Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
new-shia-naqvi

How Tall Is Imam Ali (as) And Prophet (saw)

Rate this topic

Recommended Posts

i heard there was an event where the prophet (saw) held up imam Ali(as) on his (saw) shoulders to destroy idols ontop of the kaba

now i looked at the size of the kaba, it would take a good 15 people to reach the top of the kaba, so was this a mirracle or the actual height of the prophet (saw) and Ali (as)?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

(salam)

Rasoolallah (as) and Imam Ali (as) weren't really taller then normal human beings ( I believe)

But back in the day, the prophets used to be extremely tall (like giants) which is why some of their graves are sooooo long.

I dont believe the Kaaba was any smaller back when the prophet was alive, but I could be wrong.

Maybe someone else could shed more light on this topic, sorry I couldnt be of more help.

(salam)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Zulfiqar (Imam Ali's Sword) was as tall as him (as). I think there are narrations about battles where his sword plus him would be around 12 - 14 feet in height (when raised) So you can estimate Imam Ali's height from this.

The Prophet (pbuh) must have been really strong to uphold the weight of Amirul Momineen on his shoulders when they were destroying the idols.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Zulfiqar (Imam Ali's Sword) was as tall as him (as). I think there are narrations about battles where his sword plus him would be around 12 - 14 feet in height (when raised) So you can estimate Imam Ali's height from this.

The Prophet (pbuh) must have been really strong to uphold the weight of Amirul Momineen on his shoulders when they were destroying the idols.

Wowowowow What the hell did you say?!??! Zulfiqar long as a human? WOW.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Zulfiqar (Imam Ali's Sword) was as tall as him (as). I think there are narrations about battles where his sword plus him would be around 12 - 14 feet in height (when raised) So you can estimate Imam Ali's height from this.

The Prophet (pbuh) must have been really strong to uphold the weight of Amirul Momineen on his shoulders when they were destroying the idols.

Imam Ali asws was asked: who according to you is the bravest (warrior). He asws said: it is rasool Allah saww.

Ya Ali Madad

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

According to genealogists our ancestors were all taller than us (averagely speaking). The interesting Question would be exactly how tall was the first Man on earth (Prophet Adam a.s). As time ensues, man produces himself in larger quantities but smaller in height. So in layman terms, the greater the population the smaller the height....

I have been to Israel, Syria and Egypt and after seeing some of the burial sites of past Prophets or relations, I was surprised that some of the lengths of these graves were almost 16-20 feet long. But who knows....maybe they are just made that way.

About Imam Alis (as) sword being as big as him....this is not actually true and if it is, I haven't come across any tradition to support this view. Some traditions do inform that Imam Ali (as) was not the tallest of his circles of companions but was broad and strong boned....and that the edge of his double edged sword was long enough to be seen hanging down to his feet. These traditions dictated the idea that during the desert expeditions one of the ways to identify the Imam amongst his companions was the visualization of the Sword and hence sometimes when people give lectures about his Mightiness at war this tradition comes to light and often is portrayed as if the Sword was as big as him.

Other traditions which are actually more metaphorically applied than literally is the often mentioning of the Imams sword breaking during clashes with the enemies. The traditions report that when the Sword broke the size of the remaining blade in one occasion was as small as the imams own hand and hence when the Dhul-Fiqar became available is poetically suggested that the sword not only did not break but in the battles was as tall as the imam....an expression which means "It stood out from the crowd"....I personally believe this is relation to the style of the Imam's fighting technique and the unique style of the double edged sword itself rather than the sword being as big as the Imam.

I could be wrong!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

Sign in to follow this  

  • Recent Posts on ShiaChat!

    • Why people make Islam so hard? No ideas. Is not hard. People just complicating stuff in my opinion. I don't see anything to support your claim.
    • Where is water cooked? This remind me the day the Syrians got into Europe and they where given bottles of water to drink and they started throwing the water away and then complained of being thirsty.
    • Salam. You asked a good question and I admire your sensitivity to the Holy Month of Muharram. A refrigerator is a necessity especially for someone who needs to store a medication cooler than room temperature. There is no problem with buying something you need in Muharram, just try to do your shopping before or after the 9th (Tasua) and the 10th (Ashura). Those two days are when Imam Hussein AS and his companions in Karbala lost their lives and we should honor them by mourning. 
    • Shi'as that look down upon you because of your name are probably unaware to the fact that the Imams named their children with your name as well. You are actually doing us a great service brother. Many Sunnis often ask the Shi'a why we don't name our children and follow the sunnah of the Imams who named their children 'Umar, 'Uthman, or Aisha. You are helping us prove that we do indeed name our children the way the Imams named their children (although these names are indeed seldom heard nowadays). It's true that such names have negativity associated with them because of certain personalities in Islam's history, but they are also associated with some of the greatest personalities as well. If you look at recent blog entries, brother Islamic Salvation has some great posts on 'Uthman b. Madh'un, a great companion of the Prophet. Imam Ali also named a son with your blessed name. - Abu al-Faraj said: Uthman b. Ali about whom it is narrated from Ali that he said: I name him with the name of my brother Uthman b. Madh`un.
    • What is Zibhe Azeem? What Argha? Sorry I'm still fairly new and don't understand many things. 
×