Jump to content
ali_fatheroforphans

The limits of nohay

Recommended Posts

Salam,

I find it a shame that some Pakistani nohay have tunes which are literally stolen from Indian songs.There is no point of 'prolonged singing' to create fancy tunes. I feel that it takes away the message of Imam Hussein (as). I have heard many nohay with this exaggerated touch.

We need to be careful to know when a noha becomes impermissible. I find that a lot of them are just means of "having a bit of fun" kinda like music. Some people who do mattam are more concerned about whether the mattam has a good rhythm or not, and at this point it is just about pure entertainment. I know many people who like nohay and don't care about what the message is.

I don't have a bias against any culture or anything, but we really need to know our limits.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Don;t listen to it. 

*****

You raised a point, let address it 

Some background information. As you are aware that I am a layman, average person with maybe below average intellect, and very very little knowledge of the Religion and absolutely very very very little of Fiqh. Having said that I like other lay people do know general outlines of most of the things.

Azadari, As I see it, in my personal opinion. Is not an obligation on anyone, we do not invite to it, thank or welcome anyone or feel indebted to anyone for attending any program or doing any work. We do what we can and just take care of the guests of Son of Sayeda Fatima Az Zahra(as).

\Some aspects Azadari are cultural. Based on your particular geographic region and culture. This is how it grows. It uses elements of the culture. Unlike a Mosque. Hussainia/Imambargah which is attached to the Mosque, has different rules. Mosques have very defined rules.

Hussainia/Imambargah is where ALL Types of people can come and attend the Majlis/Lecture Muharram programs, lecture , latmiya and some may not be the pious people you are looking for , these people come from different religions, sects, cultural, ethical, moral background. May not be even practicing muslims, maybe somewhat practicing muslims  or somewhat decent moral ethical muslims. Hussania/Imambargah is a halflwayhouse which leads to the Mosque.

Some people are more into Ammal others are into other Activities( if they were not , who is going to do that part of the program/procession) - no one need to be judgmental. Everyone is a guest. 

You will have many elements that you may not like, in many different things, Noha, Lectures, kind of people who come, what they do,....This is not an Obligatory Act, that has defined rules and regulations otherwise is null and void. There is no “To do  List” no check marks here. I did all that and I am fine, my Wudu is ok as per Fiqh or my Outward  Prayers is ok as per Fiqh.

This is not an Obligatory Act/ritual/ Unless something is Clearly and unanimously against the Sharia, it's allowed. No major Islamic law can be broken. Like mahram and non mahram attending a majlis without following proper Islamic code.

Noha/latmiya are not  Adhan, they are line written with emotion to awaken dead emotions. Like poetry, it uses references and imaginary concepts and let's say it does not cross all the ‘T” and for all the “i” as you need to do in Fiqh or any Obligatory Islamic Act ( Prayer. Fasting )( Obligatory Act-Bare minimum act to be a Muslims).Sometime the reference may not be to your personal liking or confine  to the strict Fiqhi rules/historical account. These are not Friday Prayer Lectures with strict Fiqh discipline. Here there are emotions involved especially towards the end and it's understood. No one takes a word as a Fiqh law,  and you can’t parse every word. Everything need to be understood in its proper context.

They are poetry, they capture an image for you. Paint a picture( it's not fiqh).

This happen during the Muharram. Some very regular and pious Mosque attendees ( mostly Old people(now in their advanced age) , who now are very religious get disconnected with the reality that (maybe or not ) they went through these times themselves. Another, Problem, is that some feel that they own the place. Not true, they are managing it for the Imam(as) of our time. Places are run by the contribution of the shia, otherwise they will not be able to operate. They are not private enterprise.Our private old boys country clubs.  And since it's not a Mosque program or Ritual Prayer.

Rules are different, here and some do not have the ability to make the switch- in their understanding. They are managing a multi national. Multi Religious, multicultural program. Everyone is a valued guest. You can’t turn anyone away, nor can you be rude to them because they do not confine to your pious  vision that you have achieved in you old age.. Remember this is a halfway house to the House of Allah(awj).

They will in time, become practicing Muslims and be regular attendees of the Mosque. But it all starts with the initial invitation to the Majlis/lecture/program of Son of  Sayeda Fatima Az Zahra(as). You may have very bad people with bad habits and bad views, different motives, business motives, singers, art people, movie people people who may go clubbing and do other things  attend, or get involved with any aspect. A singer may participate in a Lathmiya/noha- he/she is not changing his/her habit/routine or way over night. Some may like to listen to music, and may listen to the lathmiya made by these people...People attend/get involved Just because of the attraction of the Son of Syedda Az Zahra(as).

