Jump to content

uufzni

Basic Members
  • Content count

    17
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  1. I can't find on internet, a ismaili reply to the famous hadith of the twelve successor. any ismaili here to give me an explanation please.
  2. I hope in this forum somebody can. Why musa kadhim and not ismael? No shi'a twelver could give me proof that musa kadhim was the choosen one. When i read the history after imam jaafar as sadiq, they're was a huge confusion and most of people followed his son Abdullah al aftah, this is a historical proof nobody can deny it. if musa kadhim was the choose the majority will follow him immediately after the death of jaafar as sadiq. They're was a confusion because the choosen one died before his father, and logically his imamat go to his son Well it's kind of logical, and no shia twelver could give me an argument.
  3. The proof one is ismail (As) was the favorite son of jaafar as sadiq and the eldest. and the second proof that no shia can refutuate is the majority if the shia at the time of imam jaafar as sadiq followed Abdullaj al aftah. Then when they saw that Abdullaj al aftah.could not have any progeny they followed musa kadhim. If musa kadhim was choosen, people won't follow Abdullaj al aftah.
  4. If musa kadhin was the right choose imam, why the majority went to Abdullah al-Aftah ? then we they saw he can not have kids (sterile) then went to musa kadhim.
  5. Are you sure? how can you explain : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abdullah_al-Aftah ( if musa kadhim was choosen why the majority went to abdullah al aftah ? )
  6. Salam, I really can't understand why did the twelver ignore ismael ibn jaafar, most of twelver say jaafar as sidiq choose Musa kadhim ... Ok? so how about this : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abdullah_al-Aftah ( if musa kadhim was choosen why the majority went to abdullah al aftah ? ) Also let's say there is a king , who have 2 sons, the eldest died before his father BUT he had a son. So who will be the next king? in 95% it's the son of the eldest son, not the little brother.
  7. Zaydis and Aga Khan

    Thank you so much for this reply.
  8. Zaydis and Aga Khan

    please can somebody reply to my question
  9. Zaydis and Aga Khan

    Brother i think you miss understand, Zaydis follow a hassan (as) or hussein (as) descendant as long as this person declare himself as an imam, NOT exclusively zayd ibn ali (As) descendant. My question is since aga khan is the only person that declare himself as an imam, does zaydis follow him or can follow him?
  10. Salam, I was wondering if shia zaydi consider the aga khan as a legitimate imam? because i think he is the only person who officialy declare himself as an imam. thank you,
  11. Why do sunnah will tell us to looks like christian?
  12. Salam, I always found this ridiculous and today i've notice that christian also do it. https://www.google.com/search?q=√°mish+beard&biw=1517&bih=735&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwj-tO2lsO3QAhXJmJQKHUkrAgYQ_AUIBigB&dpr=0.9
  13. I know, but why musa kadhim and not muhammad ibn ismael, why he didn't let his follower follow his uncle. jazakum Allah khayrane.
  14. Thank you for your answer, but i was speaking about MUHAMMAD ibn ismail not hazrat ismail ibn jaafar. I've read about him Muhammad ibn ismael was raised and educated by his grandfather jaafar as sidiq he was heavily persecuted, but he HAVE assumed the imamat instead of giving it to musa kadhim. and he was preaching isamelism So does it mean he was a liar? This is really causing me a huge confusion. thanks again brothers
  15. Salam aleykom, I am a sunni and i want to choose the right path, i am very interested in shia twelver and shia ismaeli. However i need some help, if somebody can explain please. First I acknowledge that the only amir mueminine is Ali the only legitimate and the best man after the prophet however i wont curse the 3 caliph and i will respect them and i think they're in paradise even they did some mistake god is merciful however i hate this muawiya so much and i hope he is burning in fire with all bani ummaya except muawiya2 and omar ibn al aziz, Anyway i know the right path is to follow the imams of ahl al bay (as) everything is OK for me untill Jaafar as sidiq, My questions are : If Musa Kadhim was the real imam why Muhammad ibn Ismael was persecuted ? And why Muhammad ibn ismael didn't disavow himself with his followers? knowing that he was educated by his grandfather jaafar as sidiq. IF jaafar as sidiq has agree that musa kadhim is the next imam why muhammad ibn ismael was hidden and persecuted? Also about hadith taqalayn : the prophet say there will be 2 things the Coran and his progeny, but in shia twelver the mehdi is not here. ps: sorry for very bad english. Thank you very much
×