Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
BaqiyatullahY

Shrine Of Hijr Ibn Adi Destroyed In Syria

Rate this topic

Recommended Posts

(bismillah)

(salam)

SHAFAQNA Exclusive: Al-Azhar condemned exhumation of the grave of Hojr-e-bin Odday in Syria by Al-Nasr terrorist group

http://en.shafaqna.com/shafaq/item/16411-shafaqna-exclusive-al-azhar-condemned-exhumation-of-the-grave-of-hojr-e-bin-odday-in-syria-by-al-nasr-terrorist-group.html

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

(wasalam)

The people who did this is to be condemned, whether they were digging up a real grave or just empty dirt. That said, if they dug there and found nothing, the most logical reason for it is because there was nothing there in the first place. Many of these shrines that people venerate (Shi`a and non-Shi`a) are like that, built over sites where no one is actually buried, or where someone else is buried who was later decided to be the figure of another religion. For instance in Aleppo there's one grave that they say that Khidr is buried at. Khidr..? He's not even supposed to be dead..

In the case of Hijr (ra), you have to wonder how Shi`as would know he was buried there to be able to build a shrine over it, when it's pretty doubtful Mu`awiya would have been announcing to them where he had him buried, and then for Shi`as to have kept the memory of that in the in the Ummayad capital itself. From what I gather, much of these "Shi`a" shrines are more recent constructions done by the Iranians (and promoted by them). Even the most famous of them, the shrine of Sayyida Zaynab (as) - the very shrine whose protection so many Shi`as are using to justify their support of a tyrant - is of pretty doubtful authenticity a largely a recent construction. There's no reference in our books to it, no recommendation to visit there, and no evidence even Shi`as for centuries had any idea there was a place there for them to visit. The first reference to it in fact is from a very late medieval Sunni author who mentions local Shi`a women in the area would visit the place thinking it was where she was buried, but that they were wrong in thinking so. Keep in mind the other places she is said to also buried, and it raises the level of doubtfulness about this.

(salam)

Do you only believe what you see in a hadith book? There is no doubt about the grave of Hadhrat Hujr (as) - there are people that can see the light enamating from these graves, they don't need books to tell them what they can see.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

yes I would expect there'd be at least a single mention of it in our books somewhere.

Are you sure you don't mean to say "..in your books.."? Because last time I checked, you don't actually have any books, well you have one...but that was preserved by an ithna ashari scholar, the irony.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

(salam)

Can somebody shed some light on this alleged photo of the body of Hujr bin Adi doing rounds over the internet?

I saw it; I doubt it is the body - will need to see a credible source for it instead of just a Facebook post.

post-19560-0-57138300-1367839720_thumb.j

How did blood get on his face? Looks more like a gun shot or explosion wounds. I don't know the details of Hijr's murder, but I am assuming he would have been beheaded or buried alive. . . ?

Wassalam

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

(salam)

I saw it; I doubt it is the body - will need to see a credible source for it instead of just a Facebook post.

post-19560-0-57138300-1367839720_thumb.j

How did blood get on his face? Looks more like a gun shot or explosion wounds. I don't know the details of Hijr's murder, but I am assuming he would have been beheaded or buried alive. . . ?

Wassalam

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

from the empirical evidence, it seems that while he died he was on his right side, according to sources he was buried alive, so i imagine he would have positioned himself to his right to face the Qiblah, and the blood came from his nose due to suffocation , and ran down his face as can be seen that his nose is bloody

or it could be that he was beat or hit and split on the face, those people were the cruelest people who did this to them so there is no surprise to the way they would have handled him, and do remember this was the lead up to kerbala, so their hearts were reaching the pinnacle of evil

the blood would never dry up just the same way the blood of Imam Husayn doesnt dry up in his shrine, especially since this man died for the love of ameer ul mumineen , im sure God would have honored him greatly

Edited by yukapuka

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

from the empirical evidence, it seems that while he died he was on his right side, according to sources he was buried alive, so i imagine he would have positioned himself to his right to face the Qiblah, and the blood came from his nose due to suffocation , and ran down his face as can be seen that his nose is bloody

or it could be that he was beat or hit and split on the face, those people were the cruelest people who did this to them so there is no surprise to the way they would have handled him, and do remember this was the lead up to kerbala, so their hearts were reaching the pinnacle of evil

the blood would never dry up just the same way the blood of Imam Husayn doesnt dry up in his shrine, especially since this man died for the love of ameer ul mumineen , im sure God would have honored him greatly

Yeah, I think that too.

