Jump to content

Hassan-

Moderators
  • Content count

    2,939
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    16

Everything posted by Hassan-

  1. Doing good for the sake of Allah

    You may not be wrong, Allah (awj) is indeed the most merciful.
  2. Doing good for the sake of Allah

    Yes and it is true according to the ahadith supporting this claim. Dr Mohammad Shomali needs to prove his claim from the Quran or ahadith.
  3. If he doesn't consider himself a catholic, and he really believes that God does not exist, then he doesn't belong to the ahlul kitab (he is a kafir).
  4. Dearborne Michigan has many shi’as and mosques there, but mostly arabs.
  5. Forgetting Ruku

    Not sure, it's best you ask a marja'.
  6. Forgetting Ruku

    Not gonna lie that was hilarious.
  7. Who Is Imam Ahmad Al Hassan?

    Wikipedia of him https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ahmad_al-Hassan Old shiachat thread talking about him:
  8. Did the Prophet marry a 9 year old?

    You guys should read these 2 topics here then to understand the truth.
  9. How can we prove taqleed to akhbaari?

    There are a million topics on shiachat regarding taqlid discussions, here is one of them
  10. Are there any Ismaili Shia Muslims here?

    I haven't seen any Isma'ili here before.
  11. Liquid coming out after ghusl

    If you did not urinate before ghusl (assuming your ghusl was ghusl al janabah), then the unknown liquid will be ruled as semen and you must perform ghusl again. If you urinated before performing ghusl, then the unknown liquid will be ruled as urine, and you must repeat your Wudu and prayer. If you performed Istibra' after urinating, then the unknown liquid will be ruled as pure, and your prayer is valid. These rulings only apply if you are not sure what the liquid was. If you are certain it was semen, ghusl is required again and you must repeat prayer. If you are certain it was urine, Wudu is required again and you must repeat prayer.
  12. Please reply fast Prayers in a state of najasa

    Yes you can but you have to make sure that every single nijasah is removed, and without using water it will be hard to remove all nijasah.
  13. Please reply fast Prayers in a state of najasa

    You can use anything to purify the back area, even a piece of rock. But urine can only be purified with water.
  14. Whats killing our brothers in Palestine?

    The response of that 'someone' is not a refutation, all he did was restate the general ruling of cursing. Understanding why a marja' rules something as haram or halal is important. Gold for men is haram because the Quran and sunnah dictates it, but cursing is not forbidden in the Quran and sunnah, so why does the marja' not allow it? Well the marja' says it himself, it's because it causes fitnah. If cursing did not cause fitnah, the marja' would allow it. so if one curses in private, this does not cause fitnah which is the the sole reason why he forbid it, so logically speaking it is allowed to curse in private. Some people ask 'if the marja' allows it in private, why does the marja' not publicly say it's allowed to curse them in private?', well that's because it makes him look like a hypocrite if he did, imagine saying to a Sunni I will not curse abu bakr in front of you but I will curse him behind your back..., it would just makes us look bad, and for that reason is why the marja' does not give details about cursing, and only gives a general ruling.
  15. Whats killing our brothers in Palestine?

    Read what I said to the brother above. If you want my thoughts on it, the only reason why the marja' forbade cursing in public is because it causes fitnah among the Muslims. If one curses in private, this annihilates the root of the problem (fitnah), therefore it is illogical for him to not allow it in private.
  16. Whats killing our brothers in Palestine?

    Yes and that 'someone' did not say in the paragraph you showed me that the marja' does not allow cursing in private. No the onus is on you to prove it not me. In Islam everything is halal unless forbidden otherwise. I do not see any fatwa from Imam Khamenei that cursing in private is not allowed, if there is please prove it to me.
  17. Whats killing our brothers in Palestine?

