Jump to content
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!) ×
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!)
In the Name of God بسم الله


  • Posts

  • Joined

  • Last visited

About Link

Contact Methods

  • Website URL

Profile Information

  • Location
    Ottawa, Canada

Previous Fields

  • Gender

Recent Profile Visitors

4,625 profile views
  1. salam, salawat bar

    Mohammad wa Aalay Mohammad

    may Allah bless you on your birthday

  2. Sallam Alaykum

    beautifull poem Mashallah

    must say really touched me Jazakallah for Sharing Iltemase Dua


  3. lol no prob bro... Tell me an objections you have if any...
  4. (salam) Bro, this is what my first post was about... And the translation is wrong, it left out "fa"... The two ways of reading "fa" is "then (ie. in doing this) if you differ.." or "therefore (ie. in complying to this) if you differ" I went through why it's the latter and why Ulil-Amri (as) are not repeated. wa salam
  5. Thanks for the addition... From Yusuf Ali: "you. If ye differ " The word "Fa" is missing... This is the problem, "fa" is the factor, is it "therefore" as in "in obeying Allah and obeying the Messenger and Ulil Amri from you" , you should as a result of complying to this, when you differ.. or is like "then (in doing this) if you differ".... the two ways of reading "fa" makes you reach different conclusions. I also would like to mention, that there is two obedience commands, and hence that supports the fact Ulil-Amri (as) are Ma'asoom as well... We see else where in Quran, Prophetic authority vs Misguided Leaders is discussed...
  6. (salam) 2 possibilities to consider 1) Kuli Shayan if referrring to existence (light) rather non-existence (rijs/darkness) then can be seen in light of "given from all things" and ayat tatheer would confirm that the Imamal Mobeen has all existence in universe encompassed in him and he is deprived of only Rijs (darkness/non-existence). 2) It can also refer to the to the fact he witnesses and perceives the whole universe malakut. Another "twelve" coincidence is verse Twelve mentions twelve Naqeebs in Suratal Maeeda 5:12...and we rose from them Twelve Chiefs...
  7. Jazakallah... I think this Surah is really important for the materialistic societies today...to recall the holy families regard for oppressed and there utmost disregard for world and self... Perhaps the most emphasized example of Ahlulbayt (as) (and see 5:55) is there regards for the oppressed... Mohammad (pbuh) came to free the oppressed of the world just as Musa (as) came to free the oppressed Bani-Israel.
  8. (salam) No problem bro... The intention was for people to benefit so alhamdulilah Allah (swt) made you benefit... inshallah Allah (swt) increases you in knowledge through out your life and brings you closer to Him and Ahlulbayt (as). And thanks as well, I've benefit from your posts and topics as well. May Allah (swt) spread the whole Deen of Haq till blessed generations are raised upon the truth from birth to death and do not have to go through the deception the world is in today... wa salam
  9. (salam) bro :) Maybe they want to talk about Abrogation like Efendi did... This is the last life line they have as far as I can tell. And inshallah calmly and with wisdom, we will show the fallacy in that view... (which is quite obvious if just thought about). And besides that, there is other arguments you brought forth, like the fact wage is for the message, and to disbelievers it would mean the wage they owe if accepting, not that an wage can be expected while rejecting. And also the notion all Mohammad (pbuh) asks from them is that, is false, since he was asking a whole lot more then that...in fact, the sentence makes no sense, even with the brackets and after brackets added... That and the other wage verses.... Inshallah they will admit the truth that Family of Mohammad (pbuh) are the way to Allah (swt). wa salam
  10. (salam) Farid, do you agree at least the following verse: Have they feet with which they walk, or have they hands with which they hold, or have they eyes with which they see, or have they ears with which they hear? Say: Call your associates, then make a struggle (to prevail) against me and give me no respite." (7:195) Contradicts the view that Mohammad (pbuh) was asking Disbelievers and Mushriks of Quraysh "not make a struggle against him" and "give him respite" while this verse says "then make a struggle against me and give me no respite" (same thing Nuh (as) said) Forgetting the wage verses, at least, do you agree that it contradicts that hadith stating that is the view of Ibn Abbas (ra)? MohammadMufti, same thing, at least do you agree that it contradicts that hadith and your scholars overlooked this verse that refutes that?
  11. (salam) In talking about Politically Rising against oppressors and defeating the arrogant disbelievers and raising the Truth.... Suratal AUli-Imran in midst of that mentions 1) Authority is Granted by God, just as Honor is (the Light by which proves Authority). 2) Politically Authority of Mohammad (pbuh) (at that time) stems from people who love God over world. 3) Then Talks about Chosen Families and Yahya (as) being a Leader/Master and also about Isa (as) and Mariam (as)..which along with hinting Chosen family Mohammad (pbuh) is part of... Shows like the Talut (as) verse, the Chosen Families brought out for the sake of mankind political authority stems simply from the fact they are God's Beloved and Chosen ones and following them is following God... Clining to them is clinging to God.. Obeying them is obeying God... As all these blessed chosen group of souls, brought out for mankind, who are all offspring connected to a blessed Tree of chosen ones.. command towards Justice and Goodnness (as other Surahs emphasize on)... Then they are Political Leaders since the commanding towards good is political and Spiritual as well....they are True kings "and we made you Kings"... So this concept of "Political" vs "Spiritual/Religious" Leadership is just a product of Umma sinking in falsehood... Quran introduces Political authority of Mohammad (pbuh) by Spiritual Authority "If you Love Allah, then follow me"... as obeying him is obeying God as is in the case of all chosen ones, like the Family of Imran (as) including Isa (as)... So this Non-Political understanding of Prophets (as) Leadership has to go away, since, they all came telling people to obey them and not obey the Misguiding Leaders... Isa (as) in the speech we have specifically talked about overthrowing Tyrants... And Yahya (as), the Cousin of Isa (as), who prepared people for Isa (as), was martyred for his stead fast political Leadership against the Tyrant of that time... So where is this split of Imamate coming from...? Even if it was split before, it was combined as one in the seal and perfect Nubuwa of Mohammad (saw). Waliyal Amr (as) guides spiritually and politically as the politic attitude of a believer is related to his spirituality....
