Salaam wr wb.
I was having a discussion with a Salafi brother, and I linked him here: http://www.answering...ah/en/chap6.php
He says he checked the book and asked a scholar as well, and no luck in finding those alleged sayings from the Answering-Ansar website. I checked Wikipedia and I see it says the Minhaj al Sunnah is a 4 volume book. I assume they mean the original Arabic is 4 volumes. On the AA website it references some of the sayings with volume 8, so I'm wondering if anyone knows if they got the information from a translated text and then just added the Arabic along with it; and also if anyone knows which translation they used, because this Salafi is pretty adamant that such statements are not in the Minhaj al Sunnah book. JazakAllah to any that can help me out.
Edited by gogiison2, 05 May 2010 - 03:07 PM.