Jump to content

Recommended Posts

27 minutes ago, IbnSina said:

If you are a muslim and you celebrate the creation of america then you are a hypocrite. 

How so?

I am as proud a shia as there is yet I find nothing wrong with celebrating America. 

I am free to practice my faith here more openly than any other country.

I also disagree with America's foreign policy frequently but that is the government and not the people.

To reiterate -  Happy Independence Day.

 

2 hours ago, Laayla said:

Bismehe Ta3ala,

Please study history.  Don't celebrate oppression.

M3 Salamah, FE AMIN Allah

Slavery is a dark episode in American history but that is separate from the independance from Britain. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 hours ago, shiaman14 said:

 

[MOD NOTE: The topic is Happy. Off-topic posts were removed.)

Lol. Sorry  I missed them.

PS...I don't really celebrate this day except as a symbol of liberation from any and all oppression.

I do admit a fondness for fireworks as a better (though somewhat polluting ) use for gunpowder than mindlessly killing fellow humans.

And I like sparkly objects.

And BBQs. 

And family gatherings.

Those are happening in my backyard right now EXCEPT NO ONE IS EATING UNTIL AFTER DARK DUE TO THE  MUSLIM my daughter married. 

( This will be my last official complaint  here about that. I promise.) :D

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Becoming independent from a tyrant colonizer like British empire is good, but really is the nation of America independent? To defend American people, that's better to say: No, they are not independent.

When Iranian felt their government under Shah is a dependent element of the west, they stood up and fought for years and overturned that dependent government. Now, after becoming independent, for example, a person like Ahmadinejad, without spending money for his presidential election campaign and without support of power sources, and just through people's votes becomes the president of the nation. How can such a thing happen in a country? How can a person without spending money and without being associated to the power sources become president of Iran? Because, It's not the money and political lobbies that choose the president, but the people themselves.  If Iranian government is helping Hezbollah or sending troops to some countries of the region, if the government doesn't recognize Zionist regime as a country, etc., it's the vast majority of the people's will, and they support these stances. So, unlike the Shah's era, it's the people who are controlling the matters, whether directly or indirectly, good or bad.

On the other hand, can we say the same things about the US? are the people who choose the Presidents in the US, or money sources (notice, I am not saying that US elections are necessarily rigged, I have no idea about that)? Are the people who dictate the countries affairs or political lobbies who even may not be from America? If one wants to say that it's the people, then they are, as a result, saying that invasion of Iraq and Afghanistan, support for Israeli, creating, funding, arming and training terrorists groups, inhumane sanctions, such as food and drug sanctions, and forcing other countries to implement them on people of other countries, etc. etc. etc., are according to the choice of American people. If that is the case then, yes we can say American nation is a dependent nation, but it's not the case. That's why I am saying to defend American people, we should accept that they are not an independent nation.

However, it's just a particle of the apparent part of the issue, the hidden part is sadder and more painful. How the people think, how and what they dress, what they eat, so on and so forth, is what think tanks and their sources such as media choose, not the people, even though they are not noticing it – which is called Jahle morakab! Something very disgusting among people, by just a few years of work by media, all of a sudden will become a norm in the community, or even the people will defend that.

2 hours ago, shiaman14 said:

I am free to practice my faith here more openly than any other country.

I am almost sure that you agree with the fact that US regime is oppressing people in different countries. Clearly, fighting oppression is one of the most important part of practicing Shia faith. Now, can you fight US tyranny in the US soil? No.

The type of freedom of religion and social freedom implemented by US government and how it controls it, what it allows and when it allows all are based on a tactic that unfortunately has fooled many of us. To explain it more and in details, it requires its own long post.

----

What I posted was not so happy. So, if it's considered off-topic, please move it to the thought thread.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

^ The "kids" are still out there roasting marshmallows and telling stories around the embers. ( And keeping the animals from freaking out due to the firecrackers still going off in the area.) 

We two old parents retired to our room.