  12. (salam) Sorry I deleted the post... Yes first it was about rejectors of Zaid (qas) (whom people hated) and then it was translated that all those who rejected Abu Baker and Umar..
  13. (salam) The propaganda spreads and is accepted because people want to accept it without proper investigation.... It makes them feel better about themselves when they hear bad stuff about the people who actually rose for Islam and Quran while their people are focused on the Idol known as "Dunya". Here in Canada, an injustice is found about a Muslim, and the government is forced to compensate and admit mistakes because the people do not tolerate injustice to it's citizens. Investigation is commanded and truths are brought out... Arab countries, people go to jail with no reason, and people remain focused on their own lives, hardly caring about their own people. Huge apathy amongst the people... There is no Justice and want to seek it... Saudi Arabia Government and officials commited a huge crime, but to make oneself feel better, people rather believe the Iranian Shias are to be blame...rather then holding their government accountable... In Canada, one crime to one Muslim, and the people won't tolerate but to hear the truth and want compensation... This is the problem with the Umma, they are so use to injustice, and do not value rising for justice at all... that they will accept what they want to hear rather then firmly wishing to know the truth and standing for the truth and justice.. Nawasib cannot be expected but to this propaganda.... Sunni Scholars and Leaders are the ones who should inform the people of the false propaganda and put out the Fitna...
  14. (salam) The attitude of Ahlulbayt (as) was to look up the current situation and act towards the current Enemies..... When the usurpation happened, Ali (as) and Fatima (as), especially Fatima (as), strove for the rights... but when Ali (as) saw that the people were bent against him and only the Mutaqeen, who were his followers, would rise, he spared them that and saw more wisdom in patience and was against Fitna Sufyan wanted and kept to unity, and then helped the Umma and did not cause division. Here is lesson we ought to learn from Ahlulbayt (as) on how to look towards the current enemies instead of the past (which does nothing, it's the current armies of Satan that harm Islam that we can do something against): One of Amir al-mu'minin's (as) companions (from Banu Asad) asked him: "How was it that your tribe (Quraysh) deprived you of this position (Caliphate) although you deserved it most." Then in reply he said: O' brother of Banu Asad! Your girth is loose and you have put it on the wrong way. Nevertheless you enjoy in-law kinship and also the right to ask, and since you have asked, listen. As regards the oppression against us in this matter although we were the highest as regards descent and the strongest in relationship with the Messenger of Allah. It was a selfish act over which the hearts of people became greedy, although some people did not care for it. The Arbiter is Allah and to Him is the return on the Day of judgement. "Now leave this story of devastation about which there is hue and cry all round." (1) Come and look at the son of Abu Sufyan (Mu`awiyah). Time has made me laugh after weeping. No wonder, by Allah; what is this affair which surpasses all wonder and which has increased wrongfulness. These people have tried to put out the flame of Allah's light from His lamp and to close His fountain from its source. They mixed epidemic-producing water between me and themselves. If the trying hardships were removed from among us, I would take them on the course of truthfulness otherwise: "... So let not thy self go (in vain) in grief for them; verily Allah knoweth all that they do." (Qur'an, 35:8) This is telling us ""Now leave this story of devastation about which there is hue and cry all round." and come look at "current enemies of Islam". The recalling of Aushura is not to recall the event simply but it's attitude towards all Oppressors...by which Ummayads were defeated and inshallah all justice will spread from recalling of Hussain (as) and his Companions (may peace be upon them all). Imam Hussain (as) is Leading the battle against all oppressors and it's not simply fighting Yazeed. I do not mean by this we should not recall the past, but recalling of past should be to apply to today, not to get caught up about it. Ameeral Momineen (as) is saying, leave that talk, look at Mauwiya, the judgement belongs to God, some people were selfish, and others were apathetic, but now look at Mauwiya and leave the talk which is of no use today. I see use in proving Ahlulbayt (as), I do not see use in constantly pointing out "crimes" of the heroes of Sunnis and causing enmity. The Sermon 3 does not contradict this attitude, because it was one time shout, while his constant attitude was clearly to focus on the current situation and even sermon 3, he linked it to the current situation, of people rebelling... We have enemies today working to destroy Islam... To divide the Umma further and cause wars in the region, further split the countries and bring down the Shariah.... "Now leave this story of devastation about which there is hue and cry all round." (1) Come and look at the son of Abu Sufyan (Mu`awiyah). Does it not mean to us, "leave this story of devastion" (as don't focus on it) "come and look" at them, who work to destroy Islam, and focus on them....?
  • Create New...