Jump to content
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!) ×
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!)
In the Name of God بسم الله

Ebn Tie me yeah

Advanced Member
  • Content Count

    363
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Reputation Activity

  1. Like
    Ebn Tie me yeah reacted to Aabiss_Shakari in I Finally Picked A Mathaab   
    If Imam Must rebel against the dictatorial rule then i have few questions to Zaidis obviously to Iqra who is representing Zaidis here.
     
    1. Why Imam Ali (a.s) did not rebel against Abu Bakar, Umer or Uthman while Zaidis themselves claim that Ali a.s was Afzal than the three. Why Imam Ali (a.s) did not fight them on this point that i am Afzal and you are mafzool therefore, i must fight you for the caliphate?
     
    2. What is Zaidi stance about those who rebelled against rightful Khilafah of Imam Ali (a.s). If a rightful Imam must rebel against a false and dictatorial rule then what is your position about Aysha and Muawvia who rebelled against Ali a.s a rightful caliph?
     
    3. What is Zaidi stance on the Sulh of Imam Hassan a.s. Why Imam a.s did not rebel against Muawvia (L.A) and entered into peace deal with him?
  2. Like
    Ebn Tie me yeah reacted to The Green Knight in I Finally Picked A Mathaab   
    I am so very disappointed. You could have joined my 3'er Umariism madhhab. It has isnaad to back it and all too. -_-
  3. Like
    Ebn Tie me yeah got a reaction from Modest Muslim in I'm A Sunni Now!   
    Izzudin spoke the truth, the Malaysian Government has outlawed Tashayyu'. Anyone can be arrested and tortured and nobody is going to shed a drop of tear for them.
  4. Like
    Ebn Tie me yeah got a reaction from Robin Hood in Iran Forces Hizbullah To Participate In Syria   
    Thanks to Al-Arabiya for shedding light on the "crimes" of Hezbollah, or rather thanks Saudi Arabia, this country has done great service to Islam, that is why they have all the rights in the world to speak about resistance to Israel :P
  5. Like
    Ebn Tie me yeah reacted to Kirmani in Maulaana Ishaq Madani Has Passed Away   
    Inna Lilah Wa Inna Ilayhi Raajioon
     
    It has come to my attention from various sources that Maulana Ishaq Madani has passed away. For those of you who dont know him he is famous for this clip (among many other lectures)
     
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SiZ-8CgCVDo
     
    He was a sunni scholar, but a very pro-Ahle Bayt and anti-Salafi one. You need to understand urdu to understand that clip but basically he was very pro sunni-shia unity person and he defended shias against all the usual non-sensical accusations (like many in this video). He even explains nicely how shias combine their prayers, the way they pray with their hands down and saying Ali-un Waliullah in Azaan and Kalma is perfectly legitimate and allowed. He even actually used to stress to other sunnis that they could not blame the shias for sending lanaat on people like Abu Bakr and Umar because he admits that ALL THE CRIMES they did are written in their own Sunni books, and how according to their own books Ali A.S was the rightful caliph and how the caliphate was stolen from him. He made so many of these lectures that a lot of insecure salafis/deobandis started calling him a "closet shia" LOL
     
    Though why he chose to still remain a sunni while making all these claims, i guess that's between him and Allah SWT, but he used to speak out very strongly against violence against shias in pakistan, and needless to say he was very anti muawiya (L) and yazid (L). May Allah Forgive his sins and Grant him Janaah
  6. Like
    Ebn Tie me yeah got a reaction from Modest Muslim in I'm A Sunni Now!   
    Izzudin, don't have to be so flashy about your identity. You don't have to display the flag and your location. Stay in this forum and keep learning. Always look out for opportunities to move out of Malaysia.
  7. Like
    Ebn Tie me yeah got a reaction from Muslim2010 in Sunni Hypocrisy And Shia Imamah In Quran   
    I will soon make a thread on Ahlul Sunnah, we need to understand this sect. There are many Neo-Sunnis ie Wahabis claiming to be Sunnis. ASWJ also considered weak ahadith and Hassan narration. The word "authentic" or "sahih" is just misleading. Even if the ahadith have sound Isnad this does not mean that hadith is 100% authentic. The real Sunnis hold all ahadith in the 6 books dearly. Soon this group (ie Wahabis) will claim the only sound narration is from the Quran and all other narrations are not that authentic. Therefore they follow the Sunnah by following ONLY the Quran. Hence they are also Sunnis. We who follow ahadith are deemed mushrik, Sunnism is an evolving sect.
  8. Like
    Ebn Tie me yeah got a reaction from TheIslamHistory in Sunni Hypocrisy And Shia Imamah In Quran   
    I will soon make a thread on Ahlul Sunnah, we need to understand this sect. There are many Neo-Sunnis ie Wahabis claiming to be Sunnis. ASWJ also considered weak ahadith and Hassan narration. The word "authentic" or "sahih" is just misleading. Even if the ahadith have sound Isnad this does not mean that hadith is 100% authentic. The real Sunnis hold all ahadith in the 6 books dearly. Soon this group (ie Wahabis) will claim the only sound narration is from the Quran and all other narrations are not that authentic. Therefore they follow the Sunnah by following ONLY the Quran. Hence they are also Sunnis. We who follow ahadith are deemed mushrik, Sunnism is an evolving sect.
  9. Like
    Ebn Tie me yeah reacted to Rasul in Sunni Hypocrisy And Shia Imamah In Quran   
    Salam,
     