 

image.jpeg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, DigitalUmmah said:

happy traitor day, you smelly colonials. we never wanted you anyway GIVE US OUR TEA BACK

In Britain's Most Wanted List, I wonder who would be higher - George Washington (if he were alive of course) or Abu Bakr Al-Baghdadi?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
11 hours ago, kamyar said:

When Iranian felt their government under Shah is a dependent element of the west, they stood up and fought for years and overturned that dependent government. Now, after becoming independent, for example, a person like Ahmadinejad, without spending money for his presidential election campaign and without support of power sources, and just through people's votes becomes the president of the nation. How can such a thing happen in a country? How can a person without spending money and without being associated to the power sources become president of Iran? Because, It's not the money and political lobbies that choose the president, but the people themselves.  If Iranian government is helping Hezbollah or sending troops to some countries of the region, if the government doesn't recognize Zionist regime as a country, etc., it's the vast majority of the people's will, and they support these stances. So, unlike the Shah's era, it's the people who are controlling the matters, whether directly or indirectly, good or bad.

 

On the other hand, can we say the same things about the US? are the people who choose the Presidents in the US, or money sources (notice, I am not saying that US elections are necessarily rigged, I have no idea about that)? Are the people who dictate the countries affairs or political lobbies who even may not be from America? If one wants to say that it's the people, then they are, as a result, saying that invasion of Iraq and Afghanistan, support for Israeli, creating, funding, arming and training terrorists groups, inhumane sanctions, such as food and drug sanctions, and forcing other countries to implement them on people of other countries, etc. etc. etc., are according to the choice of American people. If that is the case then, yes we can say American nation is a dependent nation, but it's not the case. That's why I am saying to defend American people, we should accept that they are not an independent nation.

No argument from me here. The American government has been taken over by Lobbyists and Special Interests. I have been saying for the past 3 elections, that we do not vote for a party but really vote for special interests - that is the bad.

The Good - nothing is stopping us Muslims from uniting and being active in American politics. The 2 most powerful lobbying groups in Washington are Israelis and Saudis. Is it any wonder that the Executive and Legislative branches do what these groups want. Easier said than done but we could ever unite as one, then there is no reason why we cannot have as much influence or more than AIPAC or the Saudis.

11 hours ago, kamyar said:

However, it's just a particle of the apparent part of the issue, the hidden part is sadder and more painful. How the people think, how and what they dress, what they eat, so on and so forth, is what think tanks and their sources such as media choose, not the people, even though they are not noticing it – which is called Jahle morakab! Something very disgusting among people, by just a few years of work by media, all of a sudden will become a norm in the community, or even the people will defend that.

Happens all over the world. Media is controlled by governments or the rich. There are very few unbiased sources of media left in the world.

11 hours ago, kamyar said:

I am almost sure that you agree with the fact that US regime is oppressing people in different countries. Clearly, fighting oppression is one of the most important part of practicing Shia faith. Now, can you fight US tyranny in the US soil? No.

The type of freedom of religion and social freedom implemented by US government and how it controls it, what it allows and when it allows all are based on a tactic that unfortunately has fooled many of us. To explain it more and in details, it requires its own long post.

I agree with your statement to a degree but I do not agree with your conclusion. Can we fight US tyranny? Yes, absolutely. It will not be by having a long drawn out battle but through politics alone. Referencing my earlier comment, the US Domestic and Foreign policy is up for sale to the highest bidder (unfortunately). For example, the US was all but ready to pull the trigger on attacking Syria only at the behest of Saudi and Israel but political pressure and maneuvering forced them to stop.
Another example - I was speaking to a famous shia figure (let's call him Professor X)  who is active in US politics and he told me brief story.  Professor X met with a US Senator who told him to his face that the shias are weird. There was a meeting taking place on how best to tackle Syria with representatives from Saudi and other countries. There was pressure to move on Syria in a certain direction (guess which one) and it seemed like there was resounding approval to proceed until a feeble voice spoke up. The guy said that attacking Syria would mean the end of heritage of 2,000 years of Christian history of Syria and American Christians would not stand for it. The committee did a 180 on their decision. Back to the Senator - he said how can we have a meeting where the Sunnis are telling us to attack Syria and a Christian says don't while the Shias are not even on the table.

