Jump to content


Advanced Members
  • Content count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

About inocence

  • Rank
  • Birthday 10/09/1980

Contact Methods

  • Website URL
  • Yahoo

Profile Information

  • Location

Previous Fields

  • Gender

Recent Profile Visitors

1,768 profile views
  1. kafi dino say meray zehan may ya sawal hai

    آپ کی بات درست ہے. شاید ہمیں ان کے بارے میں زیادہ معلومات نہیں. اس لیے انکا اتنا ذکر نہیں کیا جاتا
  2. Brahmin Hindus In Karbala

    Salam Do we have any statements of any maraja on this topic? Whats their opinion? From the information that we have looks like a fabricated story. However there is a large community of hindu brehamins in subcontinent. In Pakistan in my city they used to have a mourning procession on shab e ashoor. But after security problems in recent years they stopped. They also state this story.
  3. Hadith on black clothes in Muharram

    Ok guyz. Let me summarize the whole debate. There are hadiths that says black clothes are makroh. There is no hadith that says black clothes are OK for mourning ahlebayt. But it is also known that women of bani hashim wore black for mourning. But there is no event mentioning men of bani hashim wearing black. Remember women and men have different rules of clothing. Women can wear resham clothes and clothes with gold embroidery, etc but men can't. Syed Razi was the first one to wear black clothes for mourning and then this practice continued till today. Now we only need a hadith that says its ok to wear black while mourning to end this Debate.
  4. Can you refer me any reading material on this.
  5. Please note my question again. I m trying to understand the Grammer here. , شھادۃ for 1 For 2، شھادتین شھادات for more than 2 Now,there is also a rule in arabic that is applied for 11 and more than 11. جمع ء کثرت more than 11 to infinity جمعء قلت. More than 2 upto 11. Does the word شھاداتھم in the verse addresses 11 or more than 11 or its just used as plural,i.e more than 2 upto infinity. Can you elaborate,please. Jazakallah
  6. No its not the intention
  7. Salam وَالَّذِينَ هُمْ بِشَهَادَاتِهِمْ قَائِمُونَ The world shahadatihim is used for refering 11 persons or more than 11 persons.? in arabic we have Jama kasrat and Jama qilat. i.e words used for more than 11 and upto 11. Please explain the intention of the word used in this verse.
  8. Salam I have heard that imam sadiq's janaza was attended by huge number of people. Biggest number of that time. Can you guyz share information on this with reliable sources. Jazakallah
  9. Hadith on black clothes in Muharram

    Shuaybi has a valid point. However, since the great scholars have allowed it then there must be ahadith in there favor. We can't imagine that either of these great scholars will go against several ahadith on this topic. If we could get some explanation from the current scholars then it would help us understand the issue.
  10. Hadith on black clothes in Muharram

    Excellent I guess to be on the safe side. We wear black while mourning for alhlebayt and when its salat time, change the clothes if possible, keeping in mind the hadith . A bit inconvenient though.
  11. Hadith on black clothes in Muharram

    Salam So whats the verdict. Do we have a consensus now? Wear black or not. Generally not but for mourning, it's ok. Makrooh while prayer. What about if mourning and doing prayer. This has become really confusing.
  12. Can you state any hadith? Or any maraja rulings explaining this.
  13. Thank you for your reply. However, as I stated, there are numerous hadiths that prohibit salat to be offered on road. Are these applicable in only those conditions when road is being used by the people.,, i.e normal circumstances
  14. اللہ کے ساتھ ہمارے معاملات کچھ ایسے ہیں کہ کبھی وہ ہم ہوتا ہے اور کبھی ہم وہ ہوتے ہیں، لیکن کسی دھوکے میں نہ رہنا وہ وہ رہتا ہے اور ہم ہم رہتے ہیں. Something like that. Shokat raza shokat said a shyr on this hadith in karbala and the whole issue started.
  15. What i have read its quite sensitive and dangerous hadith. Maybe for ahl e irfan. Or people having high maarfat level. An arabic friend might translate it correctly. I have heard urdu translation in few urdu mjalis.