Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
teenager

why is catfish haram?

Rate this topic

Recommended Posts

salam,

i have a question concerning halal food.

i have never eaten catfish, because my parents have said it to be haram and that we can only eat fish with scales. i asked them why it is haram, and they said that they do not know for sure, but it has something to do with the catfish eats junk from the bottom of the sea, as compared to fish with scales that make thier own food. i then asked what if the catfish was raised on a fish farm, and was given nutrients and special food? they told me that the food catfish eat is not the only reason, but they do not know exactly what the others reasons are.

so my question is why is it haram to eat catfish other than that it eats junk off the bottom of the sea?

please reply!

ws

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

(salam)

Because they do NOT have scales.

In order for fish to become permissible for a Muslim, it must have the following conditions:

(a) The fish must have scales on it. [That is, it should not be a skin fish.]

(b ) The Muslim should be certain or satisfied that the fish has come out of the water alive or that it died while it was already in the fishing net.

Also from Resala of Sayyid Seestani

Some experts of fisheries say that scaleless fish mostly feed upon the waste of the sea and are in a way purifier of the filth, the squalor and the garbage of the sea.

ws

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

salam,

so, the reasoning is that fish without scales eats junk. i know i am being a little to insistant, but what if the fish did not eat junk and it came out of the water alive? is it halal now?

i am trying to understand, even though i am very likely to never eat catfish in my lifetime. i think that if the only reasoning for a rule becomes null and void, then the law loses its credability. its logic, if there is a law that one should not drink beer because it has alchohol, and there is beer that has no alchohol, then the rule banning beer should be limited to alchoholic beer because that is the reasoning of the rule in the first place.

since fish without scales normally eat junk, thus making the meat filthy, then the fish should not be eaten. if a fish without scales does not eat junk, but rather nutrients, then the fish can be eaten. that is the logic i applied.

now, my question is if there is any OTHER conditions that a fish must have to be permissable to eat, other than the ones listed.

i am also asking for the exact reasoning behind the law pertaining to why fish with scales are haram, and if this reasoning becomes null and void, then does the law become null and void?

ws

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
is there any scientific reason or is the reason purely religious?

that is another question worth asking. the scientific reason would have logical reasoning, and the religious reason should be supported by the scientific reason and the religious element of why.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

A similiar arguement was directed to me to when i was working in corporate america. They used to make fun of how i wouldnt eat the other white meat (Pork), So i told them its a dirty animal so i dont eat/touch it. In their defense they replied that in this era these pigs are raised in clean envoirnment with proper food, So now what? My opinion is that you cant change the nature of the beast..

Like the saying goes

You can take the kid out of the trailer park but you cant take the trailer park out of the kid.

Hope i am making sense. As a sport fisherman i was wondering why would you want catfish anyway? they are so hideous looking that i everytime i would take a bite it would remind me of them whiskers yuck. I would suggest try either red snapper or mackerel.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

(salam)

is there any scientific reason or is the reason purely religious?

Well logical reason is to protect the health of the consumer. Scientifically it is known today that fish without scales are said to feed on the waste at the bottom of the sea. They are usually known as Bottom-feeders and feed on anything from algae to insects to worms. For this reason they may pose a harm to the humans eating them. Therefore they are forbidden to eat.

As for eating dead fish or any dead meat, well that's again for the purpose of protecting humans. For example you can never be sure how the fish died, naturally or because of poisoning by chemicals in the water or something. Dead meat may cause many diseases because of germs etc that may not be destroyed by roasting or other cooking methods, that will in turn pose a threat to your health as well.

Just some of the reasons that i could think of right now.

ws :)

Edited by kanez-e-Zahra

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

(salam)

so, the reasoning is that fish without scales eats junk. i know i am being a little to insistant, but what if the fish did not eat junk and it came out of the water alive? is it halal now?

This is one of the reasons that is known (maybe there are other reasons that i'm not aware of). I believe that this in itself is a recent discovery…….Allah (JJ) is the All Knowing and his Laws are without flaws. For all we know there may be other solid reasons for this prohibition, so I would say that what is prohibited will remain prohibited. Even if they are grown in another environment you still cannot change the characteristics of that fish. There are specific hadith were the Holy Prophet pbuh and Ayimma (as) have said clearly that fish without scales should not be consumed.

