Jump to content

Rate this topic

Recommended Posts

What if a person does not believe in the "Ismah" of Prophets & Imams (peace & blessings of Allah be upon them) and introducing himself as Shia?
How should we treat that person? He claims to be Shia & quoting ahadith of Imams, saying that he love them, yet he believe that the Prophet & Imams made mistakes & committed sins.
Is this hypocrisy or ignorance?  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Salsabeel said:

What if a person does not believe in the "Ismah" of Prophets & Imams (peace & blessings of Allah be upon them) and introducing himself as Shia?
How should we treat that person? He claims to be Shia & quoting ahadith of Imams, saying that he love them, yet he believe that the Prophet & Imams made mistakes & committed sins.
Is this hypocrisy or ignorance?  

 

Salam.what is ismah? and does this mean not believing in their imamah?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, ali_fatheroforphans said:

I think that person needs to be better informed and may need to do some research. There are many Shias who have flawed logic based on the influence of Sunnis.

You are right he should be better informed.

But we have experienced such profiles over the years consistently repeating the same flawed logic every time with a new profile and claiming to be Shia of Ahl albayat. AS.

When it is  are argued the profile holder  remain speechless and present themselves as most intellectual of SC and move away

 

Edited by skyweb1987

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's plain ignorance. 

We are ordered to follow them in their words and actions. If they commit mistakes and fall for a sin then we have to follow that also!!. And then Allah will punish his servant for following his prophet. How's that possible.?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, Salsabeel said:

What if a person does not believe in the "Ismah" of Prophets & Imams (peace & blessings of Allah be upon them) and introducing himself as Shia?
How should we treat that person? He claims to be Shia & quoting ahadith of Imams, saying that he love them, yet he believe that the Prophet & Imams made mistakes & committed sins.
Is this hypocrisy or ignorance?  

Ignorance. There are quite a few people even on SC who hold this view. Dare I say, there are even scholars who hold this view.

I say ignorance because it has a lot to do with the constant bombardment we face on this issue by wahabis, salafis, etc. Keep repeating the same thing over and over again, even if it is lies, and people starting believing it.

The 14 Infallibles are free from sin and mistake.

 

Edited by shiaman14

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 minutes ago, shiaman14 said:

The 14 Infallibles are free from sin and mistake.

No doubt it is part of our belief engraved in our hearts  and no ignorant can remove it from our hearts

wasalam

Edited by skyweb1987

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Salam Alaikum - I also have had experience with people who term themselves Shia but do not either believe in infallibility of aimmah or say some of our beloved Imams (as) did bayah (allegiance) to the rulers of their times. I have had several debates on such issues and with such personalities, and what I have realized that some of these people are really ignorant and try to mend ways, while some of these people are not ignorant but want to destroy the whole system and that is why they call themselves shia but have a different agenda. These are modern time munafiq. They are among us and they want to destroy our iman. I think some of these are paid as well for doing this. So, we need to be cautious in our approach. 

Wassalaam!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
17 hours ago, EhsanR said:

Salam Alaikum - I also have had experience with people who term themselves Shia but do not either believe in infallibility of aimmah or say some of our beloved Imams (as) did bayah (allegiance) to the rulers of their times. I have had several debates on such issues and with such personalities, and what I have realized that some of these people are really ignorant and try to mend ways, while some of these people are not ignorant but want to destroy the whole system and that is why they call themselves shia but have a different agenda. These are modern time munafiq. They are among us and they want to destroy our iman. I think some of these are paid as well for doing this. So, we need to be cautious in our approach. 

Wassalaam!

Thanks for detailed identification of such modern time munafiqeen.

True Shia should remain cautious from these paid enemy of Shia islam.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Recent Posts on ShiaChat!

    • perhaps you have missed my points:   This is the question of a person who is chained within the boundaries of space & time. Where was time before the bigbang? Hawking said that time does not exist before big bang. Read his article "beginning of time"

      http://www.hawking.org.uk/the-beginning-of-time.html    
    • If they surrounded you; first rule, stop, look at all of them directly in the eye and tell them, move out my personal space, we are having a discussion, this is not a fight. If you want to have a fight, let me call my boys you call your mamas, cause somebody gonna get hurt! easy to defeat atheists, ask, why is the state your master?, no, no ,no, we just obey, I mean follow it, they look after us?. But they make laws that you never have a say in it? but, but, they are smarter!. You admit to being dumb and thus need someone do direct you to the grass? So is that the reason why you are the slave of the men who own the money?. erm what do you mean you conspiracy theorist! That is when you got them. Then follow up with, is Sigmund and Dawkins their prophets?. If one follows the ideas of a particular men, thus they become their masters. Well why did you not mention Carl Jung?, he and Sigmund worked together before Carl decided he was a retard?. What about Kant? Socrates? Emerson? Plato? Plotinus?, the list is huge. One cannot enter such discussions without having read works of around 20 authors or more.
    • It always is. Absolutely. He created time. He doesn't need time to do anything. The other two questions in that line are meaningless.
    • Prophet ( PBUHHP ) said: "Shall I tell you a thing which will keep you away from finding faults in other people that is watch out for your weak point and you will never have time for anything to talk about".
    • Many with the so called good jobs cannot find partners. You are concentrating on the job title, focus on how to make dem monies u get me brejin. In today's world YouTube is your tutor, you can take the good from it or the bad. Research all the types of careers with their prospective qualifications or not.  Read, write, go do some volunteering or apply for work. At the interview tell them, the truth, because the point in life is, you are meant to be free and not a slave. If you claim God has guided you, surely he should Guide you whenever in need. https://www.prospects.ac.uk/ Do not be addicted to such types but be inspired.  
×