Jump to content

Abul Hussain Hassani

Advanced Members
  • Content count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won


Abul Hussain Hassani last won the day on October 1 2013

Abul Hussain Hassani had the most liked content!

1 Follower

About Abul Hussain Hassani

  • Rank
    الله اکبر

Profile Information

  • Religion
    القــــرآن والســــــنة

Previous Fields

  • Gender

Recent Profile Visitors

2,510 profile views
  1. Should I be a Shia or Sunni Muslim?

    This verse is talking about different issue. Allah is telling the believers during the war not to quarrel with each other lest they be weak in hearts and lose power etc. Exactly! just as the verse says. The Prophet (saw) already explained who the Ulil Amr refers to and the Muslims of his time also understood it. Even the Iranian Supreme leader is called as "wali al-amr Muslimeen". Why? As for the Ithna Ashari hadtih you are talking about then these are later twelver fabrications to suite their beliefs (plus it is also unreliable according to twelver Shia hadith standards). The Shia sects that existed before twelvers also have similar hadiths but they have their own list of Imams different than yours i.e. waqifis, fatahiya, zaidis, ismailis etc. The theory lacks any evidence.
  2. Should I be a Shia or Sunni Muslim?

    I already replied. Obey as long as they obey and Allah and His messenger (ص). As long as their actions are according to the Quran and Prophetic teachings. You can't disagree with the divinely chosen infallible Imams, can you? While the verse states the possibility of disagreement and in such a case Allah and messenger (ص) is the final judge. Allah mentions as long you stick to the Quran, perform good deeds, establish prayer, give zakah etc then you will be guided and protected. The scholars and learned men will teach the people. Just like your scholars have been teaching and guiding you for the last 1200 years without any divinely chosen Imam.
  3. Should I be a Shia or Sunni Muslim?

    Obey those in authority (they can be rulers, scholars, military generals etc) as long as they obey Allah and his Messenger. Allah سُبْحَانَهُ وَ تَعَالَى left the Ummah with his FINAL revelation and message.
  4. Should I be a Shia or Sunni Muslim?

    Thank you! so we agree there can be good and bad Imams. Can there be evil Prophets?
  5. Should I be a Shia or Sunni Muslim?

    If you believe in Allah, angels, Quran, the messengers and the day of judgement, you perform your prayers, give zakat etc then you are a Muslim Sunni. Sunni belief is based on the following verses: The Messenger has believed in what was revealed to him from his Lord, and [so have] the believers. All of them have believed in Allah and His angels and His books and His messengers, [saying], "We make no distinction between any of His messengers." And they say, "We hear and we obey. [We seek] Your forgiveness, our Lord, and to You is the [final] destination." (Surah Baqarah Verse 285). O you who have believed, believe in Allah and His Messenger and the Book that He sent down upon His Messenger and the Scripture which He sent down before. And whoever disbelieves in Allah, His angels, His books, His messengers, and the Last Day has certainly gone far astray. (Surah Nisa Verse 136) Notice in the verse above there is no mention of Imamah or Imams that our Shia brothers believe in and that is what differentiates the two sides. If Imamah was from the foundations of religion why didn't Allah mention it like he mentioned the other beliefs? He mentioned belief in him, angels, messengers, books, the last day but not Imams?
  6. How the tragedy of Karbala is well documented?

    No, I didn't say that. I simply shared the link of article about the documentation of Karbala in the early and primary sources. Abi Makhnaf/Tabari etc and how the Shia version of the incident is so different from it.
  7. Question to Sunnis - Kerbela

    You have misunderstood the history. It wasn't a battle rather it was a tragedy and a massacre. Hussain didn't go out for a battle. His intention was to go to Kufa to respond to people's letters. However, he was intercepted on the way and the rest you know.
  8. Question to Sunnies

    Sorry, the preacher is spreading misinformation. Sunnis don't accept such Tasfir to be genuine. Shia sects themselves didn't and don't agree on the number of Imams let alone the Sunnis.
  9. How the tragedy of Karbala is well documented?

    The documentation of Karbala in the original and in the earliest sources: http://www.twelvershia. net/2017/10/11/did-al-hussain-willingly-sacrifice-himself/
  10. Praying in a Sunni mosque

    Waleykum Salaam, Sunnis won't take any offense. They might stare at your Turbah though, out of curiosity.
  11. Ghadir Khumm

    That is a misconception. Please see this article for the most correct meaning of Mawla that also fits with the context: http://ghadirkhumm.com/meaning-of-mawla/
  12. Eid al-Ghadeer an innovation?

    How significant is Eid al-Ghadeer among the Shias? This article say this Eid has no basis in Shia sources and the Ahlulbait never celebrated it. http://ghadirkhumm.com/eid-al-ghadir/ P.S. The website is run by Sunnis.
  13. Sunni/Shia How do you know your sect is on Haqq?

    Sorry but your first paragraph lacks any evidence. How did earlier people come to Islam in the first place? Through the very people who are the champions of Islam according to Sunnis and are revered by them but hated in Shiasm. It also seems you have restricted Ahlulbait to handful of people. FYI Ahlulbait were many - many of them had power and wealth. In fact, many Islamic dynasties were from Ahlulbait. Even the Abbasids who ruled for centuries were from Bani Hashim hence Ahlulbait and many more Islamic Sunni dynasties from Ahlulbait. "Rights of Ahlulbait were taken away" Yes, some Ahlulbait (many of whom are not even liked in Shiasm) were oppressed, I agree, but not the way you believe. Response to the above "contradiction": http://www.twelvershia. net/2015/02/12/prohibition-mutah-marriages/ Yes, I am 100% certain they were said by the Prophet (saw) and Ali. Abubakr's judgement was according to the instructions of the Prophet (saw). And please don't mention the so called "Khutba Fadakiya" which is nothing but a fabrication, even doubted by Shia scholars. Ali was on Haqq in both fitans (civil wars). And of course Hussain, the leader of youth in paradise, was on Haqq against the oppressive Yazid.
  14. Sunni/Shia How do you know your sect is on Haqq?

    Waleykum Salaam I believe Sunnism is on Haqq because it is superior to Shiasm in every Islamic field: the recitation and tafseer of the Quran and other works done related to Quran - the Hadith System, History, spreading Islam etc.
  15. Why I became Muslim (Sunni)

    Does your family know about your conversion?