Kamal al-Haydari and Tahrif, this makes him a good candidate. I hope at least one moderator endorse him as it is very important (Why?). 
  3. Like
    _twelver reacted to axiom in Debate On Tahrif Al-Quran Between Shia & Sunni   
    As a layman I am fed up with all these accusations of tahreef and denial of tahreef. I am looking for a rational, respectful debate between learned shias and learned sunnis. I believe Nader is the best candidate for this as he is very knowledgeable and respected figure.
  4. Like
    _twelver reacted to Nader Zaveri in Picking A Marja?   
    (salam)
    (bismillah)
    I do not think you fully comprehended what Macisaac said. What he said is find a place (i.e. Orphanage in Iraq), then email, call, etc. each office of the maraaji` you adhere to, and ask them if you have permission to send your khums there, if they all say yes, then you send it there. And your 400% statement is illogical and impossible for anyone to even follow. I know the system is man-made and highly flawed, but the way you presented it would top the cake.
    (salam)
  5. Like
    _twelver reacted to Al-Hassan in Picking A Marja?   
  6. Like
    _twelver reacted to Nader Zaveri in Kamal Haydari & Tahreef Of Quran   
    (salam)
    (bismillah)
    First off brother, the statement you just made shows your ignorance of Shia Islam, the only "classical scholars" on that list is al-Kulayni and al-Qummi, everybody else is medieval or later scholars. 
     
    I have already discussed in detail why those who affirm al-Kulayni and al-Qummi's belief in tahrif are wrong and they are merely speculating. That is their opinion on the matter, and their opinion is wrong. Just like Sunnis dismiss opinions of scholars because they are wrong, we too, can dismiss opinions of scholars if it is not backed by hard evidential proof.
     
    Regarding Nuri al-Tabarasi, it is the same case al-Kulayni and al-Qummi, there is no statement of him believing in tahrif, rather he is merely narrating hadith that may allude to tahrif.
     
    Regarding Hurr al-`Amili, I have already provided a quote that he denies tahrif, I do not care if a scholar affirms that he believes in it. I have provided you a statement directly from Hurr al-`Amili.
     
    The only person who you have left is al-Majlisi, which I have not denied his belief in tahrif, everybody else either is mere speculation or there are other statements from the same scholars that claim otherwise.
     
     
    Brother, the more and more I read your posts the more and more I am realizing that you do not know how to read and understand Arabic, rather you are simply copying and pasting the Arabic from a Sunni-made article who are cherry-picking the scholars statement. If you can truly understand Arabic as you are apparently trying to claim by Copying&Pasting lengthy articles then I have one request from you. Please provide a word-for-word translation of al-Fayd al-Kashani's introduction where he discusses tahreef and only provide a word for word translation of the part where he says he has "ishkaal" until he affirms that both al-Kulayni and al-Qummi affirm tahreef in their books (which is about a page of Arabic). If you do not do this or purposefully glance over this, then it will be proof that you are not understanding the Arabic of the articles you are copying and pasting and you are simply relying on the author and their understand of Arabic and Shia books.
     
    I ask this, because I know once you fully translate this then you'll realize that al-Fayd al-Kashani never believed in tahrif, which is why al-Nuri attacks al-Kashani for his lack of narrating the hadith of 17,000 verse (from al-Kafi), instead in the nuskh that al-Kashani relies upon from al-Kafi for his al-Wafi has 7,000 verses, instead of 17,000. This should be proof even more that he did not believe in tahrif.  
     
    (salam)
  7. Like
    _twelver got a reaction from TheIslamHistory in Prove Adl' Of Sahaba (Companions) From Quran.   
    Why do you keep trying to change the subject?
  8. Like
    _twelver got a reaction from Haidar :) in The Oppression Of Sayeda Faatima (S.a.) Part Vii-I   
    Invoker in the post where you accused me of being a liar it took you 1 post to translate the Arabic and also give me a reference from mir'at al uqool which is only in Arabic, why is it taking so long now and don't say your teachers busy with ramadhan, the challenge was forwarded around three days ago
  9. Like
    _twelver got a reaction from rafidhi1986 in Peshawar Nights   
    Ive read most of the book however, I stopped because it seems very unreliastic that the Sunni debators never seem to have a reply to the Sayed in question. Also does anyone have the newspaper articlse which were the book before it was compiled? Also are the references given throughout it authentic?
  10. Like
    _twelver reacted to Al-Mufeed in Shia/sunni Videos   
    (bismillah)

    (salam)

    This is a thread to archive various video debates/presentations which aim to clarify Shia beliefs as well as the refutation of commonly held Sunni beliefs.

    This thread is ment for archiving purposes only and not for debate. If one is interested in debate, they may start another thread about the video in question. The thread will be closed to replies. If some one has a video they think should be added to this thread, they should send that video with a brief explanation to me (Al-Mufeed) via the personal messenger feature.