    According to Sunnis: ''It is impossible to understand and act by Quran without Ahadith.'' So, Why do you (Sunni/Salafis) have problem when Shiites are giving you explanations about Imamah from Usool al-Kafi?
     

  10. Like
    Ebn Tie me yeah reacted to Seyedeh in Shia Muslims On Marja   
    Not every one can go and study religion their whole life.
  11. Like
    Ebn Tie me yeah reacted to Wahdat in Chemical Attack In Syria On Arrival Of Un Chemical   
    Oh come on!!!!!!!!!
    You have a track record of retiring all your senses when it comes to Syrian govt Mr. Summer Breeze. 'Oh Syrian govt was itching to use chemical weapons on its people and since UN was in town then what an awesome chance...' I wonder why they chose that specific city? Perhaps maybe the 'Alwaites and Shiites' tossed a coin or something along the line. 
     
    Do you ever get tired of being absurd........time and time over?
     
    Lets both agree that Sunni community are dumb as a donkey when it comes to politics. Case in point- From UBL to Mola One Eyed Omar to Mr. Arror and.... Saddam.
     
    I I trace the aforementioned retarded analysis to Sunni political culture...or lackthereof.
     
    Using Chemical weapons in 21st century does not guarantee victory but defeat. Syrian govt has been through far far far worse and they did not use Chemical weapons...and now that they are on a winning streak...they're like 'what tha hell, lets loose some'.... Mind you, had the Syrian govt consisted of Sunni Islamists then I would have agreed with you on this dumb act 100%. Because stupidity is the MO of the sunni extremists like fsa or alqaida or taliban or alnusra or other retarded terrorist groups.
     
    Its not that they are sweet. Its just that they are wise unlike the retarded gang that they are faced with.
  12. Like
    Ebn Tie me yeah reacted to :Sami II in Chemical Attack In Syria On Arrival Of Un Chemical   
    Here is a hacked e-mail "from a British private defense contractor called Britam Defence."

    Phil

    We’ve got a new offer. 

    It’s about Syria again. 

    Qataris propose an attractive deal and swear that the idea is approved by Washington.

    We’ll have to deliver a CW (chemical weapon) to Homs, a Soviet origin g-shell from Libya similar to those that Assad should have.

    They want us to deploy our Ukrainian personnel that should speak Russian and make a video record.

    Frankly, I don’t think it’s a good idea but the sums proposed are enormous. Your opinion?

    Kind regards

    Dav
     
    http://therearenosunglasses.wordpress.com/2013/08/21/was-the-damascus-gas-attack-this-qatari-false-flag-unfolding-as-reported-in-january/
  13. Like
    Ebn Tie me yeah got a reaction from Muslim2010 in Sunni Hadith For Names Of 12 Caliphs   
    Stick to the topic, where is the 12 Caliphs?
  14. Like
    Ebn Tie me yeah got a reaction from Muslim2010 in 12 Imams Declaring Their Divine Appointment   
    There was no taqiyya on the question of Imamah. The only moment there ever was confusion (due to taqiyya) is during the uprising of Imam Zaid (as). Imam Ja'afar Sadiq (as) being the legitimate Imam and true successor said that Imam Zaid (as) was his Maula to his followers this is due to the fact large numbers of Shii's have defected from Imam Zaid (as) because he failed to do tabarra'.
     
    The general rule is that it was clear who the Imam of the Rafidha was throughout the ages. You can check out the Book Origin and Development of Early Shi'asm by SMM Jafri.
     
