Jump to content
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!) ×
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!)
In the Name of God بسم الله

Ebn Tie me yeah

Advanced Member
  • Content Count

    363
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Reputation Activity

  1. Like
    Ebn Tie me yeah got a reaction from Syed.Dynasty in Abdullah Ibn Masoud   
    All that discussion above indicate a massive black out of information during the rule of Sheikhyn in particular Hz Umar (ra). His censorship of information made it difficult for us to assess whether Companions were truly content with his rule.
  2. Like
    Ebn Tie me yeah reacted to TheIslamHistory in Ten Promised Paradise   
    (wasalam)
    Simple Question: Is giving Allegiance "Bay'ah" To Abu bakr and Umar" Obligatory according to the Islamic law?
    Answer this, and I will move on to our discussion.
     
    ________________________________________
    (wasalam) 
  3. Like
    Ebn Tie me yeah got a reaction from Muslim2010 in Umar Burnt Narrations At His Time (Authentic)   
    Mr Nader Zaweri has barely challenged the Nawasib on their Nasibi Forum with all that Rijali knowledge. 
  4. Like
    Ebn Tie me yeah reacted to Abu Tufayl in Ayat Al-Wilayah - Tafsir Ibn Abi Hatim   
    (Bismillah)
    In the end, the tool of preferencing that both the Shi'ah and the 'Aammah use is biased, extremely sectarian, and based on the assumption that a particular creed, law, and historical narrative is correct while the others are deviance.
    Anyone who bases their religion on this man-made science and claims it is objective needs to reflect deeply and read more.
    في أمان الله
  5. Like
    Ebn Tie me yeah reacted to Abu Tufayl in Ayat Al-Wilayah - Tafsir Ibn Abi Hatim   
    (bismillah)
     
    By super structure of Nasb I mean the general pattern of weakening the Shi`a and Rawafidh while giving tawtheeq to Nawasib. How they try really hard to filter out Tashayyu` and accuse people and hadith through that avenue while the opposite is largely untrue. Here is a topic related: http://www.shiachat.com/forum/topic/235015707-response-to-narrator-criticism-in-sunni-rijal/
     
    في أمان الله
  6. Like
    Ebn Tie me yeah got a reaction from Muslim2010 in Does The Quran Disrespect The Sahaba?   
    The term sahaba used by the Sunnis dont exist in the Quran and never used by our Prophet (sawa). The term "sahaba" itself is a big biddah. There is only the Prophet (sawa), the Ahlul Bayt, Muhajirun & Ansar. Muhajirun are divided into two groups, one is the early converts who were the cream, the finest early Muslims. Then there was the other group of Muhajirun who were later converts. They however do not include the Makkan pagans who surrendered after the conquest of Makka Mukarrama.
     
    The proto-sunnis decided to include Muawiya, therefore they coined the term Sahaba to include all people who had seen the Prophet (sawa) and believed in him. There is no single hadith to support this definition. The very root of their sahaba world-view is flawed and fault lines run deep endangering the prestige of Islam. 
     
    So called massive Ahlul Sunnah, take a large chunk of their ahadith from people who were not proper companion, they were as young as 18-20 able to narrate thousands of "accurate" ahadith directly from the Prophet (sawa)  after his demise is a great surprise in itself:
     
    1) Abu Huraira (2 years companionship but narrated 5,000 over ahadith)
    2) Anas bin Malik (a servant of our Prophet (sawa) who was barely 20 years)
    3) Ayesha ( an over ambitious wife with political aspiration was merely 20 years) 
    4) ibn Umar (also was in his 20-s)
    5) ibn Abbas (same) 
     
    Apart from ibn Abbas for whom the Shi'as also rely heavily, Ibn Umar is reputed to be accurate in his narrations unlike others. The point is this they were mere teenagers or young adults, the whole of Ahlul Sunnah rests on these individuals. How misleading. What more creating a sahaba worldview which is neither mentioned in the Quran nor Ahadith. 
  7. Like
    Ebn Tie me yeah got a reaction from yafatimaalzahra in Imam Ali Treats Aisha With Respect, And Asks Us To   
    Be mindful what you speak, Ameer ul Mumineen (as) was never pleased with her because she disobeyed the Quran, the Prophet (sallahu alaihi wa aaleh) in a horrific manner, slaughtering thousands of Mumineen in the war of Jamal, what is the punishment for someone causing fasad? isnt it death? 
     
