Jump to content

Rate this topic

Recommended Posts

how can god transcend time.

Time is defined as: 

The indefinite progress of existence and events in the past, present and whole.

Since god exists does that not mean that time exists as well since time is the progress of existence and since  God exists, progress of time also takes place.

Furthermore, God bringing time into existence require time. It requires the sucession of two events. God existing along with no time and then bringing time into existence again implies the existence of time. 

God existing in no time and then bringing time into existence implies time existing. Especially the words and then signify that god bought time into existence within the framework of a bigger concept of time.

Can you help me understand how God transcends time 

Finally if God does not transcend time does that not imply that there wete an infinite number of events and hence and infinite regression can happen.

 

  •  
Edited by Qasim_Husayn

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
24 minutes ago, Qasim_Husayn said:

how can god transcend time.

Time is defined as: 

The indefinite progress of existence and events in the past, present and whole.

Since god exists does that not mean that time exists as well since time is the progress of existence and since  God exists, progress of time also takes place.

Furthermore, God bringing time into existence require time. It requires the sucession of two events. God existing along with no time and then bringing time into existence again implies the existence of time. 

God existing in no time and then bringing time into existence implies time existing. Especially the words and then signify that god bought time into existence within the framework of a bigger concept of time.

Can you help me understand how God transcends time 

Finally if God does not transcend time does that not imply that there wete an infinite number of events and hence and infinite regression can happen.

 

  •  

what @certainclarity said. Also time by itself it nothing more than a measurement. we have different instruments to measure it but of its own it is undefined. The measurement of time is done using the creations of Allah such as light, sun, stars, etc. Hence Allah preceded time because first came Allah, then the tools to measure time.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
15 minutes ago, Qasim_Husayn said:

Since god exists does that not mean that time exists as well since time is the progress of existence and since  God exists, progress of time also takes place.

Time exists as a creation , not as an equivalent to God , God is not limited to anything , when you limit God he is no longer God

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

As we define existence, existence requires persistence. But we don't even know 1/1000000 of all there is to know. We don't even know what time is or how it works. How can we presume to know The Creator? 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

DRAYGOMB's PARADOX

I have posted this before but it didn't run, I find it quite interesting ...

Definitions:

God is defined as The Conscious First Cause.  
The First Cause is That which caused Time.
Consciousness is that which lets one make a decision.
A Decision is the action of changing one’s mind from undecided to decided.
Time is the measure of change.

Premises:
Something which is caused can't be required by that which causes it.
Conclusions:
Time is required for Change.
A Decision is a Change.
Decisions require Time.
Consciousness can't let one make a decision without Time.
Consciousness requires Time.
God is Conscious.
God requires Time.
God can't be the cause of Time if God requires Time.
God isn't the cause of Time.

 

Any comments?
 

* :) 

Edited by Quisant

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Now these are just my two cents, I've asked someone about this issue who might give a better answer,

God transcends physical time but not necessarily order.

You could argue that God is confined to the "boundaries" of order. Sure. Just like how he is confined to not being able to make a 4 sided triangle. To simply be able to do either would imply logical contradictions which God is not able to do.

The lack of anything (true nothingess) existing except god, and then causing something to exist implies order. But not necessarily imply the existence of physical time forever. This is because God could have simultaneously caused space and physical time to exist.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
23 minutes ago, Qasim_Husayn said:

Now these are just my two cents, I've asked someone about this issue who might give a better answer,

God transcends physical time but not necessarily order.

You could argue that God is confined to the "boundaries" of order. Sure. Just like how he is confined to not being able to make a 4 sided triangle. To simply be able to do either would imply logical contradictions which God is not able to do.

The lack of anything (true nothingess) existing except god, and then causing something to exist implies order. But not necessarily imply the existence of physical time forever. This is because God could have simultaneously caused space and physical time to exist.

 

 

Read my post, the one just above yours: 

Something which is caused can't be required by that which causes it.