But Allahu Yal3am.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

this is source.. but sure not what is written... can you translate please?

http://emadnews.com/?p=101221

Used with translate (however, you get some good points, and it is to understand):

Alghvth Sharqiya television news network that depends on the Syrian opponents after victory was announced, it was claimed that the emitting body image, "Happy Hijr bin Adi 'is.

The Madnyvz: Salafis and Wahhabis after the news of attacks on holy shrines extreme "Hijr bin Uday" and snatching bodies adjunct to the Holy Imam Ali (as), Sharqiya Alghvth video news release that is dependent on Syrian opponents after victory has been claimed This picture belongs to a holy effigy "Adi Ben Stone", from the Companions of the Prophet (SAW) and Ali (as) is.

It should be noted that no credible source of this image has not confirmed or denied.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This photo was shown on Hidayat tv and there was an hour long discussion about it. It was claimed it is the body of Hujur bin Adi (ra) How authentic is it though?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This photo was shown on Hidayat tv and there was an hour long discussion about it. It was claimed it is the body of Hujur bin Adi (ra) How authentic is it though?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest

(salam)

I saw it; I doubt it is the body - will need to see a credible source for it instead of just a Facebook post.

post-19560-0-57138300-1367839720_thumb.j

How did blood get on his face? Looks more like a gun shot or explosion wounds. I don't know the details of Hijr's murder, but I am assuming he would have been beheaded or buried alive. . . ?

Wassalam

he was beaten by muawiyahs henchmen before being buried. He asked to be buried in the same way he died without a kaffan and with chains on him because he wanted to be raised like that to confront muawiyah in front of Allah (swt). The picture was taken from the wahabis that dug up the graves phone because they couldnt believe how fresh the body still looked. Then they attempted to take the body out and but the soil kept falling over it, after a while of trying to remove the soil they gave up and climbed back out only to be greeted by an angry mob of shias who killed them.

The whole incident was witnessed by the caretaker of the shrine. The pictures were shown across many shia news networks such as Hidayat tv,

I think we should take it with a pinch of salt however it could very possibly be him since it is the grave and the picture was taken at the site.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It is said, that the body is Omar al Mokhtar.

post-19560-0-57138300-1367839720_thumb.jpg

a12796c0f4441600dd922990ac90189b.jpg

Brother, no where in the film the body is portrayed like that and even it does not resemble Antony Quinn. You can watch the whole film. I bet you wont find that face or position of body.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Brother, no where in the film the body is portrayed like that and even it does not resemble Antony Quinn. You can watch the whole film. I bet you wont find that face or position of body.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

All SC members, Macisac did raise some valid points but if we delve deeper into his argument, there might be some problems. I am sure there is a dispute as to where Imam Ali (as) is buried, Najaf is one place mentioned in the shi'a narration. If anyone here can reproduce it, it will be beneficial.

Earlier the shrine of Ammar ibn Yassir (ra) was bombed, did the shias raise a similar cry? i hope they did, because Ammar ibn Yassir (ra) is one of the outstanding companion of the Prophet (saw) and Imam Ali (as), I wouldnt be surprised if Mr. Bukhari were to exclude him from the list of companions.

The point that we should all focus including Mac is that these are symbols, shaeer of Islam and Tashayyu' and to destroy them is a symbolic message to the shias at large, that we are out to hunt each and every rafidhi! this is the message, dead or alive!

Lets not dilute its importance with other humanitarian one. MacIsac, with all due respect we are concerned about the humanitarian situation in Syria. You have to see the bigger picture, let me put to you who is leading the revolt? salafis or the broader sunnis. Now how many Ahadith these same people brought to justify the rule of Yazeed? Didnt their supremo Ibn Umar state clearly to do bay'ah even to an oppressor? and we have the statement of salafi sheikhs to further support this.

Isnt it haram to revolt against a ruler and knowing that it will cause greater harm to the people?

This is their stand, now you see these filthy wahabis reverse 360 degrees? what a shame.

