Jump to content

emceemo40

Advanced Members
  • Content count

    110
  • Joined

  • Last visited

3 Followers

About emceemo40

  • Rank
    Member

Profile Information

  • Religion
    Islam

Previous Fields

  • Gender
    Male

Recent Profile Visitors

521 profile views
  1. Whoa! Are you comparing a scholar who wrote over 1000 books on the religion of Islam to a 5 year old? Mashallah! I think you should think through again about this statement you have made because this is a very harsh comparison between two very knowledgable men who have/had millions of followers around the world. Also isn't there a rule on this website that prohibits disrespect to any religious authorities, because you are doing exactly that. You are a top moderator on this site, so I find it a bit hypocritical that you are not abiding by rules that you yourself probably made.
  2. With regards to the Khoei-M Shirazi conflict, I have personally come to the conclusion that although this letter can be found on the internet, I am unsure whether it is real or not, because if it was indeed true, I would have thought that with the mentality Yasser Habib has, YH would have probably insulted Sayyid Khoei (ra) on his tv channel, but I don't think that YH has done such a thing. Also, I don't think any of the ulema, including Khoei's successor Sayed Sistani (ha) have made any statements against doing taqleed of Sayed M Shirazi or Sayed S Shirazi, which probably means that they don't see a problem in it. Another thing I want to add, is that Shaheed Nimr (ra) was actually a muqallid of Sayed Muhammed Shirazi until the Sayed passed away in 2001. If the marjaeiya of Sayyid M Shirazi was doubtful, then why didn't Shaheed Nimr do taqleed to someone else, like Sayyid Khoei, or Sayyid Sistani for example?
  3. With regards to the Khoei-M Shirazi conflict, I have personally come to the conclusion that although this letter can be found on the internet, I am unsure whether it is real or not, because if it was indeed true, I would have thought that with the mentality Yasser Habib has, YH would have probably insulted Sayyid Khoei (ra) on his tv channel, but I don't think that YH has done such a thing. Also, I don't think any of the ulema, including Khoei's successor Sayed Sistani (ha) have made any statements against doing taqleed of Sayed M Shirazi or Sayed S Shirazi, which probably means that they don't see a problem in it. Another thing I want to add, is that Shaheed Nimr (ra) was actually a muqallid of Sayed Muhammed Shirazi until the Sayed passed away in 2001. If the marjaeiya of Sayyid M Shirazi was doubtful, then why didn't Shaheed Nimr do taqleed to someone else, like Sayyid Khoei, or Sayyid Sistani for example?
  4. Firstly, I think that it's worth mentioning to you that even the son of Ayatollah Sadiq Shirazi (Sayed Ahmed) has I think condemned Yasser Habib in this video. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=-aJhjauSSBM Also, I don't really understand why you are wasting your time defending Allahyari, because he doesn't even believe in the concept of marjaiya, and he has insulted members of the Shirazi family, including your scholar Sayed Sadiq.
  5. I would assume your scholar is Sayed Sadiq Shirazi right? This is his view on these celebrations from his website. Question: Is it permissible to celebrate the death anniversary of enemies of Allah? It is permissible to do so provided that it does not cross the Islamic barriers and boundaries of ethical practices. Meaning, that it would consist of a lecture and it would be considered an educational gathering. Rather than an atmosphere of chaos. Based on what you probably know, the death celebration that happened in London by YH was most obviously chaotic and unethical, meaning that the criteria given by their marji' was not obeyed and completely ignored.
  6. With regards those who say that Shirazi has done nothing to help the fighters, and that no Shirazi followers are fighting, this is a lie. Ayatollah Shirazi public relations office continues logistic support to PMU Category: Religious Authority Published: Wednesday, 22 February 2017 09:40 Hits: 85 Print Email The Public Relations Office of Grand Ayatollah Sayed SadiqShirazi continues its logistic support to Public Mobilization Units (PMU) in their holy war against ISIS terrorists. The support was based on the commandment of the Grand Jurist Ayatollah SeyyedSadiq al-Husseini al-Shirazi, may Allah prolong his life, to aid those who sacrifice their lives for their homeland and the holy sites. The support included medical aids, foods, beverages, clothes, and other necessities thatbenefit the fighters.
  7. Unfortunately not.
  8. I disagree. Ayatollah Shirazi has in fact helped the growth of Islam throughout many parts of the world, as a result of his works and organisations. In fact, recently an Imam Shirazi Islamic Centre has been established in Cuba, and a number of Cubans have embraced Islam as a result of this.
  9. What channel are you referring to? And can you show me a video of this please. wasalam
  10. I don't think they are against supporting Palestine, but they instead stress more importance on supporting things like the Askariyain shrines. I believe the second point you said is correct though. wasalam
  11. Is Islamic Unity the way to go?

    This is new to me. Can you please show me a video of him saying that. Jazak Allah
  12. Is Islamic Unity the way to go?

    Whoa! Thats not a very nice statement to make, especially during the holy month of Ramadan. If you believe that Sayyid Ahmed is deviated, then why should you also fall to the same level as him. Why are you mocking his voice? Allah ÓÈÍÇäå æÊÚÇáì created him with this voice. Are you saying that you have a problem with the way that Allah has created some of his creatures? Also, how does he sound like he smokes a lot? Are you now going to mock the ulema that actually used to smoke, like Sayyid al Khoei and Sayyid Khamenei? I would recommend that you don't slander any Muslims, especially our scholars, during this month and during any other month, because this would be considered as gheeba (backbiting), which is a very severe sin in Islam.
  13. Here is another video that refutes this ignorant channel on this topic.
  14. Sufi...

    If you became a sufi, then there is a possibility that you could fall into the trap of believing in wahdat al wujud/mawjud, which ultimately makes a person a mushrik/polytheist. And this makes someone an apostate from the religion of Islam altogether. Wasalam
  15. Marja

    We should ask the Ahlul khibra (people with good knowledge in religion), who I believe are scholars that have studied the religion of Islam quite well, like the Imam of your mosque for example. We cannot tell for sure who the most knowledgeable marja is, but as a result of who the Ahlul khibra usually reccomend, the overwhelming majority of Shias today follow Grand Ayatollah Sayed Ali Sistani (ha).
×