Muhammad bin Muslim asked Imam Jaffer Al-Sadiq (as) about a fish that has no

scales to which the Imam(AS) replied: " Eat of the fishes that have scales

and do not eat of the fishes that have no scales"

(Fiqh Al-Imam Jaffer Al-Sadiq by Jawad Mughniya Vol 4 Pg 368)

ws :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest Peace

(bismillah)

(salam)

God prohibits what must be prohibited. None of his limits are stupid or vain. We might not understand why but it is enough that he is The Wise, The All-Knowing and The Merciful. He is too generous to impose on us anything that was not beneficial for us.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Assalamu alaykum,

Apparently the fish without scales have a higher level of mercury in their body which can affect the human health (its deadly). Also shell fish which are haram such as Oyster, Lobster etc etc have a higher level of mercury..

Just because we dont have the answers why they are haram, an answer will pop out scientifically sooner or later, everything that is Halal and Haram for us is made that way because its the best for our bodies.

I used to question the reason why our Holy Imams (as) recommended us to eat a pomegranite every friday or atleast every 40 days if we couldnt every Friday. Subhan'Allah on Wednesday I was reading the newspaper and I read that scientist have just found out that eating a pomegranite can reduce heart disease and cholesterol in the body.

Our Holy Imam's (as) mightve recommended certain actions without giving an explenation. But there are good reasons behind them.

Such as why it is recommended to sleep on your back or on your right hand side, and Not to sleep on your Left side or on your stomach.

wa alaykum assalam

Khoder.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest abaleada
Assalamu alaykum,

Apparently the fish without scales have a higher level of mercury in their body which can affect the human health (its deadly).

(bismillah)

(salam)

They wouldn't if we didn't have coal-burning electricity factories dumping high amounts of mercury into lakes and streams nearby 56% of the population of the US. Most of the affected population are poor and minority or indigenous. Turn off the light if you don't need it, get solar panels, and push your elected (and selected) leaders to fund windmills for energy.

KPFT News of KPFT 90.1 FM Houston 89.5 Galveston http://www.kpft.org interviewed some of those poor minority people in Houston. When one man was asked about whether those mercury-ridden fish had caused any ill effects in his neighbourhood, the man broke into sobs and described how many children had tumors and neurological birth defects, and how many people had been affected with mental disabilities and cancers because of corporate pollution.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thought people might find this interesting. Fish without scales were prohibited to the Bani Israel too:

Leviticus 11:9 These you may eat, of all that are in the waters. Everything in the waters that has fins and scales, whether in the seas or in the rivers, you may eat. 10 But anything in the seas or the rivers that has not fins and scales, of the swarming creatures in the waters and of the living creatures that are in the waters, is an abomination to you. 11 They shall remain an abomination to you; of their flesh you shall not eat, and their carcasses you shall have in abomination. 12 Everything in the waters that has not fins and scales is an abomination to you.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

salam,

THANK YOU, EVERYONE!

i am exceptionally satisfied with many of the replies i recieved. i learned many things that i had not know before, like that mercury content differentiates between fish with scales and fish without scales.

thank you again!

ws

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

one of my fav pre-conversion days sea food was crabs......

I love crabs... esp the way my grandma makes em... unfortunately i cant have em now..... *sigh*

btw i dont eat pork... never did either... even before changing... just looking at that 3inch thick slab of fat makes me sick... and being a goan (goan = guy from goa india) pork is a part of life there... so you can imagine how my grandma felt when i said "eeewww!!!"

btw isnt mackerel also without scales????

Ali

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest Eilis

salaam...

just a few notes...

modern pig farms are filthy... a health hazard to anyone that works there, and an environmental nightmare (so there goes that argument!).

jews eat catfish at passover (the gilfiltefish is often made out of catfish).

Q. what's the difference between a lawyer and a catfish?

A. one's a scum sucking bottom-dweller, and the other one's a fish! (my apologies to any good honest muslim lawyers out there... this one was for your typical western money stealing lawyer!)

Eilis

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
one of my fav pre-conversion days sea food was crabs......

I love crabs... esp the way my grandma makes em... unfortunately i cant have em now..... *sigh*

btw i dont eat pork... never did either... even before changing... just looking at that 3inch thick slab of fat makes me sick... and being a goan (goan = guy from goa india) pork is a part of life there... so you can imagine how my grandma felt when i said "eeewww!!!"

btw isnt mackerel also without scales????

Ali

(salam)

Bro Ali I love crabs too :cry:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This is da chinese myth

Their was a cat and she met a fish in a pond/lake/ocean *watevr*...and dey fell in love...the cat went in da water and started hanging around with the fish...and over time da cat started to adapt to the water..and den u knwo dey had kids blah blah and den da CAT FISH was made

haha

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
(salam)
btw isnt mackerel also without scales????

Yes seems that mackerels do not have scales, therefore they are not permissible to eat.

ws :)

Salaam alaikum,

Mackerels do have scales, just not on their heads. Their bodies are covered with small scales.

http://cnet.windsor.ns.ca/Environment/Advo...m/mackerel.html

They are halal to eat. A fish doesn't have to be completely covered in scales to be allowed.