Our concern is not about keeping the Asad government in place but to make sure the shi'as are safe and the symbols of Islam are guarded. The salafis will never forgive the shias once their in charge of Damascus, mass murder and rape will follow. There is no point in talking about humanity if it is self-inflicted, there is no democracy in Syria but the Assad government has never divided its population along sectarian lines. The majority of the Syrian army are sunnis but the wahabis do takfeer on them.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It is said, that the body is Omar al Mokhtar.

post-19560-0-57138300-1367839720_thumb.jpg

a12796c0f4441600dd922990ac90189b.jpg

بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم

السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركته

`Umar Mukhtaar was hanged from the neck until death, that picture of a dead old man has a bloodied head. Doubtful it's the same person.

والسلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركته

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم

السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركته

`Umar Mukhtaar was hanged from the neck until death, that picture of a dead old man has a bloodied head. Doubtful it's the same person.

والسلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركته

Well, yeah. But the film shows, that he got hanged?

All SC members, Macisac did raise some valid points but if we delve deeper into his argument, there might be some problems. I am sure there is a dispute as to where Imam Ali (as) is buried, Najaf is one place mentioned in the shi'a narration. If anyone here can reproduce it, it will be beneficial.

Earlier the shrine of Ammar ibn Yassir (ra) was bombed, did the shias raise a similar cry? i hope they did, because Ammar ibn Yassir (ra) is one of the outstanding companion of the Prophet (saw) and Imam Ali (as), I wouldnt be surprised if Mr. Bukhari were to exclude him from the list of companions.

The point that we should all focus including Mac is that these are symbols, shaeer of Islam and Tashayyu' and to destroy them is a symbolic message to the shias at large, that we are out to hunt each and every rafidhi! this is the message, dead or alive!

Lets not dilute its importance with other humanitarian one. MacIsac, with all due respect we are concerned about the humanitarian situation in Syria. You have to see the bigger picture, let me put to you who is leading the revolt? salafis or the broader sunnis. Now how many Ahadith these same people brought to justify the rule of Yazeed? Didnt their supremo Ibn Umar state clearly to do bay'ah even to an oppressor? and we have the statement of salafi sheikhs to further support this.

Isnt it haram to revolt against a ruler and knowing that it will cause greater harm to the people?

This is their stand, now you see these filthy wahabis reverse 360 degrees? what a shame.

Our concern is not about keeping the Asad government in place but to make sure the shi'as are safe and the symbols of Islam are guarded. The salafis will never forgive the shias once their in charge of Damascus, mass murder and rape will follow. There is no point in talking about humanity if it is self-inflicted, there is no democracy in Syria but the Assad government has never divided its population along sectarian lines. The majority of the Syrian army are sunnis but the wahabis do takfeer on them.

Wrong. Ammar bin Yassirs shrine wasn't destroyed. It wasn't his shrine.

Edited by Ali-F

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم

السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركته

What does Lion of the Desert have to do with it? Yes he got hanged in the movie too, but his hanging is a historical fact.

والسلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركته

Yes, so you say that the picture isn't Omar al Mokhtar (Lion of Desert?) - so, it could be Hujr?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

Sign in to follow this  

  • Recent Posts on ShiaChat!

    • If you want to know what the conclusion of an article is, as well as the arguments, then generally yes you have to read it. Otherwise, I will summarize here, then you'll reply with something I already considered in the article, and it will take a very long and frustrating thread to get the point across. If you have the time to post several comments on this thread, then you have the time to read it. It takes less than a fifth of the time to read than it does to write.