    Allow me to quote the state of affairs during the occultation this was taken from Wikipedia:
     
    «The period which gave rise to this confusion began with the caliphate of al-Mu'tamid and continued up to the time of al-Muqtadir. During this time, the agents of the dead Imam persisted in upholding the belief that there existed a son of al-Askari in occultation who would rise when God commands him to do so. The upholders of this belief were under attack from all sides and met with severe opposition. The Abbasids were particularly concerned about the messianic successor of al-Askari in concealment. Al-Mutamid for this reason ordered the house of the Imam to be investigated, and all the rooms were locked after being searched. Efforts were made to find out if the Imam had left a son, and midwives were appointed in the harem of the Imam in order to detect any pregnancy. One of the slave girls was suspected to be pregnant and isolated in a room in a special house where she was kept under surveillance. On one occasion al-Askari's wife (Sayqal, mother of the infant Imam) was imprisoned on refusing to reveal the whereabout of her son. ... This situation continued until the caliphate was caught in the political disturbances caused by the Zanj and provincial leaders in Iran, Egypt and Syria. The Abbasid had also supported Ja'far a brother of al-Askari and claimant to the office of the Imamate in order to create a dispute within the Imam's family. Our sources describe Ja'far as a worldly and pleasure-loving man who in order to become the Imam had used various repressive means in the presence of al-Mu'tamid and more than once has tried to slander those who upheld the Imamate of the infant son of al-Askari in concealment.
     
    The Abbasids were well aware of succession and the masses also know that the Rafidha do have an Imam.
  15. Like
    Ebn Tie me yeah got a reaction from akramabbas in Sunni Hadith For Names Of 12 Caliphs   
    Stick to the topic, where is the 12 Caliphs?
  16. Like
    Ebn Tie me yeah reacted to Kazmi_202 in 12 Imams Declaring Their Divine Appointment   
    Before he refutes Ghadir, he should prove his 'framework' from the Quran and Sunnah.
     
    Where does it state that every divine agent must declare publicly to the masses his appointment for it to be genuine? Where does it state it is forbidden for a Divine Agent to do Taqiyyah? Where in the Quran and Sunnah does it state that a Divinely Appointed leader will never only declare his status to small group of believers due to an unbecoming political climate?
     
    When you prove these above 'assumptions' of yours from the Quran and Sunnah, then you will at least have a valid framework, and not one made up 3 weeks ago to suit your needs lol
  17. Like
  18. Like
    Ebn Tie me yeah got a reaction from Noah- in Nasrallah: Blaming Sunnis For Bombing = Israeli   
    There is seriously something wrong with how Syed Nassrullah thinks, I have a great deal of respect for him but to cast out those Shii's who genuinely believe that Sunnis are responsible for the current mayhem will not help him.
     
    Neither there is any far-sightedness in this regard. 90% or more of the Sunnis have already thrown Hezbollah out of their hearts for supporting the Bathist Regime of Bashar Al-Assad. Now I hear Hizbullat and Hizbul Shaytan. The idea of the so-called Unity of the Ummah has been shattered by the on-going conflict in Syria.  All of Iran's effort on Unity is also been squandered.
     
    The Sunni states and Iran do not have a common foreign policy, so Unity is an illusion which cannot be achieved in the near future. The Wahabis continue to dominate ASWJ and spread terror. They assassinate any real Sunni scholar apposing them, the masses are held hostage under their deviant banner. 
     
    Al-Jazeera reported KSA purchased cluster bombs from USA, KSA was the same country that criticised Syria for using cluster bombs, now will they use it on their local Shii population as a means of collective punishment. This is what I fear, when they start losing the war in Syria, the Wahabis would target any living Shii they can find as means of revenge. They will hold the Shiis hostage (Shiis in Al-Ahsa)  and bargain with Iran and Hezbollah to end their involvement in Syria.   
  19. Like
    Ebn Tie me yeah got a reaction from Muslim2010 in Why Is Hayatul Quloob So Bizarre?   
    Assalamualaikum,
     
    What is bizarre in Hayat ul Quloob? I hope its not because it does not conform with the Nasibi Bukhari's view. 
  20. Like
    Ebn Tie me yeah reacted to akramabbas in Insulting The Companions   
    bro, Imam (as) might have cursed. But the point is our Imam (as) never cursed openly. They only cursed in prayers, dua etc. And the problem of today Shia is they openly curse them which is totally wrong.
  21. Like
    Ebn Tie me yeah reacted to Abdul Qaim in Nasrallah: Blaming Sunnis For Bombing = Israeli   
    I'm sorry to say, but I fear the Sayed is bending over backwards too far this time in the name of wahda. The Sunni world has increasingly become Salified. There are far too few real Sunnah who are willing to label Salafis/Wahabis as being outside of the fold of Tasanoon. Salafism has become mainstream and the Sayed is addressing an ever diminishing minority of "real" Sunnah. Is anyone from the other side listening anymore?
  22. Like
    Ebn Tie me yeah reacted to Ibn-Ahmed Aliyy Herz in 12 Imams Declaring Their Divine Appointment   
    Ugly jinn here is my skype,   Shadi.herz1    , we will have a discussion going into the books and I will post our recorded conversation  here.
     