    My dear bro, you are not understanding the paragraph. What you showed me is not a fatwa, it is someone explaining a fatwa of the marja', it is talking from a third person perspective not a first person. First the author starts off in third person perspective by stating what Imam Khamenei says about insults: قال سماحة السيد القائد مراراً لا توجهوا الإهانات لمقدسات سائر المذاهب إذن يجب اجتناب هذه الممارسات (Imam Khamenei said repeatedly to not insult the sanctity of other sects, therefore avoid such acts) Then the author stops right there with what the marja' states, and tells us what other people say in first person perspective: :و النقطة الجديرة بالملاحظة هي أن البعض يقولون (Another point I'd like to make is that some people say:) Then the author quotes what other people say in a third person perspective: لا إشکال في أن نعلن في المجالس الخاصة ("There is no problem in cursing in secret majalis") Then the author goes back to first person by answering the people from his own opinion and tells us the marja' never specified whether in public or private: :لكن سماحته لم يقيّد الأمر بأن يكون المجلس عاماً أو خاصاً، بل قال على نحو العموم (However the Sayed did not specify whether to not insult in public or secret, instead he said in a general sense: ) The author switches to third person and states the fatwa of the marja' once again: لا توجّهوا الإهانات لمقدسات سائر المسلمين، أي سائر الفرق الإسلامية (Do not insult the sanctity of other Muslims, any sanctity of the other sects in Islam) As you can see brother, there is no fatwa of Imam Khamenei not allowing cursing in private. The marja' only has a general fatwa for la3n, he does not go into specifics and details about it.
  18. Did the Prophet marry a 9 year old?

    A’isha was most likely 6-9 years old when she got married.
  19. Whats killing our brothers in Palestine?

    The person is saying “However the marja’ did not restrict it to public or private” لكن سماحته لم يقيّد الأمر بأن يكون المجلس عاماً أو خاصاً Then goes on to say “But he says in a general sense: Do not insult important figures of other muslims”. بل قال على نحو العموم: لا توجّهوا الإهانات لمقدسات سائر المسلمين The Sayeds response was a general response, and he did not say anything about private or public settings.
  20. NOTHING IN QURAN OF IMAMAH

    You are missing the point here. The same way Allah (awj) tells us to establish prayer via the Quran and sends a messenger to guide us on how to pray, Allah (awj) also tells us to obey the people with authority via the Quran and sends a messenger to guide us on who to obey (e.g hadith al thaqalayn). Salah and Imamah are highly important beliefs in Islam, both mentioned in the Quran, and both explained via ahadith. Do you understand now? If you really read the topic I linked you and still can't rationalize with the evidence for imamah, then I rest my case, I don't want to waste my time explaining to you.
  21. Whats killing our brothers in Palestine?

    Brother, read what it says: لكن سماحته لم يقيّد الأمر بأن يكون المجلس عاماً أو خاصاً، بل قال على نحو العموم: لا توجّهوا الإهانات لمقدسات سائر المسلمين، أي سائر الفرق الإسلامية He never mentioned public or private, he just generalized by saying one shouldn’t insult public figures. Also it uses the word الإهانات which means ‘insult’ or ‘sab’, it does not mean cursing ‘la3n’. Those are two different words. We already know that insulting or sab is impermissible.
  22. Whats killing our brothers in Palestine?

    I do not see in your link where he said not to curse in secret majalis, he only gave a generalized answer by saying not to curse public figures of other sects.
  23. 2nd Marriage with same wife

    I don't understand what you mean by 'the process of three successive divorces'. According to Imam Khamenei, all you need to say is "my wife <name of wife> is divorced" and the couple will be officially divorced after she finishes her iddah.
  24. Whats killing our brothers in Palestine?

    Cursing is not forbidden according to Imam Khamenei unless it is in public.
  25. NOTHING IN QURAN OF IMAMAH

    You are wrong. Salah is considered the pillar of faith, meaning if you don't do salah your entire faith will collapse. If salah is one of the most important acts in Islam to an extent where if you don't believe in it you will be a kafir, then why are the details of salah not mentioned in the Quran? The Quran tells us to pray, but it does not tell us HOW to pray. This proves that the Quran does not explain everything clearly, and that's why we use ahadith to help us. The same thing with imamah, the doctrine of imamah is mentioned countless times in the Quran but we use ahadith to strengthen the doctrine. If you want to see where imamah is mentioned in the Quran, read this topic here:
×