Third example - G7+1 vs Iran negotiations. Political succes.s

That is our problem. We will sit on the by lines and complain about the World being against us instead of standing up and changing the world. Thankfully the political winds are achangin' and we are beginning to become more politically active to influence things our way.

We will probably agree to disagree.

PS. I celebrate July 4th because I love America but I celebrate it more because I really, really hate Britain. Also, I love the smell of gunpowder in the evening.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Recent Posts on ShiaChat!

    • Need to explain the reason of this wiki and Islam. My way of thinking : How do we sure/certain that Iblis has knowledge of God perfectly when he/Iblis disobey God's order to bow.
    • Salaam Alaykum Brother Good for your sister that has such a good brother. It is very important to observe Hijab and Islamic dress code. First of all, don't expect your sister to change her behaviour in one night. This process takes months, or maybe one or two years, so be patient. Never get angry on this because it only ruins your previous effort. Always calm and patient. Second, don't expect your sister to be nice to you when you talk about Hijab with her. She probably disrespects you or say inappropriate words, you MUST be quiet if it happens. Apparently your mother is concerned about this. It's a good thing that you are not alone. Observing Islamic dress code is very very gradual process. Your mother and you should be together and patient. Try to be more respectful to your sister and help her as much as you can. Let her think that you always support her. Your mother should also show observation in this matter. Your sister should see that your mother doesn't wear any kind of cloth. For example, when your mother and you and your sister are shopping, your mother should say(loudly so that your sister hears that), I don't like this dress. It's too short or tight and I'm Muslim. Never use force or fighting to make her dress islamically. Let her to understand this herself. Remember be kinder and more patient. Do as much favor as you can for your sister. Tell your mother to do the same. Gradually you can start talking with your sister in person about Hijab. The key is that she should first TRUST you that you are saying that just for help and your love as her brother.
    • Over the last 40 years, we have seen an increase in income inequality, especially in the US, with wages stagnating for a large majority of the population, but profits for corporations continuing to grow exponentially, this was obviously dealt a blow in the financial crisis, but the mechanisms in place to fix the crisis largely continued to promote neoliberal, state capitalism. The federal reserve, which I believe is criticised unfairly is largely a mechanism in place to fix problems within a very highly flawed system. You need a body that has to regulate banks and interest rates, otherwise you would have a situation that is even worse, where banks would continually just collude and set rates in a way that benefits them. The problem however is that, the Fed's mechanisms only empower the same system that has done damage to so many people's lives. By promoting bank bailouts, which then just give the bank the insurance that they can continue to do whatever they want, and the government will just continue to bail them out, they have no much incentive to act differently. Financial reform and regulation have been implemented since the financial crisis but these aren't enough, and the bailouts only led to bank CEOs giving themselves higher bonuses. But the question is how do you fix the system? If you don't bail the banks out, you leave millions unemployed, you make small business reliant on banks for short-term financing shut down. If you don't print money and you don't increase the deficit, you get rid of the few ways in a flawed economic system to boost the economy. So how do you fix it? More regulation? Do you make the Federal Open Market Committee meetings more public, but then that just allows political influence and gives more power to a very corrupt congress to make decisions, when you can't exactly trust them either? There have been attempts to make other currency systems like bitcoin, but on a national level what is a good solution? To centralise the banks completely would be a good idea but its just giving power to corrupt lawmakers who are bought by corporate interests. 
    • I think an important question that nobodies asked is what kind of relationship do you have with your sister?  If you're not super close and just come out of nowhere with all these rules shes going to rebel and your parents could get involved- telling you to stay out of it. If this happens- she might think its okay because her parents are defending her.  If you're not close, then maybe this is an opportunity to be. Try and be really open and non judgemental and find out why she doesn't wish to observe hijab. It may just be down to ignorance: she simply doesn't know its importance in islam. You'd be surprised what kind of interesting conversations you'd have.  My brothers beliefs are fairly different to mine and fairly often we have interesting discussions/debates about all kinds of topics. He's also very open minded so I feel reassurance/comfort if I ever need to ask advice or information about a certain topic. 
×