    All videos must be in the english language or have english subtitles.



    1) Imam Ali (as) is the 1st khalifa- Sayyed Kamal Haydari refutes Uthmaan Khamees






    2) The Knowledge of Imam Ali (as) in Saheeh Sunni Hadeeth- Seyyid Kamal Haydari




    3) Imam Ali 1st Khalifa! [Eng] من كان اول خليفة لرسول الله (ص)؟؟




    4) The Prophet (s) and the Heavens grieved for Imam Hussein in Kerbala - Seyyid Kamal Haydari




    5) Who was the Imam of Sayyeda Fatema bint Mohammed (s)?





    6) Karbala and Bani Umayyah by Ayatullah Kamal al-Haidari




    7) The Sunna of Cursing Imam Ali (as) From The Pulpits- Sheikh Zakariyya refuting Uthmaan al-Khamees




    8) 10 Exclusive Virtues of Imam Ali (as) and the hypocrisy of Sheikh Shoa'ib Arnaoot- Sayyed Kamal Haydari




    9) Muawiya ibn Abi Sufyan's hatred for Imam Ali- Seyyid Kamal Haydari





    10) Is Bibi Aisha Siddiqa/Truthful? Kamal Haydari- هل أم المؤمنين عائشة صديقة؟ ا



    11) Killer of Umar VS Killer of Imam Ali according to Ibn Taymiyyah

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ml5R_alxLG8&playnext=1&list=PLak3Ah5hhNNrMF7m0JGDeQHk0YVtJF3w6&feature=results_video

    12) Sheikh Zakariyya refutes Uthmaan Khamees Part 2

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=k_HFmPigovc


    13) Bibi Aisha and her stance to Imam Ali (a.s)- Seyyid Kamal Haydari

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=WWC5YOoIQrE

    14) Khaybar and the 2 caliphs-Kamal Haydari أبو بكر وعمر جَبُنا في معركة خيبر

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JbIeffHGtIw



    15) Bibi Aisha according to the Holy Quran Part 1- Sayyed Kamal Haydari

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=95a8uDCoOcQ



    16) Sheikh Zakariyya refutes Uthmaan Khamees on temporary marriage

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u6RHWXEu2Vs



    17) Umar al-Khattab's knowledge- Sayyed Kamal Haydari

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kLbS0RzvVOI



    18) Banu Umayya and the Ahlulbayt Úáíå ÇáÓáÇã- Sayyed Kamal Haydari كُره بني امية لأهل البيت

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tax3dHFQz10



    19) Imam Ali's words on Aisha - S. Kamal Haidari (ENG SUB)

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1r-Y8abt_c8



    20) Strange Salafi Fatwa | Sayyid Kamal Al-Haydari | Bayt Naqawi

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8JeoNRHwNog 
    21) Is prostrating on soil Bid'a?
     
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F0--VFCcbQg
     
     
     
    22) Refuting Uthmaan Khamees on Hadeeth Kisa
     
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=usTwxnWVOkM
     
     
     
    23) What happened to the Sunnah of the Beloved Prophet (saw)?
     
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PYX9vkHE1Rw
     
     
     
    24) Can the Prophet (s) hear and reply to those who call unto him? 
     
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5M4baQ44Wag
     
     
     
    25) Sheikh Zakariyya exposes Dimashqiyah's lies and deceit. 
     
