Jump to content

Rate this topic

Recommended Posts

"It does not matter what interpretation of Islam they have"

Most all interpretations are derived from the Prophet, this person is brain dead and has no understanding of how Islamic scholarship works.

She also quotes Ibn Ishaq who no Muslim scholar accepts as authentic as there are no narrations or isnad which he lists as his sources.

His biography of the Prophet also never survived we only have bits and pieces of it.

 

Ibn Ishaq (d. 150/767)….was a very controversial figure. Malik, Ibn al Qattan, Ibn Hanbal, and others considered him highly unreliable because he accepted hadiths from questionable narrators as well as Christians and Jews. But Ibn Shu’ba felt he was impeccably reliable… [Hadith, Muhammad’s Legacy in the Medieval and Modern World, Jonathan A C Brown, Oneworld Publications, Kindle, p86]

Throughout his work, Ibn Ishaq precedes every statement with the word za`ama or za`amu, he (they) alleged). It carries with it more than a hint that the statement may not be true, though it might be sound. This attitude reflects Ibn Ishaq’s caution and fairness.

Source: https://yahyasnow.wordpress.com/2015/07/20/who-was-ibn-ishaq-and-was-his-work-reliable/

Edited by Enlightened Follower

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Her whole argument falls under an Ad Hominem attack on the Prophet which is a logical fallacy:

"Ad hominem attacks can take the form of overtly attacking somebody, or more subtly casting doubt on their character or personal attributes as a way to discredit their argument. The result of an ad hom attack can be to undermine someone's case without actually having to engage with it."

Source: https://yourlogicalfallacyis.com/ad-hominem

Edited by Enlightened Follower

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

hahahahahaha, war mongering speech and attitude but medinah accepted him lolz, Meccan people evicted him and Medinian people did not that. What an idiot is she. Medinah is 448 Kms away from Makkah and Makkah was center of whole Arabia and Medinian people did not know what was happening ? This shows that Meccan people did not respected Prophet but Medinian people knew such a blessing and welcomed him. The reason for which Prophet PBUHHP evicted Jews out of Medinah was that they used to say to tribes of Medinah Ows and Khizrij that once our Prophet comes we will kill you but when Prophet came, Ows and Khizrij became Muslims. and their dreams were shattered and they begin to engage in conspiracy to fail Prophet PBUHHP by engaging in war support to infidels of Makkah.  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

People like her are dime a dozen. They are not out there to engage in a dialogue but to lead a smear campaign against Islam and the Prophet. So why give them coverage?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
9 hours ago, Marbles said:

People like her are dime a dozen. They are not out there to engage in a dialogue but to lead a smear campaign against Islam and the Prophet. So why give them coverage?

 

In the past when someone tried to write a book and ruin the face of Islam, all Muslim scholars, Sunni, Shia,... would write many volumes of books to answer a single false claim, but now as the Muslims are taken by a deep sleep, these attacks remained unanswered, only few tend to answer such nonsenses but they are outnumbered and cannot defend as they should.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

She reminds me of this neo-nazi named Evalion. Look her up. She basically made stupid remarks about Jews, Blacks and Muslims (50% of Iranians are born from incest???), then excessively praised Hitler in many videos. Thank God she was banned.

Is she an Islamic scholar? I, as a muslim would never be taken seriously talking about fiqh and interpretation of faith without formal education, but this woman is more qualified than Ayatollah Sistani?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Recent Posts on ShiaChat!

    • That did not only said 35% fat only.....It says 35% rich but you are only stuck with fat bro. Get out of it, it says proteins, calories, fats and so on so forth. Secondly, this is just a research about cows and monkeys, it isn't about humans but it says that there is difference between milk of male and female infants. Finally, you could see the change yourself that you posted 1 liter to be 1.027 kg and I posted 1.03 kg, Even though, it was not mentioned if the milk was freshly drawn or kept for a time which may affect it's content. Finally, repeating again, you need samples to weight for baby girl's milk against baby boy's which unfortunately neither you nor I have. So, until this happens, I stick to my belief and you stick to what you belief,  
    • I also find the Quran and the Hebrew Bible being more similar. The Hebrew Bible being a milennium older than the Quran sets rules for almost everything. The Quran have taken some of it, while the New Testament has very few laws and apeals to its believers to use the consciense given by God. Slaughter sacrifice is originally pagan. Judaism grew out of paganism. In Judaisms infancy (early first milennium BC) even human sacrifice existed. The Hebrew Bible tell the story, and science confirm it. (Human sacrifice still existed in Sweden when Muhammed lived! ) Christianity evolved from Judaism. The first Christians were Jews. The first followers of Islam were Arabs. In this way Christianity and Judaism is more related.  Muslims believe Quran is Gods word sent to Muhammed by the angel. Christians do not believe so. Neither do I. I believe Arabs for some reason adapted the personalities and stories from the Bible. Clearly most of it from the Hebrew Bible. This is why Islam is closer to Judaism.
    • More Differences:

      His Vision:

      It is narrated through good chains of narrators that Imam Muhammad Baqir (a.s.) said: “The Holy Prophet (S) said that the eyes of we prophets sleep but our souls remain awake and I see from behind as I see in front."

      https://www.al-islam.org/hayat-al-qulub-vol-2-allamah-muhammad-baqir-al-majlisi/prophet-s-appearance-character-physique

      This is also reported by Bukhari & Muslim:

      Al-Bukhaari (741) and Muslim (424) narrated from Abu Hurayrah that the Messenger of Allah (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) said: “Do you think that I face the qiblah (and do not know what you are doing)? By Allah, your bowing and prostrating are not hidden from me; I can see you behind my back.”  Ahmad (9504) narrated that Abu Hurayrah said: The Messenger of Allah (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) led us in praying Zuhr, and in the last row there was a man who prayed badly. When he said the salaam, the Messenger of Allah (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) called him and said: “O So and so, do you not fear Allah? Do you not see how you pray. You think that you could hide from me some of what you do, but by Allah I can see behind me as well as I can see in front of me.” Classed as saheeh by Shaykh al-Albaani (may Allah have mercy on him) in Mishkaat al-Masaabeeh (no. 811)  His Sleep:

      It is mentioned in some other traditions that Imam Ja’far Sadiq (a.s.) said: Once Abu Dharr went to meet the Holy Prophet (S) but was told that he was in another orchard. When Abu Dharr reached there, he saw the Prophet asleep. Abu Dharr took a dry stick and broke it just to ascertain whether he was really asleep. The Prophet opened his eyes and said: “O Abu Dharr, are you testing me? Do you not know that I see you in my sleep as I see you when awake? My eyes sleep but not my soul.”

      https://www.al-islam.org/hayat-al-qulub-vol-2-allamah-muhammad-baqir-al-majlisi/prophet-s-appearance-character-physique Miscellaneous Reports:

       A cloud always shaded him in the sun.
      No foul smell ever reached the Holy Prophet (S)
      Anything in which the saliva of the Holy Prophet (S) fell became auspicious. It could heal the sick.
      The Holy Prophet (S) could speak every language.
      The Holy Prophet (S) could hear voices even when asleep. He could hear talks of angels which others could not. He also could know what was in other’s minds.
      Pebbles recited the glory of God in his holy palm.
      When the Holy Prophet (S) walked on soft soil, his feet did not leave marks thereon. On the contrary when he walked on hard ground, it left his foot marks.
      When the Holy Prophet (S) walked in the sun, he did not cast any shadow.

       
    • Yeah, I know that. I am not opposing it due to candies but scary faces for even smaller things results in bigger dangers. Why not funny and cute masks for girls such as fairies and warriors for girls and boys not scary faces.
×