Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
Ibn al-Hussain

The Umar Series On Mbc

Rate this topic

Recommended Posts

(salam)

Is anyone following the new Umar series on MBC? You can watch the episodes in Arabic online here: http://shahid.mbc.net/media/program/408

Unfortunately I'm not a native Arabic speaker, so no point watching it since I can't understand anything, but is it any good? From the few clips that I saw it seems they are covering the story from the Prophet's time onward (freeing of Bilal by Abu Bakr etc.).

Also, apparently they are showing the faces of some of the popular companions including Imam Ali and Umar - have any Sunni scholars spoken about this?

Wassalam

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

(wasalam)

I watched some of an episode; and saw they depicted 'Abu Bakr, 'Umar and I believe Khaalid bin Walid. The Saudi and Egyptian Sunni clergy have gone bonkers over it;

http://www.saudigazette.com.sa/index.cfm?method=home.regcon&contentid=20120710129528 (interestingly enough, they don't mention 'Imaam Ali's (as) depiction in this article)

http://www.emirates247.com/entertainment/films-music/top-saudi-cleric-slams-tv-series-on-umar-set-for-ramadan-telecast-2012-07-07-1.466119

http://www.emirates247.com/news/region/saudi-prince-vows-to-stop-tv-film-on-muslim-caliph-2012-07-16-1.467428 (this "prince" wanting to take the network to court?)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

(bismillah)

(salam)

Salafis tend to generally be against it because it shows the faces of Sahaba and some of the actors are not exactly known for their piety. Plus the problem with a number of these series is that they're not completely historically accurate so some people see something on the show and they think that's what actually happened even though that may have just been something that the director or a writer made up to be epic or to kill some time, etc.

Details:

While i am of the view that it is extremely important to use media like movies to spread Islam, i would prefer it if they didn't show the faces of especially 'Ali (as) and the Prophet (pbuh) and there should be scholars who are consulted for every detail in the movie, because in a way, these movies/series are like hadiths; you're telling people what happened, and since this involves religion and actual events, we should be accurate.

And Allah(swt) knows best.

Edited by ImamAliLover

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Besides the very obvious issues with the show, it's got pretty good cinematography.

I think that's only advantage of the show. The money they spent on it really worked because the outcome looks very modern, something you would expect from the US.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I might have picked up on something incorrect, but why was Umar by The Prophet (SAW) when he made Hajra into Medina? From what I recall within Hadiths & History, Umar wanted to kill The Prophet (SAW) while he was ALREADY in Medina. Sounds like they just exalted Umar a bunch.

Unless that guy in brown turban and dress isn't Umar...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Are they going to show Umar running away from battle :)

They show everyone Ali included, it is so amazing,

Arent you guys strictly against showing faces of sahaba? And i think some of you even go to the extent of calling it an act of kufr.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I might have picked up on something incorrect, but why was Umar by The Prophet (SAW) when he made Hajra into Medina? From what I recall within Hadiths & History, Umar wanted to kill The Prophet (SAW) while he was ALREADY in Medina. Sounds like they just exalted Umar a bunch.

Unless that guy in brown turban and dress isn't Umar...

Umar became Muslim before hijra, around 616.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I hope the people who object to the faces of the actors playing the Prophet (pbuh) and Imam `Ali (a) being shown also object to the faces of Maryam عليها السلام, Nabi `Isa, Nabi Sulayman, and Nabi Yusuf عليهم السلام, among others being shown in popular films and TV series.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

(salam)

Can someone go to 23:25 onward and confirm that the lady shown there is meant to be Lady Fatima (sa):

I think thats Abu Bakr (ra)'s daughter

Arent you guys strictly against showing faces of sahaba? And i think some of you even go to the extent of calling it an act of kufr.

Not Sahaba, the 10 promised paradise.

Edited by Dagga

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I hope the people who object to the faces of the actors playing the Prophet (pbuh) and Imam `Ali (a) being shown also object to the faces of Maryam عليها السلام, Nabi `Isa, Nabi Sulayman, and Nabi Yusuf عليهم السلام, among others being shown in popular films and TV series.

