Jump to content
sidnaq

help needed from ex christians

Rate this topic

Recommended Posts

On 7/9/2017 at 10:58 PM, Gaius I. Caesar said:

I left Christianity because it is a irresponsible belief and defies logic and common sense. Why would one claim to believe in one God and say that He is three separate but equal personalities  in one deity and then tell you that God (The Father) is not Jesus or the Spirit , Jesus (The Son) is neither the Spirit or God and the Spirit is not God or Jesus. 

And when you ask them for more details or how it to be, they say "It's a divine mystery"

Can you trust such an answer? I couldn't growing up.

@iCambrian this is what I said, I said nothing of the sort that you think that I said. What exactly is the issue here?

Quote

This idea of "understanding my own mysteries more-so than understanding your mysteries" is arbitrary. 

^ I said nothing of this sort in my post, please read it in the full context.

Edited by Gaius I. Caesar

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 12/07/2017 at 1:28 AM, Quisant said:

My God says that he is the only real God.
Therefore all other gods are disproved.

Funny?

But I have always reasoned out my belief in the One and the Only God.

Some folks may not agree with my logic.

But that is not my problem.

Nor does your mockery prove your point.

As for me, I am quite satisfied that there is a God.

And He is All.-Powerful, All-Knowing, All-Just and All-Merciful.

Little jokes don't bother Him.

So I am not bothered either. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, Gaius I. Caesar said:

@iCambrian this is what I said, I said nothing of the sort that you think that I said. What exactly is the issue here?

^ I said nothing of this sort in my post, please read it in the full context.

you said " there's more clarity and understanding of its mysteries ", regarding Islam's mysteries and Christianities. My response to that was,

" This idea of "understanding my own mysteries more-so than understanding your mysteries" is arbitrary.  "

Meaning that, a mystery is a mystery. given the subjective and abstract nature of our religions, it becomes arbitrary trying to size up one vs another in any objective or clear way.

What im trying to say is that, a person cannot objectively justify a move from one religion to another based on inherently subjective concepts. Whether a person believes that the trinity makes sense or not, I dont think is justification for either moving toward or moving away from Christianity. Its too subjective and not a central or fundamental core concept. Hence why many christians, even here in this chat might not even be trinitarians. I would think there would be more pragmatic reasons for a move from one religion to another.

Edited by iCambrian

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

@iCambrian I see where you are coming from, but I don't think it is arbitrary, if anything it is quite subjective as it is with all religious topic.

3 hours ago, iCambrian said:

you said " there's more clarity and understanding of its mysteries ", regarding Islam's mysteries and Christianities.

Correct, with the assumption that a reader such as yourself understanding that I am talking about my personal and subjective experiences.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 8/20/2017 at 3:24 PM, Gaius I. Caesar said:

@iCambrian I see where you are coming from, but I don't think it is arbitrary, if anything it is quite subjective as it is with all religious topic.

Correct, with the assumption that a reader such as yourself understanding that I am talking about my personal and subjective experiences.

I can relate, especially when it comes to trinity, but it wasn't enough reason for me to leave Christianity. There's a lot more to Christianity than one doctrine. There are also trinitarians that receive blessings from God, so I don't think it's a game changer for God either. I thought that when I first admitted I didn't believe in a trinity that I would feel the condemnation, who cares people, but from God. I actually felt lighter, and my relationship really didn't change. I was open to explore scripture with new eyes. He doesn't live in the mainstream of any established religion. By the time men establish the does and don'ts, must and can'ts of how to believe in God their way it's always messed up. Millennia of contradicting religions proves nobody really cares what God thinks.  124,000 prophets can't be held responsible for what humans made of the message.

God doesn't change because of doctrine, or religion. He is what He is regardless our belief system and criteria. We have to look past that to experience God. It also makes for a better starting point for study. That's just my experience, thus far.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I was in tears watching this. The Spirit of truth in me bore witness to the truth of this women's testimony. I have never seen Jesus in real life, like appear to me in a light where I seen his hands, and heard his voice. But so many times, he has surrounded me with his presence, he has washed me with his love. Like he truly loves me and reveals himself to me in a variety of ways. Also if this is not concrete evidence. Look at my life:

My Parents never graduated high school, I haven older sister who has been addicted to drugs, prostitution, an older brother in Prison for long periods of time, grew up with no father. Imagine the things set against me, the insecurity, low self-esteem, and pain I grew up with. With these cards handed to you, what hope do you have? I was a broken young girl.

Literally, Jesus came into my life and gave me value, worth, purpose, a new identity. He cared for me like his own baby and raised me. he taught me values, gave me wisdom, helped me, and most of all loved me through the good and bad times. He gave me experiences of good things in life that I forever am grateful for.

