Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
Mahdiyah

Imam Ali (as) - Tall Or Short ?

Rate this topic

Recommended Posts

If he was short, he would've looked fat, as according to reports, he was very muscular. Furthermore, if he was short, he would not have had the ability to lift the door of Khaibar. Its more likely for someone tall and muscular to lift something that heavy. Compared to Walid father of Khalid and Amr bin Abdu Wudd, who were built along the lines of the Bigshow from WWE, he was slightly shorter, yet all reports indicate that he had a well proportioned body.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

he was of medium build and skinny

als in regards to lifting the door of khaibar, he said that he did it with the power of the ruh

there is a hadeeth that after the battle of khaibar Imam Ali and the companions returned and Imam Ali got an old piece of bread to break and eat and he could not sucessfully break the bread(i.e he struggled) and the companions said "Ya Ali we just saw u lift a door at Khaibar that 40 men are needed to lift, and you are now struggling to break this dry bread?" the Imam replied " when i lifted the door of khaibar i did it with the power of the ruh because it was for Islam, and now when i try to break this bread , this is for me which i do with my own self "

Edited by yukapuka

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The Ayema (a.s) were all prefect all around. They couldn't be too short or too tall, too slim or overwight.

Height depends on genetics. When we say 'they were prefect' we do not refer to what they were, but who they were.

It's not what they were, it's what they did they defined them.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If he was short, he would've looked fat, as according to reports, he was very muscular. Furthermore, if he was short, he would not have had the ability to lift the door of Khaibar. Its more likely for someone tall and muscular to lift something that heavy. Compared to Walid father of Khalid and Amr bin Abdu Wudd, who were built along the lines of the Bigshow from WWE, he was slightly shorter, yet all reports indicate that he had a well proportioned body.

You do realise many short guys look extremely muscular due to the fact shorter guys find that they obtain muscle/it spread out much quicker/easier, and for a tall guy, it's much harder?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Imam Ali (as) surely had to be very fit considering how many battles he participated in. I understand if someone might point out he was skinny because when he would fast to be closer to Allah there would usually be a begger asking foe food fron the Imam. Thus leaving him with nothing but some water and a very small portion of bread if any.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

He was of medium height for the Arabs of that time.

Imam Ali (as) was the same height as the Prophet (pbuh). He would've had to be the same height/build, how else would the assasins have not seen that it was someone else in the Prophet's (pbuh) bed?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You do realise many short guys look extremely muscular due to the fact shorter guys find that they obtain muscle/it spread out much quicker/easier, and for a tall guy, it's much harder?

Was he not the father ofHazrat Abbas?The battle of Siffin was Hazrat Abbas's first battle, yet many confused him with Imam Ali. Even if Hazrat Abbas got his 7 foot height from his maternal side, how could the enemies fail to distinguish between a seven foot tall man and a short man?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Was he not the father ofHazrat Abbas?The battle of Siffin was Hazrat Abbas's first battle, yet many confused him with Imam Ali. Even if Hazrat Abbas got his 7 foot height from his maternal side, how could the enemies fail to distinguish between a seven foot tall man and a short man?

Hz. Abbas was 13 years old (or somewhere around that age) at the time of Siffin. He was not done growing. If he was that tall when he was fully grown then he could've easily been the height of an average adult at such a young age when he was still growing.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Spiritual height or physical height?

If you are talking about His (A.S.) physical height then it was enough to cleave the enemies of islam into two.....be those include shayba, amr bin abd'bud, marhub o antar or those who tried to harm Rasool Allah (saww) in uhad when the munafiqeen in the muslim army ran away like cowards.

Ask me about the stature of those who would flee on sight of Janab-e-Ammer-ul-Momineen (A.S.) with Zulfiqar Drawn or those who carry spite and malice against Buturab (A.S.)

As for his Spiritual Height....how can a speck of dust like me or you fathom the height of He who knew the ways in heavens better than we know the ways in this world.

