Jump to content
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!) ×
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!)
In the Name of God بسم الله

Ebn Tie me yeah

Advanced Member
  • Content Count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Ebn Tie me yeah

  1. @Just the Truth, Why did you spread rumours about me? I am sure you know for a fact that I am not a Quranist and there is a plethora of ahadith concerning Imamat in the Sunni collection. I have in many instances refuted your arguments, my position is very simple there is no clear verse on Imamat in the Quran does that make me Sunni?
  2. Playing the devil's advocate: Dont we have ahadith narrated from ibn Umar? those were sufficient. There are thousands of ahadith from Ayesha bint Abu Bakr. There is one famous hadith narrated by our First Caliph, Abu Bakr that Prophets dont leave any inheritance! That one hadith is sufficient for us to prove his superiority :P :shaytan:
  3. The religion u displayed "Mozlem" does not mean something good in Arabic, it means oppressed
  4. You got a point there, the verse on purification is more metaphoric to imply that they are taken to the next level similar to the Sura of Al-Dhuha It is not to show infallibility. The other side of the verse of purification is that ur implying that they were impure before the purification. Naazubillah Yes, the Quran has many many examples of what you would interpret as minor mistakes and we would call Tark Awliya, literally fallen from grace. There is the story of Prophet Daud (as) repenting and Prophet Adam (as) being chased out of paradise. So you can "play" with these verses to prove
  5. As a general rule, all Muslims regardless of sects are supposed to follow only Ameer ul Mumineen Ali bin Abi Talib (as) after the demise of the Holy Messenger (sawa). Anyone following anything else besides the Quran and Ahlul Bayt are misguided and lost like the Sunnis who formed their own sect based on Sahaba fantasy world
  6. As I told you, please conduct your independent research on to this matter, the reason i dont wish to deliberate further on this because it will affect the unity of the Muslims. You can research on the mushafs of Ibn Masud and Ubay bin Kaab, both of the companions of the Holy Prophet (sawa) were also the Partisans of Ameer ul Mumineen (as). Also do some research into the role of Banu Ummaya in preserving the Quran.
  7. Mushaf Ibn Masud, i dont want to go on any further on this. We will drop it here. You can do your independent research
  8. This verse is not sufficient to establish the concept of Wilayat, Sunnis still deny it. The event of Ghadeer clearly establishes the concept of wilayat and there is no clear Quranic reference to it.
  9. I told you it comes from an enemy of Ameer ul Mumineen (as)
  10. The current version of the Quran is known as the Uthmani Mushaf which we have today.
  11. Out of context. Ali there does not fit in the context of the verse and it should be read literally. Imam Ali (as)'s name is not mentioned specifically ie by name in the Uthmani Mushaf we have today. You can ramble all you want but the fact is simple, his name neither Imamah or any of the shia doctrine is mentioned in Uthmani Mushaf.
  12. That is not the prayers of Ameer ul Mumineen (as). None of the statement made describes your idol. When Umar died, daughter of Abi Khathima wept and said: Ah! Umar! Straightened the crooked; and cured the sick. Mughaira Ibne Shoba said: When Umar was buried, I came to Ali. He had just taken the bath. His head and beard were still wet. He was wrapped in a wide towel. He was sure that Caliphate would reach to him. He said: May God send His mercies on him. Daughter of Abi Khathima spoke the truth. He gained the good and is saved from the evil of the world. By God! She did not say these words
  13. Firstly Najhul Balaghah has many Sunnis in the chain of narration. According to the esteemed Ayatollah Al-Khoei' it is a reference to Salman Al-Farisi (ra) he was a governor of Mada'in in Persia. Yes he is not your Idol Umar. Your sect has mostly white washed the contributions and the merits of Salman Al-Farisi (ra) who has merits far far exceeding that of your Idol Umar. Established whose Sunnah? Sunnah of his own wimps and fancies i suppose. He was instrumental in trampling the laws of Allah . I wish to highlight other of his contributions among which imposing a ban on Mut'ah which was sa
