Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
mansab.jafri

Best Shia Vs. Sunni Debate?

Rate this topic

Recommended Posts

In your opinion, what are the 3 greatest debates in history between Shia and Sunni ulema, and why? What did they cover?

Also, in your opinion, who are the 3 greatest Shia debaters in history, excluding our Imams, cuz that's unfair :D

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
(salam)

I guess it's hard to chose one. They were all good.

Chk this out:

http://www.shiachat.com/forum/index.php?showtopic=58130

Fi-AManillah

Well, I mean full-fledged debates, similar in style to Peshawar Nights, or at least debates that cover very important dividing topics, particularly Imammate.

Lemme know if you know of any, discussions are always interesting to read.

Edited by mansab.jafri

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

those dont seem like authentic debates just another example similar to peshawr nights where a shii author writes the debate and sunni answers..

pretty decieving if you ask me..

there is a whole series of debates with tijani on youtube but they are in arabic. i hope someone translates them soon

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
those dont seem like authentic debates just another example similar to peshawr nights where a shii author writes the debate and sunni answers..

pretty decieving if you ask me..

there is a whole series of debates with tijani on youtube but they are in arabic. i hope someone translates them soon

Isn't Tijani kinda lame???

Anyway, that's what I've heard, I can't really know because I don't understand too much Arabic.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Well, I mean full-fledged debates, similar in style to Peshawar Nights, or at least debates that cover very important dividing topics, particularly Imammate.

Lemme know if you know of any, discussions are always interesting to read.

Peshawar nights is quite a deep book...between scholars of callibar...i doubt you'll find that level on ShiaChat...

btw Tijani isn't lame at all...

Edited by Shia & Proud

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

Sign in to follow this  

  • Recent Posts on ShiaChat!

    • Salam,  I just wanted to give my heartfelt and sincere apologies to the brothers and sisters for not being in contact with them over the past months regarding this project.  I think I took on too much with this. It was really affecting my work and also my marriage due to all the time it was taking, many messages that I had to respond to(I won't go into how exactly that part worked, but you all can probably take a good guess). When it started to affect my marriage, I decided that I really couldn't  carry on with it. I had to make an 'executive decision'. Although this project was important to me, my marriage and my family were more important.  I still think the project is a good idea, but I think there are some details that need to be thought thru a little more, like how the work will be distributed amoung the members of the team, and how and who will respond to messages. If anyone would like to continue the project, I could act as a 'consultant' but as far as 'day to day' operation, this would have to be done by someone else.  The personal issues I had because of this project actually lead me to believe that I shouldn't be advising anyone on topics of marriage (or anything else for that matter) since it seemed to me that I can't even handle my own marriage, which was in a downward spiral at that point (alhamduillah things are better now). 
    • The Group in question which I will not even associate the word Islamic was a rabid dog that bit the hand that was feeding it believing it was strong enough to be in a dominant position. The Saudis were originally funding these Wahhabi monsters to cause chaos in a country that was recently invaded by the US in which the US accidentally helped Iran gain a even greater powerful presence in the region. The Saudis did not like these neither did the US, so with oil money from the US the Saudis started to fund these radical groups. When the group in question got too powerful they announced a Caliphate directly challenging the power of  Saudi Arabia which sees itself as the leader of the Islamic world. This was a good opportunity for this new self proclaimed Caliphate because with the civil war in Syria and instability in Iraq they were able to spread extremely fast. Israel wants a divided Middle East and has been supporting these radical groups because Syria, Iraq and Iran challenge Israel’s war crimes against the Palestinians. Israel have even been accused of providing medical care and strategic bombing to help these terrorist groups which makes sense because the rabid dog has been rather kind to Israel, no attacks, no indiscriminate killing...makes you wonder. The US won’t intervene until Assad is toppled that is clear their bombing campaign does nothing compared the the Russians in Syria and the US are the middle man funding groups like FSA who support Al Nusra who support Guess who?! Exactly the rabid dog in question. This is much of the same tactic as Saudi Arabia just wait until there is good enough damage done in eliminating Iranian influence and place puppets in charge.  
    • If you want to know what the conclusion of an article is, as well as the arguments, then generally yes you have to read it. Otherwise, I will summarize here, then you'll reply with something I already considered in the article, and it will take a very long and frustrating thread to get the point across. If you have the time to post several comments on this thread, then you have the time to read it. It takes less than a fifth of the time to read than it does to write.

      As for science, part 3 deals with that.
    • In every church. The commands are 3.000 years old, from a time when Israelis still were polytheists and sacrificed animals to Gods on hilltops. In my understandng the idol ban was not a ban on photograps or sculptures, but a ban on worshipping Baal and other semitic Gods. Only the God Jahwe was to be worshipped by the Israelis.   
    • isn't there "Jesus/god" on the cross in about every  church?
×