Edited by kaash

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Imam Ali (AS) and the Prophet(SAWW) were exactly the same height and also same in many other ways. They were medium at height which means that they weren't short and neither were they very tall. Probably around five ten

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
18 hours ago, Mohsin Bokhari said:

Imam Ali (AS) and the Prophet(SAWW) were exactly the same height and also same in many other ways. They were medium at height which means that they weren't short and neither were they very tall. Probably around five ten

I know it doesn't matter but just FYI Imam (A.S) was shorter than Prophet (SAWW)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 24/10/2017 at 2:08 PM, Ron_Burgundy said:

I know it doesn't matter but just FYI Imam (A.S) was shorter than Prophet (SAWW)

It does matter. People use these very petty issues to reduce the maqaam of Imam Ali(AS). It shouldn't really matter at all whether he was tall or short but the truth is that he wasn't so we shouldn't undertake these things

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 10/26/2017 at 3:38 PM, Mohsin Bokhari said:

It does matter. People use these very petty issues to reduce the maqaam of Imam Ali(AS). It shouldn't really matter at all whether he was tall or short but the truth is that he wasn't so we shouldn't undertake these things

Long story short After Prophet (SAWW) he was the best. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

He was neither tall nor short, he had broad shoulders, he had strong arms, he was bald on top of his head. His beard reached his chest. He had several scars in his body and one massive scar from Uhud. His eyes where kind and soft and his face was pleasing to the eyes.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

Sign in to follow this  

  • Recent Posts on ShiaChat!

    • Seal of the Prophets, Prophet Muhammad al Mustafa, (peace be upon him and his pure progeny) the best of the creation, the best example to follow for you, the one who has more right on you then you yourself. Is off limits to your conversations? its a deal breaker. So, who's Sunnah are you using/ discussing/ following as a role model in formulating your plans for the Caliphate?  It seems like its a political meeting, for political power struggle.     
    • I wonder if it is enough for a person to believe in Islam until they die to be eternally in heaven eventually? I mean maybe a person would not believe if they were subject to torture but since they are not subject to torture they believe. For example a Muslim maybe never experience much hardships with being a believer and he/she believes but if he/she were put under much hardship they would disbelieve. Must a Muslim believe no matter what or can they just rely on that if they believed in this life then they will someday enter heaven? 
    • Guest Boy
      I m 28yrs old .I started praying since last year. I was not knowing the importance of praying.My parents never told me to pray .They were only after my studies.I was busy in my life not knowing the real purpose if life  . I new nothing about what are the duties of muslim. Then Allah guided me at the age of 27 and i started going to masjid . Now i regret why was i so far away from my deen for so many years.Some questions kill me everyday ..Why didnt allahs guidance came early .? .I have to make up for so many prayers.i have asked Allah for forgiveness .Why i hav to still make up?. Is it too late age to get guided ?  Like i have done nothing no namaz no roza ..when my parents never told me about deen how am i responsible ? Now i ask Allah for forgiveness why i still have to make up for qada ?? If i make niyat of making qada after some years is it ok  or i hav to start praying qada ??When were u ppl guided to do these things ? I am feeling very bad..Whatever we learn from childhood imprints in heart ..i have learnt nothing..share ur views please
    • This is not possible because this is a breach of the basis of unity. When its decided that we are not going to discuss about our beliefs. Scholars can sit together and discuss all this but this can't be done in a public scenario.
    • Quran has not talked about the punishment of Apostaty in this world. But we have Sahih hadeeths from Imams. Quran doesn't tell everything explicitly.  When Imam Ali said that "all secrets and knowledge is condensed in Quran" then it means we can't access it but they can. So its better to be satisfied with the hadeetha and Marajes have done a lot of study to accept these hadeeth and Law. And you're not being killed for your belief but your action. Flee to any other Non Muslim country and you're free but if you harm Muslim society by your Apostasy then you are ought to be killed as you are a corrupter.
×