    Imam Ali (as) did not execute that punishment because it will stir more fitna, he was already accused of murdering Usman. This does not mean he did not despise her. Please be mindful.  
  8. Like
    Ebn Tie me yeah got a reaction from yafatimaalzahra in Imam Ali Treats Aisha With Respect, And Asks Us To   
    I agree with you on the filthy words used, it is really unfortunate. I however strongly disagree that you associating her with our Master (sallahu alaihi wa aaleh), i see the signs of batriyya in you? have you forgotten what she did during the burial of Imam Hassan (as)? 
  9. Like
    Ebn Tie me yeah got a reaction from Robin Hood in Imam Ali Treats Aisha With Respect, And Asks Us To   
    Be mindful what you speak, Ameer ul Mumineen (as) was never pleased with her because she disobeyed the Quran, the Prophet (sallahu alaihi wa aaleh) in a horrific manner, slaughtering thousands of Mumineen in the war of Jamal, what is the punishment for someone causing fasad? isnt it death? 
     
    Imam Ali (as) did not execute that punishment because it will stir more fitna, he was already accused of murdering Usman. This does not mean he did not despise her. Please be mindful.  
  10. Like
    Ebn Tie me yeah got a reaction from Robin Hood in Imam Ali Treats Aisha With Respect, And Asks Us To   
    I agree with you on the filthy words used, it is really unfortunate. I however strongly disagree that you associating her with our Master (sallahu alaihi wa aaleh), i see the signs of batriyya in you? have you forgotten what she did during the burial of Imam Hassan (as)? 
  11. Like
    Ebn Tie me yeah got a reaction from Amina in Some Shiites Hate Towards The Sahaba, Why?   
    Oh my o my, this sahaba thing is blown out of proportion, there is a big difference between what we regard as sahaba and those that you regard, even a drunkard is known as sahabi to you, your scholars simply plucked out of thin air, that the sahaba are those who have seen me and believed in me and people of the later generation must follow me, show me atleast one verse from the Quran or Ahadith?
    where is quality of companionship? you people say big things "sahaba" Ahl Sunnah" blah blah but most of the authentic narration rests on 4 individuals, Ayesha, Abu Huraira, Ibn Umar & Anas Malik. So this 4 people represent the entire system of Islam and they are sufficient for the vast 800 million muslims? How many narration from the Shi'a of Ali like Ammar ibn Yassir, Malik Al-Ashtar?
    Or even Miqdad?
    Islam of the 4 people, what a deception, Ahl Sunnah..
  12. Like
    Ebn Tie me yeah got a reaction from Muslim2010 in New Qibla For Shia   
    An emotional statement nothing more! 
  13. Like
    Ebn Tie me yeah got a reaction from Rasul in Refuting Minhaj As-Sunnah (Vol.1) Download Pdf   
    Personally i believe the biggest fatal error in their school is to include Ameer ul Mumineen (as) the forth rightly guided caliph. Ibn Hanbal wanted to buy time in order to keep his school afloat for atleast 1000 years or so
  14. Like
    Ebn Tie me yeah reacted to Qa'im in Do Shia Muslims Consider Ibadis As Part Of Islam?   
    Ibadis are what the historical Khawarij evolved into, and while their beliefs are no where near as extreme as they were at the time of the first 11 Imams (as), they still carry feelings against `Ali (as) that would be considered heretical.
     
    While Shi`a Islam and the Ibadis disagree on the position of `Ali (which is of utmost importance to Shi`as), there are certain things that Ibadis and Shi`as share. Besides the obvious (five daily prayers, fasting Ramadan, performing Hajj), Ibadis hold the following in common with the Shi`a:
     
    Do not believe God is physically visible. Believe that the Qur'an is created. Believe in wilaya and bara'a, but it is practiced differently. They do not say "ameen" in Fatiha They say "hurry to the best action!" in the call to prayer, and they do not say "prayer is better than sleep!" in the morning call to prayer They pray with their arms by their sides Consider that the historical Khawarij were originally followers of `Ali, but they then split from him and began cursing him. Khawarij in Arabic means "those who went out of [something]". The Khawaraj were further subdivided into many groups. They were known for memorization of the Qur'an, impeccable prayer form, praying all night, but not actually studying the meanings of the Book. However, they were brutal, merciless, and they considered other Muslims to be apostates. The group was short-lived, and the much-less-extreme version of it became the Ibadis.
     
    The Wahabis are often compared to the Khawarij, because of their brutality, their sectarianism, their strict adherence to outer parts of the religion and ignorance of the inner parts of the religion, and their closed-mindedness.
  15. Like
    Ebn Tie me yeah got a reaction from PenOfTruth in New Qibla For Shia   
    An emotional statement nothing more! 
  16. Like
    Ebn Tie me yeah got a reaction from Aabiss_Shakari in Imam Hasan   
    Asalamualaikum,
     
    Imam Hassan Al-Mujtaba (as) was already martyred, his burial was done by his brother Imam Hussayn (as) in Jannat Al-Baqi 
  17. Like
    Ebn Tie me yeah got a reaction from Ali-F in Imam Hasan   
    Asalamualaikum,
     
    Imam Hassan Al-Mujtaba (as) was already martyred, his burial was done by his brother Imam Hussayn (as) in Jannat Al-Baqi 
  18. Like
    Ebn Tie me yeah got a reaction from Hasan0404 in Imam Hasan   
    Asalamualaikum,
     
    Imam Hassan Al-Mujtaba (as) was already martyred, his burial was done by his brother Imam Hussayn (as) in Jannat Al-Baqi 
  19. Like
    Ebn Tie me yeah got a reaction from The Green Knight in Did Yazeed Order Imam Hussain (As) To Be Killed?   
    The most inappropriate of things to be brought up in a Shii forum. There is no doubt Yazeed (LA) murdered Imam Hussayn (as). 
     