  14. Keshere, I hate repeat myself, you seem to be abusing the platform which is given here in Shia-Chat to spread rumours and what more defending Nasibis like Taliban and Sheikh Osama. Note to Admin: Please remove all these garbage by Zaid Hamid, enough has he fooled the patriotic Pakistanis, ISI has done tremendous damage to Pakistan. Please remove this garbage..
  15. The foundation of the Deen of Muhammad Mustafa Õáì Çááå Úáíå æÂáå (according to the Sunnis) is built on oppressors such as Ubaydullah Ibn Ziyad (la) and Hajjaj bin Yusuf (la). There are many more murderers and blood-thirsty hounds who are known to be strong in Sunnah. Ahl Sunnah Al-Dajjal wa Al-Shaytan
  16. Al-Hajjaj bin Yousuf The narrator of Sahih Muslim and graded as Thiqah according to Sunni Rijal: وقوم من الناصبة المبغضين لعلي رضي الله عنه وأولاده ومهم الحجاج بن يوسف الثقفي A group of Nasibis and haters of Alee (r.a) with him and his children, such as Al-Hajjaj bin Yousuf Al-Thaqafi. Source: Minhaj Al-Sunnah. Vol. 4, Pg. # 554. الأعمش ، قال : " رأيت عبد الرحمن بن أبي ليلى وقد أوقفه الحجاج ، وقال له : العن الكذابين : علي بن أبي طالب , وعبد الله بن الزبير , والمختار بن أبي عبيد , قال : فقال عبد الرحمن : لعن الله الكذابين , ثم ابتدأ ، فقال : علي بن أبي طالب , وعبد الله بن الزبير , والمخت
  17. Such disrespect! May the Curse of Allah be on those who disrespect graves and the grave-digging wahabis!
  18. Assalamualaikum, I found this article by an honest Sunni, May Allah reward him. Please see below the article and the particular emphasis of the 14 Righteous Companions. This article is on Ibn Saba (la) but i find it relevant to point out the 14 Companions. Attacking Two of Most Beloved Companions of the Prophet (PBUH&HF) and Their Disciples Sayf alleged that Ibn Saba is the one who instigated the two prominent companions of the Prophet Muhammad, namely Abu Dhar (RA) and Ammar Ibn Yasir (RA), against Uthman. He said this Jew met Abu Dhar in Damascus, and that he
  19. Brother i have even seen it in Shia books, so leave him alone.lol
  20. I never knew men also break promises. If he truly loved you, a man will not abandon his lover, i dont need to teach you, there are wholesome Bollywood movies to watch. So i advise you to remove the family name "abidi", the shias of the sub-continent are very strange with very shallow mind, they are fanatical about being Syed or Abidi, Zaidi,Jafri, Kazmi,Rizvi and Naqvi. If you see any family names with those i have shown you, please avoid them. Most of them do not even perform Namaz but busy themselves with Majalis during Muharram. Muslim only in name. They are proud to be known Syed
  21. Why arent they not from ashab ul ijma, Abu Hamza Al-Thumayl and even Aban bin Taghlib were both very senior companions from the time of Imam Sajjad (as). Any particular reason? I also wanted to know the stance of Abu Hamza Al-Thumayli and Momin Taq with regard to Imam Zayd (as)? I heard there was a debate with Momin Taq. I read that Abu Hamza Al-Thumayli's children all fought under the banner of Imam Zayd (as), is this true and why did he send his children to fight where else Momin Taq did not fight.
  22. Among the Ashab ul Ijma, you missed : Abu Hamza Al-Thumayli, How about Momin Taq?
  23. I cant find the Quranic verse you quoted which states that Prophet (sawa) was the warner and guide? When we produce authentic narration as per your standards, you hit around the bush. Imam Ali (as) is the shepherd of the Ummah, if you choose to ignore him then this is what our Prophet (sawa) has to say: Tibrani writes from Al-Matlab bin Abdullah Ibn Hantab from his father. He says that I heard the Holy Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) announce at Johfa: “Am I not more superior to you than yourselves?” The people replied: Yes, O Messenger of Allah! The Prophet then said: “I wil
  24. We are talking about the Chief of the Women in Paradise, hope people in your sect know that it is not Ayesha. According to Imam Malik, Syeda Kainat Fatima Al-Zahra Siddiqa (as) has the highest place in the sight of Allah after our Messenger (sawa).
  • Create New...