Apply this to the Noha/Lathmiya and other aspects of Azadari- you will get the picture.

There is an issue with age, at different ages we get involved with different activities. At a particular age, a person may be more inclined towards Noha/Latmiya and less towards listening to a lecture. We can’t be judgmental here. He/she will get to the next stage in due time, not our time frame. May listen to something that is not of your liking or taste or speaks to what you have inside you. But that is what that particular person wants at this time….

 

( Disclaimer: Do not take anything personally, or literally this is not a Fiqh write up, above only represent my opinion and certainly do not read it like - based on the grammar, the mean this..If anything is not clear, before making a judgement - ask for clarification).

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
14 hours ago, ali_fatheroforphans said:

I find it a shame that some Pakistani nohay have tunes which are literally stolen from Indian songs.

That is definitely wrong. I do what brother @S.M.H.A. said. Just dont listen.

13 hours ago, S.M.H.A. said:

Some aspects Azadari are cultural. Based on your particular geographic region and culture. This is how it grows.

I did Arbaeen 2012 (or 2013 dont remember) in Iraq. I was shocked when I heard some Iraqi nohay and the beats of drum but if that is how they choose to remember Imam Hussain (as), then that is their choice.

The beauty of Imam Hussain (as) is that his message is universal. Same is the case with azadari. It has evolved over time as new shia communities get established around the world.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
9 hours ago, sidnaq said:

can you give an example of these types of nohay?

Okay.

I'm sure you have heard of Karbal Tou Piya Likhda (I love this noha btw).

My dad made me listen to a song called 'sheeshe ka tha dil mera" which is literally a copy of the noha 'Karbal tou piya likhda'. Be careful it's Muharram plus video might not be very appropriate (I'm not telling you to listen to it).

This took away the spirit of the noha. I don't know if the noha copied the song or the song copied the noha.

There were a couple more but I completely forgot. I'll let you know when I remember. 

Edited by ali_fatheroforphans

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
9 hours ago, ali_fatheroforphans said:

Okay.

I'm sure you have heard of Karbal Tou Piya Likhda (I love this noha btw).

My dad made me listen to a song called 'sheeshe ka tha dil mera" which is literally a copy of the noha 'Karbal tou piya likhda'. Be careful it's Muharram plus video might not be very appropriate (I'm not telling you to listen to it).

This took away the spirit of the noha. I don't know if the noha copied the song or the song copied the noha.

There were a couple more but I completely forgot. I'll let you know when I remember. 

i see JazakAllah

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 9/23/2017 at 2:35 AM, ali_fatheroforphans said:

I find it a shame that some Pakistani nohay have tunes which are literally stolen from Indian songs.

If I'm not mistaken, "Karbal tun piya likhda" borrows its tune from an old noha called "Sajjad main Zainab hoon".  Our nauhakhwans provide us with a service and, in my opinion, should be given the benefit of the doubt in these situations.

On 9/23/2017 at 7:37 PM, ali_fatheroforphans said:

This took away the spirit of the noha.

Please don't let such nonsense detract from the passion that you have for a noha about Imam Hussain as.  That song will have been forgotten about ten years from now, but people will still be reciting those nohay.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Recent Posts on ShiaChat!

