Jump to content

Recommended Posts

.

thank for suggestion..i'll visit there one day.But about "What is Sunni ? what is Shia ?" question, I'm not quit sure bout it. Maybe its from layMuslims. But not with layMuslims witk little knowledge. From what I've read through the net, some Indonesia's web surfer quit familiar with shia sunni thingy. If we ask same question, the answer will be "We are Sunni. Shia are misguided." Countless of debate, plenty of argument.....But not all of them,..because there are plenty of Shia w'site in Indonesia which mean lot of followrs of AhlBayt there. Also, in the same time, I watched JAB personality like Kang Jalal, Haddad Alwi..aired on tv. ...That's confusing... but glad to hear where MUI stand on this issue. Here, the only hi-lite for JAB is when there's a raid.

Habaib...yeah I reliaze that. I listened to habib lecture especially Habib Munzir. Its like in Yaman...where decendant called habib and respected. I believe there are Habib who follow MazAhlBayt too, right? That's wonderful. How tolerant is that, brother? Is it if Jama'hAhlBayt solat according to Imam ( like hands on the side, prostate on turbah)...nobody will say anything? Thats nice...

Assalamualaikum.

Sorry for late answer.

My Shia uncle always fold his hands when solat except in a place where people cannot see him. Okay, okay, I admit, Shia in Indonesia are not really free to express their belief. Even there were some raids on Shia Muslims houses, and a madrasa that known as Shia base. But at least what happened to Shia Muslims in Indonesia are not so bad like in Malaysia.

Sometime I watched Habib Munzir lecture on Tv, but I often visit his website. He is an aleem from Shafi'i madhab, but in some occasion I found he defend Shia when someone said Shias are deviants. Habib Riziq follow Shafi'i madhab too, but he made friendship with some Shia ulama in Indonesia. Habib hasan Assegaf is known as Ahlul Bayt lover, and from what I know, salafi accuse him as Shia.

I was born in a family that almost all people in my family follow Shafi'i madhab. In early of my teen age I left Shafi'i and turned into non-madhab. But later I felt like walked without guidance. Then I decided I must follow a madhab and started to learn Islam again. I also learned Shia because Shia was one of my options. Later I decided to back to Shafi'i madhab. But it doesn't means I regard Shia is deviant.

Ya, begitulah kisah saya. Maaf jika saya cakap Inggris, kerana ada perbedaan antara bahasa Indonesia dan bahasa Melayu Malaysia, dan saya khawatir akan timbul salah fahaman.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

.. Also, in the same time, I watched JAB personality like Kang Jalal, Haddad Alwi..aired on tv. ...That's confusing... but glad to hear where MUI stand on this issue. Here, the only hi-lite for JAB is when there's a raid.

Haddad Alwi is Shia? :blink:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Salam to all my Malaysian brothers in sisters :) Ada yang dari Selangor? Setahu saya.. keluarga saya je la AB yang tinggal kat PJ. Ada lagi? Would love to know you all

Salam to all my Malaysian brothers in sisters :) Ada yang dari Selangor? Setahu saya.. keluarga saya je la AB yang tinggal kat PJ. Ada lagi? Would love to know you all

salam ashrafmr. duduk kat selangor ke? Kalau nak cari AB di sana, senang saja.. pergilah ke hauzah yg dah jadi famous tu. Mana lagi kalau tak di Gombak. Saya rasa majlis memperingati kelahiran Fatimah Az-Zahraa' akan diadakan lagi mcm tahun lepas.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Salam. Sdr Rosley,

Nak buat majlis sambutan kat Trg?!.. nak cari pasal? Kat Gombak tak apalah.. diorang dah terkenal.

Sori, saya tak faham, apa maksud "kita ada anak murid Imam Khomeini"....

B) (salam) saja nak tengok kalau ada orang berani, baru balik ke... kalau dah lama mungkin tahulah kat trg ada anak murid Imam Khomeini... org lain dok guna dia lama dah... Wassalam.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

Sign in to follow this  

×