Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
Zahra syed

descendants

Recommended Posts

taken from here:

Quote
My question is specifically about the opinions of knows Shia Mujtahids or Scholars about Sheikh Abdul Qadir Jilani(ra).

Shia scholars has nothing to do with genealogy

if you want to know such things you have to ask the genealogists, just as if you want to know some thing about cosmology you have to ask the cosmologgists.

anyhow if we looked at the lineage of Abdulqader al-Gelani we will find it false & fabricated

the (fabricated) lineage of Abdulqader al-Gelani is as following

Abdulqader son of Musa son of Abdullah son of Yahya son of Muhammad son of Dawoud son of Musa son of Abdullah son of Musa son of Abdullah son of Hassan son of Hassan son of Ali son of Abi Talib

Noor al-Absar, by Sheblenji, page 320

the famous genealogist Ibn Enba declared that this lineage is false and Abdulqader doesnt belong to Bani Hashim tribe.

Umdat al-Talib, page 129

if you search in genealogy books, you will never find a person with this name (Musa son of Abdullah son of Yahya) because its fabricated character.

our friend Nabil al-Karkhi (may Allah's mercy be upon him) proved the falsehood of Gelani's lineage (Arabic website)

http://tanzeeh.shiaunion.com/trips/iraq_trips/gylanyun.htm

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On Thursday, November 17, 2016 at 10:58 PM, DigitalUmmah said:

taken from here:

Shia scholars has nothing to do with genealogy

if you want to know such things you have to ask the genealogists, just as if you want to know some thing about cosmology you have to ask the cosmologgists.

anyhow if we looked at the lineage of Abdulqader al-Gelani we will find it false & fabricated

the (fabricated) lineage of Abdulqader al-Gelani is as following

Abdulqader son of Musa son of Abdullah son of Yahya son of Muhammad son of Dawoud son of Musa son of Abdullah son of Musa son of Abdullah son of Hassan son of Hassan son of Ali son of Abi Talib

Noor al-Absar, by Sheblenji, page 320

the famous genealogist Ibn Enba declared that this lineage is false and Abdulqader doesnt belong to Bani Hashim tribe.

Umdat al-Talib, page 129

if you search in genealogy books, you will never find a person with this name (Musa son of Abdullah son of Yahya) because its fabricated character.

our friend Nabil al-Karkhi (may Allah's mercy be upon him) proved the falsehood of Gelani's lineage (Arabic website)

http://tanzeeh.shiaunion.com/trips/iraq_trips/gylanyun.htm

 

Jazakallah for this info even

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

Sign in to follow this  

×