Yawn...Muslims dont like their holy personalities to be displayed on screen or in pictures. There is no reason/indication otherwise for you to post this.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yawn...Muslims dont like their holy personalities to be displayed on screen or in pictures. There is no reason/indication otherwise for you to post this.

Yawn...Muslims dont like their holy personalities to be displayed on screen or in pictures. There is no reason/indication otherwise for you to post this.

This is so coz of their internal love for each other............ :donno:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yawn...Muslims dont like their holy personalities to be displayed on screen or in pictures. There is no reason/indication otherwise for you to post this.

Right...

etc...

All these films are made in Iran.

Seems the only time most Shias have a problem with faces been shown is when it comes to the Ahlulbayt (as). Fallibles like Zaynab bint `Ali are given more respect than infallible Prophets.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Seems the only time most Shias have a problem with faces been shown is when it comes to the Ahlulbayt (as). Fallibles like Zaynab bint `Ali are given more respect than infallible Prophets.

If you are mentioning them being depicted in film, then In all fairness, Zaynab bint 'Ali was a Muslim woman who would have her face veiled so they wouldn't be able to show it anyway. The Prophets (as) would probably not have their faces veiled.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you are mentioning them being depicted in film, then In all fairness, Zaynab bint 'Ali was a Muslim woman who would have her face veiled so they wouldn't be able to show it anyway. The Prophets (as) would probably not have their faces veiled.

The other women at Karbala were Muslim women with veiled faces as well, yet they were not portrayed in the same way (their faces or at least eyes were shown). Additionally, according to many reports, their face veils were ripped off in the aftermath of the battle, and they were not wearing them on the way to Shaam.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Besides the very obvious issues with the show, it's got pretty good cinematography.

Agreed, the Arabic is easy to understand as well. I'm glad they didn't mix in dialects.

The cinematography is better than those Iranian ones.

Edited by Hannibal

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

Sign in to follow this  

  • Recent Posts on ShiaChat!

    • That doesn't quite make sense to me if I were to be honest with you. I'm being forced to live, I'm suppose to just randomly cope with life and deal with everything pretending like it's ok. And when it becomes to much to handle and I give up there's a bigger punishment waiting. Ppl say pray make dua do good deeds.......I've been doing nothing but that. I'm begging to feel like islam is fake. Partly why I'm willing to take this risk.
    • Why does that even matter?! Your basically saying "no don't kill yourself forget what your going through just keep up with that good reputation!!"
    • Imam Jafar al Sadiq a.s replied in context to infatuation. What do you think about what was the condition of your attraction towards that guy ? Were you infatuated by his personality or attracted by morals and behavior. Have you loved him due to being of good faith or good personality. If you loved him due to good faith, then you loved him due to Allah and if you loved him due to his personality, then you loved him due to materialistic aims and one who has materialism in his spirit, will learn one day that materials do not live by his side always. And if one learns such lesson with the departure of materialistic sooner, it would be much better. 
    • yes. and we know they already knew because of the ahadith that i mentioned. as for why their knowledge/question is not mentioned in the quran, if that is what you are asking, then only Allah knows. absence of evidence is not evidence of absence. basic principle of logic.
    • Ya Akhi, I think you have not pondered what I have mentioned.  Verse 33:33 mentions that Abu Bakar, Umer and Usman were not true Khalifas appointed by Allah because they are not infallible which is one condition for Imamate or Caliphate which is mentioned in Quran [Shakir 76:24] Therefore wait patiently for the command of your Lord, and obey not from among them a sinner or an ungrateful one. Since all three of them were sinners and fallible so they are ruled out of 12 Imams of Quraish.  Secondly, Verse 33:33 Proves that Imams are only from Ahlebait of Prophet PBUHHP and they were Muhammad, Ali, Fatima, Hasan and Hussain and the following Imams. This was the reason that the Imams after them were called Sons of Prophets.  Another Evidence was from yourself which you gave from Nehjul Balagha which proves that we Shias are right in saying that Bibi Ayesha, Talha and Zubayr did mistakes and violated their oath which they took before Imam Ali a.s. Now, if you accept the above facts, I would further go on providing you traditions about Ghadeer-e-Khum and if you do not say that Bibi Ayesha, Talha and Zubayr did not do wrong, then why wasting my time and yours bro ? 
       
×