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EZPbQb3aAJg
  11. Like
    _twelver got a reaction from Invoker in Sunnis Please Explain   
    There isn't an iota of relativity between what is being discussed now and the OP. Thaqalayn thanks for hijacking my thread. If any of you (invoker and muslim720) want a proper discussion, make a new thread and ignore thaqalayn or at least don't let him change subjects so much
  12. Like
    _twelver got a reaction from power in Sunnis Please Explain   
    All jokes aside, I still haven't gotten an answer for my op
  13. Like
    _twelver got a reaction from Thaqalyn in Sunnis Please Explain   
    I would really appreciate if a Sunni (preferably muslim720) could give me their opinion on this, and what is the reasoning for this statement?
    Doubtlessly, it is not lawful to curse or abuse any of the companions, neither cursing and abusing Ali (as) nor uthman or anyone else. SIN OF ONE WHO ABUSES ALI IS LESS THAN THE SIN OF ONE WHO ABUSES ABU BAKR, UMAR, AND UTHMAN. If one is having justification of abusing Ali (as), he is not having justification of abusing Abu Bakr, Umar and Uthman. Soldiers of Muawiyah are not blameable, it is the Shia, because they abuse the first three caliphs, whereas a nasibi only abuses Ali (as)
    Minhajus Sunnatun Nabawiya volume 4 pg 46
  14. Like
    _twelver got a reaction from بعيد in Sunnis Please Explain   
    I would really appreciate if a Sunni (preferably muslim720) could give me their opinion on this, and what is the reasoning for this statement?
    Doubtlessly, it is not lawful to curse or abuse any of the companions, neither cursing and abusing Ali (as) nor uthman or anyone else. SIN OF ONE WHO ABUSES ALI IS LESS THAN THE SIN OF ONE WHO ABUSES ABU BAKR, UMAR, AND UTHMAN. If one is having justification of abusing Ali (as), he is not having justification of abusing Abu Bakr, Umar and Uthman. Soldiers of Muawiyah are not blameable, it is the Shia, because they abuse the first three caliphs, whereas a nasibi only abuses Ali (as)
    Minhajus Sunnatun Nabawiya volume 4 pg 46
  15. Like
    _twelver got a reaction from b4s1t in Sunnis Please Explain   
    I would really appreciate if a Sunni (preferably muslim720) could give me their opinion on this, and what is the reasoning for this statement?
    Doubtlessly, it is not lawful to curse or abuse any of the companions, neither cursing and abusing Ali (as) nor uthman or anyone else. SIN OF ONE WHO ABUSES ALI IS LESS THAN THE SIN OF ONE WHO ABUSES ABU BAKR, UMAR, AND UTHMAN. If one is having justification of abusing Ali (as), he is not having justification of abusing Abu Bakr, Umar and Uthman. Soldiers of Muawiyah are not blameable, it is the Shia, because they abuse the first three caliphs, whereas a nasibi only abuses Ali (as)
    Minhajus Sunnatun Nabawiya volume 4 pg 46
  16. Like
    _twelver got a reaction from GermanShia in Sunnis Please Explain   
    I would really appreciate if a Sunni (preferably muslim720) could give me their opinion on this, and what is the reasoning for this statement?
    Doubtlessly, it is not lawful to curse or abuse any of the companions, neither cursing and abusing Ali (as) nor uthman or anyone else. SIN OF ONE WHO ABUSES ALI IS LESS THAN THE SIN OF ONE WHO ABUSES ABU BAKR, UMAR, AND UTHMAN. If one is having justification of abusing Ali (as), he is not having justification of abusing Abu Bakr, Umar and Uthman. Soldiers of Muawiyah are not blameable, it is the Shia, because they abuse the first three caliphs, whereas a nasibi only abuses Ali (as)
    Minhajus Sunnatun Nabawiya volume 4 pg 46
  17. Like
    _twelver got a reaction from ThE-Samz in One Liners   
    In marriage there are 3 rings:
    *the engagement ring
    *the wedding ring
    *the sufferRing
  18. Like
    _twelver got a reaction from Abu Nur in Sunni Imam Lies On Live Tv [Enjoy]   
    I think I lost some brain cells after watching that :s
  19. Like
    _twelver got a reaction from GreyMatter in Sunni Imam Lies On Live Tv [Enjoy]   
    I think I lost some brain cells after watching that :s
  20. Like
    _twelver got a reaction from Rasul in Sunni Imam Lies On Live Tv [Enjoy]   
    I think I lost some brain cells after watching that :s
  21. Like
    _twelver got a reaction from Grief in Sunni Imam Lies On Live Tv [Enjoy]   
    I think I lost some brain cells after watching that :s
  22. Like
    _twelver got a reaction from Ali_Hussain in My Debate With Farid: Exposing The Lies   
    Muntaqim, you need to stop thinking everyone in the world is out for Shias and stop being arrogant. I don't appreciate your petty accusation
  23. Like
    _twelver got a reaction from Sayyed Ali in My Debate With Farid: Exposing The Lies   
    This would've been the most interesting topic we'd had here for a while, I don't know why anyone would tell brother Wasil to stop.
    Also, Muntaqim Force, I recommend you read the debate over again I've never before seen a "staged" debate where the one staging it loses. The most knowledgeable two here are Dar'ul Islam and Wasil, I'm baffled at what makes everyone think they can attack the latter. Anyway please continue with the topic, it's a great one and I thought it would've been great to have some more light shed on this issue.
  24. Like
    _twelver got a reaction from Muslim2010 in The 14 Righteous Companions Of The Prophet Õáì Çááå Úáíå æÂáå   
    Salaam alaykuum brother, great post! I just wanted to add Allama Murtaza Al-Askari has written a great book regarding Saif ibn Umar at-tamimi and his lies against the Shia where he provides an indepth analysis of the events surrounding the myth of Abdallah ibn Saba and Abdallah ibn Saba himself. To anyone interested, it can be found at shialibrary.org
  25. Like
    _twelver got a reaction from HamzaTR in Online Books?   
    Salaam alaykuum brothers/sisters
    I was wondering if anyone would be kind enough to recommend some free online books and also as I'm new to this website give me a quick walk through as to how it works :)
×
×
  • Create New...