*

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 28 April 2016 at 6:15 PM, Qasim_Husayn said:

how can god transcend time.

Time is defined as: 

The indefinite progress of existence and events in the past, present and whole.

Since god exists does that not mean that time exists as well since time is the progress of existence and since  God exists, progress of time also takes place.

Furthermore, God bringing time into existence require time. It requires the sucession of two events. God existing along with no time and then bringing time into existence again implies the existence of time. 

God existing in no time and then bringing time into existence implies time existing. Especially the words and then signify that god bought time into existence within the framework of a bigger concept of time.

Can you help me understand how God transcends time 

Finally if God does not transcend time does that not imply that there wete an infinite number of events and hence and infinite regression can happen.

 

  •  

What a great question!  How do you think of these things?  I think you are gifted.  Because a lot of people don't bother asking such questions in the way that you have done.  Time is such an abstract concept!  Mashallah.  Good for you!

Let's talk about this privately if you are up for it (like over Skype).  I have a double degree in Western Philosophy and Islamic Mysticism and would love to discuss such issues and see what you think.

Ethereal

 

 

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ever heard of the question, "When did God create everything?"  Or, "When did time begin?"  Correct me if I am wrong, but this basically seems to be what you are asking.  Or you can also ask a somewhat related question,  why did He have to create at the time that He chose to create?  Why couldn't He have created it before, or why couldn't He have waited after?  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 28/04/2016 at 3:15 AM, Qasim_Husayn said:

how can god transcend time.

Time is defined as: 

The indefinite progress of existence and events in the past, present and whole.

Since god exists does that not mean that time exists as well since time is the progress of existence and since  God exists, progress of time also takes place.

Furthermore, God bringing time into existence require time. It requires the sucession of two events. God existing along with no time and then bringing time into existence again implies the existence of time. 

God existing in no time and then bringing time into existence implies time existing. Especially the words and then signify that god bought time into existence within the framework of a bigger concept of time.

Can you help me understand how God transcends time 

Finally if God does not transcend time does that not imply that there wete an infinite number of events and hence and infinite regression can happen.

 

  •  

Qasim your answers are here:

1. Explain transcend into easier words so that I may learn too

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Time applies to mortal things. It came into existence when God created creation so as he created universe time got birth along with it. And with that creation he also provided it with enough properties to last up to particular time. So, time is for creation and got Birth with creation and was prolonged for creation by the properties which were inculcated into it to withstand upto time appointed. Now, what the atheist asked you about Gid's relation with universe?  Explain so I may learn it too.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On ۱۳۹۵/۲/۹ ه‍.ش. at 2:45 AM, Qasim_Husayn said:

how can god transcend time.

How God transcend time??

To answer this question it is necessary to identify the nature of time at the beginning, after familiarity with the nature of time, we can easily understand how God transcend time? To become familiar with nature of time I refer to Mulla Sadra’s point of view about the subject under discussion he believes that time is the amount of motion and regular change which take place in the nature of all phenomenon in material world, based on this definition we easily draw the following conclusions: firstly   time is something which drive from motion and changing of the phenomenon of this world toward perfection. Secondly time is something which has close relationship with material existent because only this world is a place where change and motion take place, taking in to consideration these two conclusion it is time to realize how God transcend time? Based on Islamic teaching and Quranic verses God is not material being which are subject to change and instability, so,    God is beyond time and place .         

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 08/05/2016 at 7:58 AM, eThErEaL said:

Ever heard of the question, "When did God create everything?"  Or, "When did time begin?"  Correct me if I am wrong, but this basically seems to be what you are asking.  Or you can also ask a somewhat related question,  why did He have to create at the time that He chose to create?  Why couldn't He have created it before, or why couldn't He have waited after?  

Q:-When did God created everything ?

Answer:- God created everything when he willed.

Q:- When did time begin?

Answer:- Time begin when His will was followed by His creation.

Q:-Why did He have to create at the time that He choose to create ?