     He (عليه السلام) said, ‘Three are the worst of creations, which afflicted the best of the creations,1.    Abū Sufyān, he fought the Messenger of Allāh and hated him (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم)2.    Mu`āwiyah, he fought `Alī (عليه السلام) and hated him (عليه السلام)3.    Yazīd b. Mu`āwiyah, may Allāh curse him, he fought al-Ḥusayn b. `Alī (عليه السلام) and hated him until he killed him (عليه السلام)This is taken from Al-Kafi Volume 8. Graded as Hasan, you see Nader Zaweri's page
  20. Like
    Ebn Tie me yeah got a reaction from sayedzeeshan in Did Yazeed Order Imam Hussain (As) To Be Killed?   
    The most inappropriate of things to be brought up in a Shii forum. There is no doubt Yazeed (LA) murdered Imam Hussayn (as). 
     
     He (عليه السلام) said, ‘Three are the worst of creations, which afflicted the best of the creations,1.    Abū Sufyān, he fought the Messenger of Allāh and hated him (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم)2.    Mu`āwiyah, he fought `Alī (عليه السلام) and hated him (عليه السلام)3.    Yazīd b. Mu`āwiyah, may Allāh curse him, he fought al-Ḥusayn b. `Alī (عليه السلام) and hated him until he killed him (عليه السلام)This is taken from Al-Kafi Volume 8. Graded as Hasan, you see Nader Zaweri's page
  21. Like
    Ebn Tie me yeah got a reaction from Abul Hussain Hassani in Order Of The Qur'an   
    This the verse often quoted by contemporary scholars. This is a free standing verse, there is no further explanation provided on how the Quran can be protected. 
     
     
    The contemporary compilation of the Quran that we have now was compiled by fallible individuals, the most popular belief we have now is the fact the current Quran we have dates back to the recession of Caliph Uthman Bin Affan not that of Imam Ali (as). If the current Quran was compiled by Ameer ul Mumineen (as), can this be proven?
     
    In another word, Caliph Uthman bin Affan was divinely inspired and guided by Allah so that Quran is safeguarded.
     
    I know this will be hard for shias to accept but this is the only solution.
  22. Like
    Ebn Tie me yeah got a reaction from Ibn Hashmi in Order Of The Qur'an   
    This the verse often quoted by contemporary scholars. This is a free standing verse, there is no further explanation provided on how the Quran can be protected. 
     
     
    The contemporary compilation of the Quran that we have now was compiled by fallible individuals, the most popular belief we have now is the fact the current Quran we have dates back to the recession of Caliph Uthman Bin Affan not that of Imam Ali (as). If the current Quran was compiled by Ameer ul Mumineen (as), can this be proven?
     
    In another word, Caliph Uthman bin Affan was divinely inspired and guided by Allah so that Quran is safeguarded.
     
    I know this will be hard for shias to accept but this is the only solution.
  23. Like
    Ebn Tie me yeah got a reaction from Waiting for HIM in Order Of The Qur'an   
    There was a question posted on the order of the Quran, his eminence Ayatollah Al-Hakeem replied in the following manner:  
     
    How do I know that the order of revelations (Surahs) in the Quran are in correct order, or legitimate? Where is the proof they are in order beginning with Al-Alaq and so forth?
     
    Answer: We are not certain of the sequence of the verses’ revelations. We are sure of the fact that the Quran is the current contemporary one.
     
     
     
    Only after the zuhoor of Qaim (as), we would able to confirm this issue, Allah knows best
  24. Like
    Ebn Tie me yeah reacted to Basim Ali in Order Of The Qur'an   
    This is the verse: 
     
    إِنَّا نَحْنُ نَزَّلْنَا الذِّكْرَ وَإِنَّا لَهُ لَحَافِظُونَ 
    Surely We have revealed the Reminder and We will most surely be its guardian. [15:9]
     
    I think the verse is open to several interpretations, don't you think? 
  25. Like
    Ebn Tie me yeah reacted to Gypsy in Sunni - Shi'a Converts   
    That's how most of the Sunnis are. They don't really have any rational explanations on why their precious sahabas fought the ahl al-bayt. They can't explain all the wars after the death of the Prophet (pbuh). And they want you to believe that their nobody imams are superior to the Imams of Ahl al-Bayt.
    Thank God you were guided by Allah swt. Clearly you don't belong with them.
    Welcome aboard.
×
×
  • Create New...