Jump to content

Haidar :)

Advanced Members
  • Content count

    209
  • Joined

  • Last visited

About Haidar :)

  • Rank
    Haidar

Profile Information

  • Religion
    Shī'ī

Previous Fields

  • Gender
    Male
  1. And as expected, they have not addressed Ibn Taymiyyah's [imam al Nawasib] statement where he admits the incident occurred.
  2. I wouldn't say it's of no value at all. There are many truthful hadiths in there such as the bid'ah of Umar changing the Adhan.
  3. Muhammed Pbuh Was A Bewitched Prophet At One Time

    We don't have a problem with the above narrations. The pious, loyal, companions are, no doubt, as have been described in our traditions. Non of those traditions say ALL the sahaba were good people, on the contrary, there are narrations from the Imams where they slate some of those who you call his sahaba. If you would want to see a balanced view of their opinions on this matter, look at all the narrations from them regarding the sahaba, and you'll find some were significantly praised, and some were not, such as Muawiyah "ra". Such a commonly used verse of the Holy Quran. But, the verse directly after it must be read as well, about the hypocrites. I don't want to go into it, but I want to ask you a very simple question. Do you believe ALL of the Muhajireen and Ansar were pious and loyal?
  4. How Can We Defend?

    LOOOOL. Abu Bakr (Allah be pleased with him) said: The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) had said:" We do not have any heirs; what we leave behind is (to be given in) charity." So both of you thought him to be a liar, sinful, treacherous and dishonest. And Allah knows that he was true, virtuous, well-guided and a follower of truth. When Abu Bakr passed away and (I have become) the successor of the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) and Abu Bakr (Allah be pleased with him), you thought me to be a liar, sinful, treacherous and dishonest. It looks like you've been banging your head lol.
  5. Abusing Is Not Allowed In Islam

    If you want to see our general opinion on insulting [not la'nah, something different and actually recommended], hold a poll, and you'll then know which side the majority are on.
  6. (salam) When looking at the gradings of Allamah al Majlsi, I often see the grading written as 'Majhool ka-sahīh' (majhool like sahih), or 'hasan ka-sahīh' (hasan like sahih). What does he mean when he say this? How did he reach this conclusion from looking at the given isnād? Also, what does he mean when he says 'dha'īf 'alal Mashhoor' (ضعيف على المشهور), and why did he say that (how did he reach that conclusion)? Thanks in advance.
  7. I was cursing ibn Muljam and anyone who says that Ibn Muljam was a great man, a mu'min etc. Just as that 'scholar' said.
  8. According to that la'een Ibn Muljam (also la'een) was a good man.
  9. When will you continue [if you are going to continue at all] ? It is easily the best, most accurate translation around, with the Arabic of each hadith there as well.
  10. The Ahlul Bayt - The Family Of The Beloved

    Invoker be aware that Muhammad Sarwar's translation of al Kafi is so poor sometimes it is a joke.
  11. Do not lie. Mir'at al Uqul is not available in English.
  12. Muhammed Pbuh Was A Bewitched Prophet At One Time

    They are not part of the specified Ahlul Bayt. Yes, they are part of the general household [family]. That does not make on immune to kuffr. There are many examples of Prophets who had a household which has betrayal and disbelief within it. This is not a valid argument. It is blasphemy to question the īmān of some sahābah when Allah revealed a whole verse titled 'Al Munāfiqūn'? Obviously, one or more of the narrators my be majhool/liar etc. , the chain may be broken (unlinked), and the rest of the usual isnād criticism. What about them? We know that, but we are usulis here. The translation is Sahih International found here here: http://quran.com/66/4 -It is a mistake in their translation - your one is correct. I can tell you that with all honesty I merely took the top translation (sahih International). I was in a hurry. Now, their are two options presented in the verse. The first is 'if you repent to Allah, then your hearts are inclined' the second part, which you have clipped out says ' but if you help one another against him (Muhammad SAW), then verily, Allah is his Maula (Lord, or Master, or Protector, etc.), and Jibrael (Gabriel), and the righteous among the believers, and furthermore, the angels are his helpers'. The question is - where is the evidence that they repented? Does the Quran say they repented? No. Where does it say that their hearts were actually inclined? Just because the threat [of divorce] did not happen, it does not mean they repented. Remember that Allah dislikes divorce, and the verse says "If/Perhaps/may be..." [66:5] The verse does not say you will be divorced if you do not repent. If you can provide evidence that they did repent, then you can support your argument, but you haven't brought that yet. But what actually implies that they did not repent is "Allah sets an example for those who disbelieved..." You'll have to provide the reference of the hadith. The point I am trying to make is not as to whether she was forgiven or not, but that she was a liar and did conspire against the Prophet (pbuh). Thus, you cannot blindly believe her. That it is kuffr, to fight the Imam of the time, and that applies to Aisha also (and, ironically, Sunnis say that if you fight the rightly guided caliph, then that is kuffr also). Yet, for the case of Aisha she is excused. There is no problem © Sunni logic. It is not fixed, but it is temporary, and it is agreed across all schools of thought that marriage with the intention of divorce is a grave sin. I have replied to this already. You cannot say that he was 'bewitched' or possessed. No one denied that a Prophet can become affected by Shaytan, but to become bewitched is something completely different.
  13. It takes an Arabic teacher to translate a couple of paragraphs?
  14. So we're now agreed that Abu Bakr and Umar raided the house, and you agree with them? We're actually getting somewhere now :]
  15. The nasibi inside has been revealed. These are the sons of Umar, Muawiyah, Yazeed, and Ibn Taymiyyah [la'natullahi alaihim ajma'een].
×