so these ahadith are fabricated because? your scholars say they are? my scholars say they arent. why are your scholars right and mine wrong?
no. read my last response again. i already responded to this exact claim.
yes i know that.
i am not doubting anything. nor am i saying that his killer was on haqq. i am saying i dont know what happened. the details.
but just to be clear, on an unrelated topic, i do not believe the progeny of the prophet pbuh was infallible, not even the ahl e kisa, despite what you extract from 33:33.