Jump to content
SoRoUsH

Declaring the Imams' sayings to be Taqiyya

Rate this topic

Recommended Posts

Salam, 

Here's a tradition: 

علل الشرائع: أبي، عن سعد، عن البرقي، عن ابن بزيع، عن ابن بشير، عن أبي حصين، عن أبي بصير، عن أحدهما عليهما السلام قال: لا تكذبوا بحديث أتاكم به مرجى ء و لا قدري و لا خارجي نسبه إلينا، فإنكم لا تدرون لعله شيء من الحق فتكذبوا الله عز و جل فوق عرشه
 
[3/80] Ilal al-Sharai: My father from Sa’d from al-Barqi from Ibn Bazi from Ibn Bashir from Abi Husayn from Abi Basir from one of them عليهما السلام who said: do not reject a narration which is brought to you by a Murji or a Qadari or a Khariji which he attributes to us, for you do not know - perhaps it is something of the truth and you will be rejecting Allah Mighty and Majestic above his throne.

 

Question:

Knowing this, why and how do some people choose to declare some sayings to be taqiyya? How would they know? Maybe it is something of the truth but we just don't know or are not willing to accept?

Edited by SoRoUsH

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Wa alaykum as-salaam. You'll find taqiyya used a lot in Hurr al-`Amuli's Wasa'il ash-Shi`a, and this may be because he used it as a hermeneutical tool to sift out narrations that contradicted the general Shii consensus (shadh ahadith). He mostly didn't use a rijal approach to tackle shadh traditions. Though even those who use rijal will say that they do not outright deny narrations, but that they weaken them and put them aside, and leave them to Allah.

Anyway, in my experience, many narrations that are declared taqiyya can be reconciled in some way with the consensus. Sometimes, it can be called tawriya rather than taqiyya, which are double entendres - the Imams crafted their words carefully. There are many narrations where the Imams essentially admit to doing taqiyya, and there are cases were taqiyya/tawriyya are quite clear (for example, narrations that praise the first two).

The narration in the original post is really emphasizing that we should not flat out deny a narration, reject it, make fun of it, etc. but that we should have some precaution when approaching the tradition.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, Qa'im said:

Anyway, in my experience, many narrations that are declared taqiyya can be reconciled in some way with the consensus.

Thank you!

This has been my experience, too. Some authors/scholars seem to be either intellectual lazy or too entrenched within a specific position to be able to look for reconciliation. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Recent Posts on ShiaChat!

    • http://www.presstv.com/Detail/2017/11/19/542786/arab-league-saudi-arabia-iran-meeting True color, desperation will not change anything to human who have been mesmerized.
    • Yeah, I know a set of parents that we’re doing the same thing for their daughter. Kept rejecting guys because they didn’t feel he was up to par. The guys info wouldn’t even make it to get to accept/reject. Their daughter is now 40 and unmarried. They rejected so many guys that people just stopped approaching her. 
    • It absolutely leads to sin unless you are a fantastic mu'min. And yes, although they might not turn to haram in terms of having relationships with girls, but you can't tell me you didn't see these guys talk about some girls in lustful ways or look at them in such a way. Furthermore, and something we seem to forget, is that in these gender mixed schools there is gender mixing in everything. In sport, as an example. Boys turn to watching filthy films whether they are in segregated or gender mixed schools.
    • No brother. What I do is this: I pray 17 rakaat Qadha prays everyday plus 11 rakaats Salaat-ul-layl. Salaat-ul-layl is something that does NOT have any replacement. It gives you good feeling. It really gives human being feeling of being in heaven. If you do Salaat-ul-layl, keep going. It guarantees both Dunya and Akherah.
    • I can give my opinion on men, as I'm not sure about women. I might have a pretty biased view due to personal experience, but some guys can get pretty desperate if they are segregated.  Also how does co-ed lead to sin? Most guys who were my friend in high school turned to pornography to sin, rather than girls. We might as well provide them with home schooling in that case. Trust me, we need to teach guys to respect women in this day and age. Alienating women is not the best option.  To be fair, there is a disadvantage of co-ed. If parents don't monitor their children, then there is a risk of them getting into the boyfriend/girlfriend culture.
×