     
    I honestly don't feel like typing 2 pages to explain to you what has already been explained 1000 times.

    He is asking for public designations for the Imams (as).
     
    Ali (as) was publicly designated by the prophet (as).
     
    Ali publicly designated his son Hassan (as) and is considered by the sunniyya to be the 5th khalifa, so why are you even opening your mouth challenging us when even you accepted him as your publicly announced Imam?
     
    Imam Hussein (as) publicly rebelled and died against a corrupt ruler, you know this and yet you're still asking for proof for hussein (as) wanting to be leader? He lead a revolution against yazeed how dense could you possibly be?
     
    Ali ar ridha (as) was publicly designated by Allah 3zza wa jal by miracles literally converting the masses of the waqifiya into the school of ahlul bayt (as) eventually driving them into extinction.
     
     
    Oh poor ugly jinn  :cry:
     
    He doesn't want to watch a 30 minute video, but he'd rather spend 3 hours a day for 2 weeks writing pages of refutations, lol.
  23. Like
    Ebn Tie me yeah got a reaction from TheIslamHistory in 12 Imams Declaring Their Divine Appointment   
    This argument is still running and I am shocked. Dear Admin, I really like this comment, I was wondering how can I make this my signature?
     
    Considering the fact that this is a brilliant question!
     
    My simple answer Jin, after which I don't want to waste my time replying to your intellectually challenging questions. This is the sort of entertainment you provide to our enemies.
     
    It is an established fact that the masses were well aware who was the Imam of the Rafida and the filthy caliphs whom you hold dearly watched every succession carefully. Please read history don't come here and tell me where can I find the appointment of Imam Hasan Al-Askari (as) from Sahih Bukhari or Quran Kareem.
     
    I ask you sincerely does it even matter whether the Imams made public announcement? When it was made in Ghadir Khum almost everyone was called even the Idols of Quraysh and their daughter to pledge allegiance to Ameer ul Mumineen (as) and even then what happened?
     
    As for the other Aimmah Mutahireen (as), Imam Al-Husayn (as) sacrificed his whole family to pronounce his Imamat, do you accept him as an Imam?  
     
    As of the rest of Imams, do you expect the Abbasi and Ummavis to provide the stage for the Imams to declare their Imamat? 
     
    Uglier Jinn, you only made yourself appear like a fool by asking such rubbish here.
  24. Like
    Ebn Tie me yeah got a reaction from Zaynab McCabe in Fatima And The Door   
    The general problem is that people have this preconceived notion that all Sunni narrations are accurate while all Shii narrations that contradict it are fabrication. Even if that narration was authentic by any standard, it is too controversial to be mentioned by anyone.
     
    Sunnis have rejected many clear cut incidents that happened although it is reported in their most authentic books such as sahih bukhari. The most famous narration is that Syeda Fatima (as) died in the state of anger against the Sheikhyn. Now simple logic will tell you this is not because of Fadak. I even read that the narrator Al-Zuhri did tahrif by adding "anger". I cant believe this!
     
    The Fadak issue was blown out of proportion to distract the people from the other oppressions. For Syeda Fatima (as), Fadak means nothing to them because they are those that Allah (azwajal) is pleased with for their  piety (as mentioned in the Quran).
     
    I have one question which is not disputed by any faction, why did the regime of the Sheikhyn impose such crippling sanctions on the Ahlul Bayt? All their sources of revenue were constrained ie Fadak and Khums? and still the Ahlul Bayt will remain content with the two idols?
     
    Khums was ordained by the Quran and yet the Idols did away with it, I recall reading Al-Farooq by Allama Shibli, the author did his best through logic to justify what the Idols did ie suspending the clear injunction of Allah (azwajal)
     
     
    Despite all these super clear narrations from Imamat to Khums, Sunnis will reject and reject!
  25. Like
    Ebn Tie me yeah got a reaction from Abu Tufayl in Response To Narrator Criticism In Sunni Rijal   
    I know that guy Farid, I was there before until they disabled my account for no reason. That Zindeeq (Ebn Yazeed) said we have only black and white, my reply to him is that your religion has only GREY. Almost everything is unclear, even the character of Yazeed. That guy Ebn Yazeed does takfir of almost every living creature except wahabiya and him.
     
    Message to Farid, we will smash your idols!
×
×
  • Create New...