Sayyid Khamene'i

Question: Our today's question is about the definition for fish to be halal. What are the criteria for a fish, that it can be accepted as halal. Can you give us a complete definition. As we know one of the criteria is, that a fish should have fish scale. Therefor our questions in this regard:

1. Are there also other criteria as precondition, that a fish is halal for meal?

2. Is the precondition to have scale a scientific one or based on the opinion of people?

3. How many scale should a fish have, that it is accepted as halal?

4. Is it acceptable, that a fish has only scale on one body side but no one on the other side, as it is described for example for the fish called plaice We would be very happy, if you could enlighten us in this regard.

Answer: Bismihi Ta`ala

1. There is no other condition but to get it out of water alive i.e. to die outside the water.

2. The recognition of this matter is the responsibility of the mukallaf (person bound by religious obligations) even with referring to the expert people or to the `urf (common view).

3. There is no certain number for the scales. However, it should be said that it has scales according to `urf. It suffice that the fish is originally a scaled one even if all its scales had disappeared later. Like a kind of fishes which rubs its body against every thing and its scales fall away and when one looks near its ears, he may see some of them.

4. The ruling is made clear in the above answer.

WaSalaam, Hajar

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

(salam)

Really :unsure: Does it depend on what species of mackerel it is coz I was told that they don’t have scales. Hmmm……looked around the net and seems for some species of mackerel it is conditional i.e. some may have small scales while others may not.

http://www.fact-index.com/m/ma/mackerel.html

The scales are extremely small, if present.

This site says:

http://www.havbruk.no/fishlist/makrel.html

Mackerel does not have a swim bladder, which makes it difficult to register on fish finding equiment. Nor does it have scales, so it is difficult to register its age.

Have they made a generalisation because not all of it's body is covered with scales or the scales are so tiny that it can't be seen?? ... :unsure:

Thanks for the rulings and clarification.

ws

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

(salam)

It could be that the ones they catch in countries, other than the US and Canada are a different variety. Or their scales could be so small, that some don't consider them scales.

WaSalaam, Hajar

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

Sign in to follow this  

  • Recent Posts on ShiaChat!