Answer:- There is not time for Him, He wills whenever He wants, He may delay it or He may make it happen. All things revolve around his will, If He chose to create, He will make it in such a way that it will do whatever He wants and otherwise.

Q:- Why couldn't He have created it before or why He couldn't have waited after ?

Answer:- Before and after are for creation. For Him, it is His will and determination and He is master of His will. He willed to create when He confirms it to Happen. After creation does not improves his knowledge so that He may do some experiment and delay its creation for improvements, His knowledge is absolute, Before is not an obstruction for Him because He is self-existing, ever-living, before every creation and after every end so there is no fear for Him that He may create  before otherwise He will get extinct.. Since there is no age for Him and there is no end for Him, and He is older of all and strongest of all. He is master of Time and everything.

Edited by Danish14

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 4/29/2016 at 11:32 AM, Quisant said:

DRAYGOMB's PARADOX

I have posted this before but it didn't run, I find it quite interesting ...

Definitions:

God is defined as The Conscious First Cause.  
The First Cause is That which caused Time.
Consciousness is that which lets one make a decision.
A Decision is the action of changing one’s mind from undecided to decided.
Time is the measure of change.

Premises:
Something which is caused can't be required by that which causes it.
Conclusions:
Time is required for Change.
A Decision is a Change.
Decisions require Time.
Consciousness can't let one make a decision without Time.
Consciousness requires Time.
God is Conscious.
God requires Time.
God can't be the cause of Time if God requires Time.
God isn't the cause of Time.

 

Any comments?
 

* :) 

" Consciousness can't let one make a decision without Time.
Consciousness requires Time. "

How do you explain dreams in which it seems you can process the information of what seems to be a day in a couple hours.

Consciousness is not bound by time.

A super AI could process an infinite number of things at once.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

We learn from the Quran that God is the originator of everything. E.g. "Say: Allah is the Creator of all things." (13:16).

This implies two states. In state A, God existed alone. In state B, God existed alongside His creation. Where A is before the act of creation, and B is after the act of creation.

But for there to be a 'before' and an 'after' requires Him to exist in time. No?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Recent Posts on ShiaChat!

    • @E.L King gave great advice. Also make sure that even if she doesn't listen, you don't let her think that you're fine with her not wearing hijab (Sayed Sistani). But you have to remember to give her the message in a way that resonates with her and is most likely to produce a response. It also doesn't mean you should stop treating her with kindness - on the condition that such treatment doesn't encourage her in her ways, in which case even breaking ties with family is wajib if it's the only way to stop them from committing sins (see Sayed Khamenei's Q and A on this topic). So pray for her and find the best way to guide her to fulfilling this important obligation.
    • As l posted during Europe's refugee "crisis". one country built something like 75-100km of border 'wall' (chain link, razor wire, and all) in a weekend following a week or more on another section of their southern border.
    • A new anti-Trump book has been released. Collusion by Luke Harding(2017). These two book reviews express skepticism over the inherent validity of any innuendo or "relationships" between Russia and Trump. ln a BBC interview, 23Nov17, Harding said this putting-Trump-in-the-Soviet/Russian-camp has been a Moscow objective since the 1980s. https://www.kirkusreviews.com/book-reviews/luke-harding/collusion-harding/  https://www.publishersweekly.com/pw/by-topic/industry-news/promotionalss/article/75310-vintage-to-release-collusion-a-new-book-on-trump-russia-controversy.html
    • Whoever is telling you "that's between her and Allah it does not concern you" is ignoring the commandment of Allah to enjoin good and forbid evil. Enjoining good and forbidding evil is even more important when it comes to your own family members. If she has her mind made up and you cannot stop her, then it is not wajib on you anymore, only then can you let it go. But if you can stop her by convincing her through dialogue and preaching, then it is wajib on you to to try. But you should never show pleasure in these actions of hers. May Allah bless you.
    • Yeah I think she's exactly the same.
×