      As for science, part 3 deals with that.
    • In every church. The commands are 3.000 years old, from a time when Israelis still were polytheists and sacrificed animals to Gods on hilltops. In my understandng the idol ban was not a ban on photograps or sculptures, but a ban on worshipping Baal and other semitic Gods. Only the God Jahwe was to be worshipped by the Israelis.   
    • isn't there "Jesus/god" on the cross in about every  church?
    • دانلود نوحه علی اکبر از نزار القطری نوحه ( آهنگ مذهبی ) بسیار زیبای نزار قطری که به زبان فارسی اجرا شده متن نوحه علی اکبر + دانلود    Persian/Arabic Lyric علی علی اکبر علی علی شبه پیمبر علی علی شبه پیمبر علی علی ای جانم تازه جوانم مرا تو جانم در جانی  ای جانم با اشک سردم مرا تو دردم درمانی  ای جانم ریحانه المک  یول دووم مک  بکفایی ای گل حیدر ای گل حیدر علی علی شبه پیمبر علی علی شبه پیمبر علی علی ای جانم ای علی اکبر سرو صنوبر رعنایی  ای جانم بر دو لبانم همی بخوانم لالایی  ای جانم یحلا لشبتک دمئی وسوفتک باسمایی امید مادر   علی علی ای همچو کوثر  علی علی   رنگم پریده ای سر بریده ای ماهم ای جانم قدم خمیده ای نور دیده بر راهم   ای جانم یا علی ابنی  فک دک یدب دب نو هوهم با تیر و خنجر  علی علی وداع مادر علی علی شوم  فدایت  کنم دعایت با حسرت ای جانم یوسف لیلا جوان برنا بر راهت ای جانم حایل مسییت  نوع عرضیی لوئلایی الله اکبر علی علی ای یار و یاور علی علی هنگام پیری دستم بگیری فرزندم ای جان هم  ارزویم تو را ببویم دلبندم ای جانم بس مادر تک من وک دعه تک یم شیی یم با دیده تر علی علی تا روز محشر  علی علی    ای جانم بود و نبودم با تار و پودم اکبر بود  ای جانم بسی که شب ها ذکرت به لبها کوثر بود  سحر ال لیالی دم ال لحالی لا کش عود ای گشته پر پر علی علی بی فرش و بستر علی علی   ای جانم چشم انتظارم لحظه شمارم  ای مادر   ای جانم بین حال زارم من بی قرارم  ای نورم  لا ماه ال بال و دم لا جال بد عبا ای ماه انور علی علی در بین عسکر جانم علی  http://nakaman.ir/3770/دانلود-نوحه-علی-اکبر-از-نزار-القطری.html
    • http://www.zakeran.com/2016/10/download-maddahi-new-ali-akbar-qatar/ علی علی اکبر علی علی شبه پیمبر علی علی شبه پیمبر علی علی ای جانم تازه جوانم مرا تو جانم در جانی ای جانم با اشک سردم مرا تو دردم درمانی ای جانم ریحانه المک  یول دووم مک  بکفایی ای گل حیدر ای گل حیدر علی علی شبه پیمبر علی علی شبه پیمبر علی علی ای جانم ای علی اکبر سرو صنوبر رعنایی ای جانم بر دو لبانم همی بخوانم لالایی ای جانم یحلا لشبتک دمئی وسوفتک باسمایی امید مادر   علی علی ای همچو کوثر  علی علی رنگم پریده ای سر بریده ای ماهم ای جانم قدم خمیده ای نور دیده بر راهم   ای جانم یا علی ابنی  فک دک یدب دب نو هوهم با تیر و خنجر  علی علی وداع مادر علی علی شوم  فدایت  کنم دعایت با حسرت ای جانم یوسف لیلا جوان برنا بر راهت ای جانم حایل مسییت  نوع عرضیی لوئلایی الله اکبر علی علی ای یار و یاور علی علی هنگام پیری دستم بگیری فرزندم ای جان هم  ارزویم تو را ببویم دلبندم ای جانم بس مادر تک من وک دعه تک یم شیی یم با دیده تر علی علی تا روز محشر  علی علی ای جانم بود و نبودم با تار و پودم اکبر بود ای جانم بسی که شب ها ذکرت به لبها کوثر بود سحر ال لیالی دم ال لحالی لا کش عود ای گشته پر پر علی علی بی فرش و بستر علی علی ای جانم چشم انتظارم لحظه شمارم  ای مادر ای جانم بین حال زارم من بی قرارم  ای نورم لا ماه ال بال و دم لا جال بد عبا ای ماه انور علی علی در بین عسکر جانم علی https://niazejahan.net/14957/دانلود-نوحه-عربی-فارسی-علی-اکبر-نزار/ http://dl.niazejahan.net/nohe/nezar/03_Nezar_AliAkbar_Almoin.Ir.mp3
×