    • NO, IT IS HARAM. SENDING GIFT TO HER AND CONGRATULATING HER FOR HER FALLACIOUS MARRIAGE IS ALSO HARAM.
    • Imam Ali ibn Abu Talib(as)   I have avoided the discussion of “The God” and aspects and working, so we do not get distracted and dwell in the realm( of Evil, Mercy, Love, help, present/absent, why does he not act, or why he/ she is silent, why allow all this, that is going on ) that is out of our domain for this discussion at this point in time. If there is a need, I(Layman opinion) will say, The one who  created me, doesn't owe me anything, beyond guidance. If anything exists it's the lack of follow through or rejection of the guidance. I.e. If the humans allow conditions to develop, and there is oppression. Where is God is not the question. Question, is Humanity has been guided at two levels ( inner and outer), rejection of both is the issue not why God does not take away this evil person that we elected or tolerated until he/she turned on us(we were fine up untill it was happening to others). We human need to do our job, instead of having entitlement mentality, and deflect it to it's your fault God., where are you and why you do not help. We have been helped. Intellect/Guidance( brief understanding, as a layman). Maybe not the best example but it will suffice, We would not expect the Mars rover to dwell in the realm of our working, instead it should be concerned with its prime directive, and we are to provide it guidance to accomplish its work. There are may misunderstanding, in  definition, version, understanding due to linguistic, terminology(old/new), cultural (East/West) and lack of Conceptual discussion at the basic fundamental level instead of technicalities and mechanic(which is subconsciously embedded in the way we have been groomed in schools and universities). A charged and contentious environment does not help in getting to any resolution. It's usually tit for tat, and pride get in the way in different threads a that were responding to targeted and side issue out of context. No one to the best of my knowledge and understanding denies we are limited creations in all  aspects. Your creation and Your surrounding creation(s) , are proof of something that  can not be denied. So, there is a Cause, the unlimited, infinitely powerful, Unknown/Unseen Source of all this. What you(non Muslims) call that source is not relevant - you can call it a system,  I call it God. So, there are no Atheists or Agnostic here. What an Atheist/ Agnostic may be, saying is that they do not believe in the God of Islam as “presented “or as understood or as described. That is a very different issue. But this issue, gets mixed up with other issues dealing with the mechanics in other threads which are on specific topics. Getting back to the Topic. We turn now to Stephen Hawking. He proposes M-theory, a variant of string theory, to explain the origins of the universe. The conclusion of his last book, The Grand Design, states:
      Stephen Hawking is a SME ( Subject Matter Expert) in his field of Study. If he gave his scientific theory and left it at that. I would not care nor it should be my concern, as there are many SMEs and have their theories in the Scientific world about may things.  His connecting it to and concluding that there is no need for god( his understanding of what god is to him). Is the issue, I am highlighting it not only because of what he said, because he or people like him are followed and the laypeople use these ideas to formulate their ideology. This is something, prevalent, using  fiction which they call ‘Science” as a tool to attack Divine Religion. This is where this talk and connection / implication that this is the god and of you can’t pray to or ask for help form gravity, or physical laws are not empathetic, and are cold  and have no concern for the humans ….This connection makes no sense. Comparing apples and oranges and mixing stuff that is confusing. This mentally is delusional and it stems out of misunderstanding of the concepts of pray, or help, mercy, etc..or implications that ignorant people believe in miracles and angels. Or we can’t carbon date the text, or evidence of such and such event. In short ignorant conclusions by apparently learned people in their field of study Trickle down effect, and the lay Atheists/Agnostics take these talking point and formulate an opinion and argument with it. Objectivity is also an issue, here. Double standards. Scientific theories are not subject to the same rigorous, and shredding mentality.   Its 5000, 2000, 1400 old stuff, we are Technically advanced. We forget that this advancement is in Technology,(only). The basic alphabet  in terms of Social behavior, is as old as the cave people.  Moving beyond, Mechanics, working, Techinacilities and this attitude of the best generation to exist, every preceding generation had the same attitude. and we will be looked at and our theories considers as old and outdated by the new generations.  Its a Point is time assessment.  What are the benefits of the revealed information- i.e Revealed to us through our struggle and study through discovery of us and whats around us.? Do we follow the Laws, derived from this new knowledge?  If not what are we rally arguing about. If a person can't even at least in Theory acknowledge the laws of Nature for our(Humanity)  Benefit. If you were to do that, you may rethink you position, because you may realize that you have been arguing against something that Natural laws actually prove.  This is what concerns me, at this point. Why can't the objective, learned and "technically" advanced people  see that and make this connection? Technical stuff/mechanic, of Biological change, next stage, or toasters, cars, bridges, space race, new medicine and quest of the common animal are of what consequence except for knocking a book or theory of descent or maybe some new medicine may develop form the finding. If the theory of micro evolution as marketed to support the a particular version of evolution ,  is inserted here, its argues that we will always be a step behind and they(Virus) will mutate, or accomplishing something making life better and having some toys and pride issues over other nations that we went to pluto..so what ?  How does this help us , solving the social problems of Humanity? (That is what Divine Religion is about).. Is there a comprehensive Social theory under development due to above technical advancements. ?  Is there a comprehensive Social theory out there? (maybe not to the liking of the people due to Nurture, but is there) To, me it looks like a willful denial of the Nature, a clash of Nature vs Nurture. People are finding any thing to latch on to stay free of any obligation/accountability.  Correct me if I am wrong, I am a layman, average person. I read , what is written by people , i assess and drive at a conclusion. So, I post to be criticized, constructive criticism. So, I can better under and remove misunderstanding(s) to gain better knowledge.   
    • The nature of the Existence is to exist. Thats all.
    • If the father doesn't approve of it, and didn't leave the door open for further contact, then that's it. They are not being disrespectful. Saying "no" should not forcibly come with an explanation, thus you can't demand it nor force them to listen to you. It is called freedom, and that is more sacred than anything you can tell them.
×