I graduated high school and spoke at my graduation, helped many people from the neighborhood I grew up in. Went to a prestigious university in California and now live in the Middle Eastern Country of Jordan. I have traveled around the world and seen more of God through Jesus. I never forget the pit he saved me from and I am 23 years old but still his baby! I love my Jesus. If anyone would call on him they would see he will come to them. Jesus is real and alive and active in the world, saving people. He surely saved me!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
19 hours ago, Journal1 said:

I was in tears watching this. The Spirit of truth in me bore witness to the truth of this women's testimony. I have never seen Jesus in real life, like appear to me in a light where I seen his hands, and heard his voice. But so many times, he has surrounded me with his presence, he has washed me with his love. Like he truly loves me and reveals himself to me in a variety of ways. Also if this is not concrete evidence. Look at my life:

My Parents never graduated high school, I haven older sister who has been addicted to drugs, prostitution, an older brother in Prison for long periods of time, grew up with no father. Imagine the things set against me, the insecurity, low self-esteem, and pain I grew up with. With these cards handed to you, what hope do you have? I was a broken young girl.

Literally, Jesus came into my life and gave me value, worth, purpose, a new identity. He cared for me like his own baby and raised me. he taught me values, gave me wisdom, helped me, and most of all loved me through the good and bad times. He gave me experiences of good things in life that I forever am grateful for.

I graduated high school and spoke at my graduation, helped many people from the neighborhood I grew up in. Went to a prestigious university in California and now live in the Middle Eastern Country of Jordan. I have traveled around the world and seen more of God through Jesus. I never forget the pit he saved me from and I am 23 years old but still his baby! I love my Jesus. If anyone would call on him they would see he will come to them. Jesus is real and alive and active in the world, saving people. He surely saved me!

Long story short, I have seen people see what I could not. I have been surrounded by a presence my Muslim friend called the Spirit of Allah, because he felt it too. Okay, that's two stories.

I believe that presence to be the Holy Spirit, sent by God, often in the form of angels, many ascribe to being Jesus. I wish I could have asked the lady that proved answer to my prayer but the timing was rather intense and I was too busy figuring out what was going on already. I couldn't see what she saw but I knew "God in His essence" was there. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Recent Posts on ShiaChat!

    • I  understand what you are trying to say but kindly understand what i am trying to ask. You are saying that how leaving Islam should be punishable by death. I am asking its not about what should be and how it should be, its about what is ruling in this matter. And whether any Ayyah  directly hints towards this ruling ?  I completely agree but similar to above discussion in link there is no reference to Quran. 
      I understand that even treason against country is punishable by death then why not for religion. But what i want you to understand that rulings are not as per yours and mine understanding. If that so then i say it should not be done like this.  Its matter of life and death of a human being. It cant be interpreted that easily as per one's thinking. Same Islam asks to respect every human being regardless of their religion and color. 
    • @hasanhh and anyone else who would enjoy a light comedy war film. This one has its moments. Its also thought provoking and asks a big question about the purpose (or the absence of it) behind the US occupation of Afghanistan.
    • KSA wants to try and make a dent before their abominable presence leaves the stage of history forever. However it is ridiculous to think Saudis will be fighting a war with anyone alone while they can't even bomb Yemeni babies on their own. Same goes for Israheil. So naturally they will bring their uncle Frankenstein Sam to help them out with the heavy lifting as usual. However due to important strategic reasons they will be go for Lebanon and Syrian territory first. This is why Netanyuhu and King Salamander have been grovelling at Putin's feet through 2017. If I was Putin I would pull a Danzig with them and take their monies then back stab them after having filled my defending allies with weapons. China will not be joining in. They are worse than Jews in seeking wealth. Of course the US senate will soon give the go ahead for their troops and fleet to deploy (since someone in the thread was innocently asking why one of their fleets stays in the region, this is it). This is also why they had Iran under sanctions since so many years, to weaken their preparations. This is also why they have created hell in Balochistan and other borders surrounding Iran. They think that will prove to be enough deterrence for paramilitary forces attempting to reinforce IRGC. Manpower. That stupid video someone linked before was right about one thing and that is the very significant advantage in manpower Iran has. Available manpower is directly proportional to motivation of the people. That is why Israhellis and Saudis and Yanks are bound to lose if the Shia manpower is mobilized who a lot of them will proceed to fight till the death while the axis of bankers has little motivation which will die out when the body bags start coming in. Israhellis used to literally die of fear when Saddam fired a few scuds into their cesspool. Saudis are too decadent and incompetent. Yanks are waking up to the truth and are also oppressed now and its not a false flag attacked year 2001 anymore. Those of them who will fight will have to fight each other being transsexual, pro-Trump, anti-feminist, white supremacist, pedophiles and all the throngs of tedious little issues plaguing them now. So with such a difference in Morale and perhaps a little bit Russian support as well, God willing above all else, things will change forever. At worst there will be a regime change in Iran which will not change anything because the biggest push of all pushes comes later under Mahdi (as) and Jesus (as) who are promised the manpower, hardware and the ultimate victory to bring the world about and set if free.
    • I know some eastern women put up with their husbands, even after being beaten and abused, as they are very dependant on them. I mean, some women go to the extent of obeying their husband soo much and this is just pure injustice! As for your question about a guy being rejected because he was Eastern - I feel it is a very personal choice as long as she doesn't think Eastern men are inferior to Western men. The choice could be associated with a lot of factors, like personality clash etc I personally would find it easier to get along with Western Muslim girls, because their way of thinking, interacting etc would be similar to mine. However, I'm okay with marrying an Eastern Muslim girl if I get along with her.    
    • You could have fed an entire family for a year with that money, instead of buying things that eventually go out of style and fall apart/get lost after a few years.
×