    • https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=10&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=0ahUKEwjKjJuLttTXAhXNI1AKHbmwCnkQFghbMAk&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.slideshare.net%2Fhuseinmhanna%2Fthe-structure-of-the-universe&usg=AOvVaw1u9CB07-W2u5JxwR-e2HWP http://qfatima.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/tawheed.pdf
    • Feminists typically use terms like "male-dominated culture" so I just wanted to ask if you are a feminist. Also patriarchy is not inherently bad. No matter how you look at it Islam promotes a form of a patriarchal society. So just so you know. However I am not defending the patriarchy of Desi culture. Which is what we are talking about. I am advocating the patriarchy of an Ideal Shia Islamic social society (Yes these have existed historically to various extents).    Also I have seen housewives who can cook a mean paratta and clean well and still they are degraded by not only other women but by men, who tend to gravitate towards free-loving women. They are not appreciated by men as well. I am talking of the West, so I will let others respond on how accurate your statements are about the east. Something tells me you are still projecting and exaggerating.    Again, when you use the word "men" you are referring to a specific type of men. So don't generalize like the OP did. Also modesty is also a concern as well. I have seen this and I can give anecdotes as well to prove this. But let us not play the anecdote game. You would be surprised what western Muslim women, especially in college, get up to. So let us not pretend Muslim women are angels. Remember, for every Muslims man who fornicates there is often times another Muslim woman willing to do it with them. So don't think it is a "guy" issue, it is also a gal issue as well. Also there may be more reasons than the ones you and I listed too as to why an eastern man wants to marry a western woman, but it has everything to do with the guy trying to "make-up" for his guilty conscious and it may manifest in ways such as he thinking he can make it up by having his wife cook and clean (in a weird and twisted way, after all humans are psychologically complex creatures). But your cynical explanation makes it sound is as if Muslimah are dainty little flowers who earn money through a job and when they get married their hubby goes all Hollywood mustache twirling villain on them, or goes Ape on them out of nowhere. This is an incredibly naive and biased analysis and only ends up creating more questions rather than answering them.     Also you just answered your question. Replace men with "cultural Desi men". But you saying "men" is generalizing and I can also name "hundreds of examples" that run counter to yours. As can anyone here. No one here is defending Desi (primarily hindu influenced culture). But you seem to think we are.   On a tangential note Muslims nowadays are willing to blame Islam rather than Hindus for the defiencies that are present in Desi culture. Despite the fact that most of the deleterious behaviors of Desi culture had its origins in ancient Hindu culture that ancient Muslims picked up on. "Purdah" is a famous example of something that quite likely originated amongst  and was widely propagated  by Hindu culture and that Muslims adopted as well but tend to confuse with Islam in incorrect ways (the state of the prophets wives was not the same of a random Muslim woman back then and now,  most scholars agree on this).    Also you went on a tangent about working and being modest. Read my first post on the topic to know that Muslim women ALWAYS worked for 1400+ years in some job or another but had time for their family and household responsibilities. Even Umar Ibn al Khattab of all people hired a woman as "head of market operations ".  And above all else these Muslim women only thought of their job as a job and never let their job or income define them. I don't care if you earn money or not. You are not special or free or liberated or any other adjective you can name. And historically Muslim women used to be doctors way back even in the 1000s but never used to let their career define them. Except that they heal people. But modern day feminism does define a womans worth by her income and somehow she is "not tame" because she earns money. That is laughable. Sister "notme" did a good job of explaining the problem with people like you and your motivations to work. 
    • Sermon 1: Praise is due to Allah whose worth cannot be described…. In this sermon he recalls the creation of Earth and Sky and the creation of Adam and in it he mentions the Hajj Praise is due to Allah whose worth cannot be described by speakers, whose bounties cannot be counted by calculators and whose claim (to obedience) cannot be satisfied by those who attempt to do so, whom the height of intellectual courage cannot appreciate, and the divings of understanding cannot reach; He for whose description no limit has been laid down, no eulogy exists, no time is ordained and no duration is fixed. He brought forth creation through His Omnipotence, dispersed winds through His Compassion, and made firm the shaking earth with rocks. https://www.al-islam.org/nahjul-balagha-part-1-sermons/sermon-1-praise-due-Allah-whose-worth-cannot-be-described#creation-universe
    • https://www.urmc.rochester.edu/encyclopedia/content.aspx?ContentTypeID=90&ContentID=P02630 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Primitive_reflexes http://islamic-laws.com/eatinghabbit.htm According to the Holy Prophet (s.a.w.a.), inviting relatives, friends and neighbours for a dinner (Valeema) is sunnat on five occasions - Marriage, Aqiqa (first shaving of the child's head), Khatna (circumcision), when one has bought a new house or made a new house and lastly, when a visitor returns from travel. For Vegeterians Unless they choose a proper balance of foods, strict vegetarians are at risk for several deficiencies, especially vitamin B12. The other nutrients at risk are riboflavin, calcium, iron, and the essential amino acids lysine and methionine. Vegetarian children not exposed to sunlight are at risk for vitamin D deficiency. Zinc deficiency can occur in vegans because the phytic acid in whole grains binds zinc, and there is little zinc in fruits and vegetables. Since B12 is present only in animal foods and a limited number of specially fortified foods, vegans should probably take B12 supplements prescribed by a physician. Further, the symptoms of vegetarianism may include protein deficiency, amino acid and mineral depletion coupled with chronic low levels of energy. Another tradition describes green kasni leaves as a very good vegetable. Not a single leaf of kasni is devoid of a drop of water of heaven and therefore when one eats one should not shake it. It is also stated that kasni leaves (endive) are superior to all vegetables in the same manner as Ahlul Bait (a.s.) are superior to all mankind. Kasni leaves when eaten cause birth of male children who are also beautiful. When a person was ill with fever and headache, the Imam (a.s.) asked kasni leaves to be beaten in pulp, spread on paper, and sprinkled with oil of banafsha and then applied on the forehead of that person as it will completely cure both the fever and the headache.   The effects of eating Behi (quince), as stated by Hazrat Ali (a.s.), are the following: a)      Strengthens weak heart b)      Causes increase in weight c)      Cleans the stomach d)      Increases reason e)      Makes a man courageous   According to Imam Ja'far-e-Sadiq (a.s.), eating Behi (quince) improves complexion and causes beautiful children. When a person complained to Imam Reza (a.s.) of having few children, he (a.s.) asked him to eat egg with onion.
    • http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2017/11/22/israeli-bloggers-photograph-inside-one-islams-holiest-sites/ An Israeli blogger’s photograph from inside one of Islam’s holiest sites set off a firestorm in the Middle East also Saudi Arabia, Egypt, the United Arab Emirates and Bahrain added two organizations to their terror lists: the World Islamic Council and the International Union of Muslim Scholars. Eleven people were also added to the list, including two Muslim Brotherhood operatives. http://www.freemalaysiatoday.com/category/nation/2017/11/23/organisation-of-which-hadi-awang-is-vp-declared-terrorist-body/  
×