Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
ZulfiqarAbdullah

I Have Lost All Respect I Had For Dante

Rate this topic

Recommended Posts

Salaam Alaykum

Look what this idiot Dante says in his book "The Divine Comedy":

In the Divine Comedy, Dante describes in Inferno XXVIII that both Ali and Muhammad were in the 8th (and second harshest) Circle of Hell, as sowers of dissent:

Look what the fool Dante says:

"See how mangled is Mohammed! Ahead of me proceeds Alì, in tears, his face split open from his chin to forelock. And all the others whom you see sowed scandal and schism while they lived, and that is why they here are hacked asunder."

GAH! I can't do anything since the idiot's dead! It makes me EXTREMELY angry.

The moronic false-prophet Dante STEALS his view of Hell fom the Islamic view of Hell and then goes on to denounce Islam and call a great man like Muhammad (as) a person of Hell!

I hope this fool is burning in Hell. I wish that, when Imam Mahdi (as) returns, people like this will be ressurected only to be killed again my Imam Mahdi's (as) hands. Then he'll see whom he mocked!

Not all non-Muslims are like this. Look at what the Tenzin Gyatso, the 14th Dalai Lama said:

"If Buddhism had Ali's Nahj al-Balagha and Hussein's Battle, then everyone in the World would be Buddhist".

Edited by ZulfiqarAbdullah

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

keep in mind that dante lived a long time ago when information was not as easily accessible. he probably didn't know any better. i'm surprised he even knew who imam ali was!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
keep in mind that dante lived a long time ago when information was not as easily accessible. he probably didn't know any better. i'm surprised he even knew who imam ali was!

Salaam Alaykum

At that time, the Qur'an was accessible in Latin. However, it was called: "Lex Mahumet pseudoprophete" which translates to: "The Law of Muhammad the false Prophet". They had a biased Qur'an; I'm sure Dante read it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Not all non-Muslims are like this. Look at what the Tenzin Gyatso, the 14th Dalai Lama said:

"If Buddhism had Ali's Nahj al-Balagha and Hussein's Battle, then everyone in the World would be Buddhist".

:!!!:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Salaam Alaykum

Look what this idiot Dante says in his book "The Divine Comedy":

Look what the fool Dante says:

"See how mangled is Mohammed! Ahead of me proceeds Alì, in tears, his face split open from his chin to forelock. And all the others whom you see sowed scandal and schism while they lived, and that is why they here are hacked asunder."

GAH! I can't do anything since the idiot's dead! It makes me EXTREMELY angry.

The moronic false-prophet Dante STEALS his view of Hell fom the Islamic view of Hell and then goes on to denounce Islam and call a great man like Muhammad (as) a person of Hell!

I hope this fool is burning in Hell. I wish that, when Imam Mahdi (as) returns, people like this will be ressurected only to be killed again my Imam Mahdi's (as) hands. Then he'll see whom he mocked!

Not all non-Muslims are like this. Look at what the Tenzin Gyatso, the 14th Dalai Lama said:

"If Buddhism had Ali's Nahj al-Balagha and Hussein's Battle, then everyone in the World would be Buddhist".

(salam)

Dante's logic for "seminator di scandalo e di scisma"—a "sower of scandal and schism"— is in actuality his perception that Islam is a schism of the religion of Jesus.

He must have known of the Islamic presence in Italy

He was extremely patriotic and placed the traitors of Italy in the mouth of Satan.

There is no justification for his placing of Nabi Muhammad (saw) and Imam Ali (as) in hell.

(salam)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I read it about 10 or so years ago in college. There is another passage which is even more insulting. I don't remember where in the book it happens but in it Dante and his guide are crossing a river and the Prophet (pbuh) is either standing on the side of the river or in another boat but Dante says something to him and the Prophet (pbuh) responds by passing gas loudly. If I remember correctly the line goes something like "after speaking to him he (Muhammad) responded with a bugle from his a**".

I remember my professor not spending much time on that passage. He was reluctant to even discuss it and moved on very quickly after speaking about it. I remember the christian students in my class just giggling while myself and another muslim student felt our tempratures rise.

Its important to realize that Dante was a fervent christian and anything he wrote would be only from a christian point of view. The book itself is itself a christian book describing the levels of hell to christians to get them in line. Islam to Dante was a heathen religion.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I read it about 10 or so years ago in college. There is another passage which is even more insulting. I don't remember where in the book it happens but in it Dante and his guide are crossing a river and the Prophet (pbuh) is either standing on the side of the river or in another boat but Dante says something to him and the Prophet (pbuh) responds by passing gas loudly. If I remember correctly the line goes something like "after speaking to him he (Muhammad) responded with a bugle from his a**".

I remember my professor not spending much time on that passage. He was reluctant to even discuss it and moved on very quickly after speaking about it. I remember the christian students in my class just giggling while myself and another muslim student felt our tempratures rise.

Its important to realize that Dante was a fervent christian and anything he wrote would be only from a christian point of view. The book itself is itself a christian book describing the levels of hell to christians to get them in line. Islam to Dante was a heathen religion.

Dante stole most of his poem from ibn Arabi and other muslim mystics who drew inspiration from the Ahle Bayt alayhim as salam so he can hate as much as he wants, no one really reads him now anyway

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Actually Dante's Inferno is considered to be a classic of that age. Its read and discussed in many Literature classes in colleges/universities in the U.S.

"Its read and discussed in many Literature classes in colleges/universities in the U.S."

Bingo!!!! You win the prize, "literature".

Peace

Satyaban

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The hardness of your reaction to Dante is perhaps understandable, but unjustified. The cheap insults (idiot, etc) are pretty juvenile too. When you contribute some masterpieces of literature, feel free to call whoever you like an idiot. Until then, kindly shut it; you're out of your depth.

Dante was an Italian poet living in Catholic Europe in the 13th and 14th centuries. The 1200's and 1300's.

His writings are understandable given the time and place he lived in. The notion in Christian Europe of a non-Christian being eligible for salvation was pretty much unthinkable; where else do you think Dante could have placed Muhammad without being burned alive at the stake? The placement with the "sowers of discord" actually identifies Muhammad as a believer in God, but one who split people from the right path. Which is not acceptable to us, but it is actually an understandable thing for a 13th century European to believe.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

Sign in to follow this  

  • Recent Posts on ShiaChat!

    • Tawheed means that we don't believe Allah has body parts, but rather, the reference to his hands in the Quran is not that he literally has hands, but it's a metaphor for his mercy. We believe Allah is not constricted to time or space or body, according to the Ahlul Bayt (AS)
    • thank you very much
    • Honestly why are the Sunni speakers silent? not a single lecture on Imam Hussein(as)? no Facebook post or anything?  It is just plain ridiculous! I feel sad that even Hindus know more about the battle of Karbala than many modern day Muslims.
    • Okay. I'm sure you have heard of Karbal Tou Piya Likhda (I love this noha btw). My dad made me listen to a song called 'sheeshe ka tha dil mera" which is literally a copy of the noha 'Karbal tou piya likhda'. Be careful it's Muharram plus video might not be very appropriate (I'm not telling you to listen to it). This took away the spirit of the noha. I don't know if the noha copied the song or the song copied the noha. There were a couple more but I completely forgot. I'll let you know when I remember. 
    • Allah was too busy explaining bananas, honey bees, mountains and palm trees in the Qur'an and left this really important matters of creed out. That's why he need fallible humans to explain in created Tafseers what He meant.
×