14 replies to this topic

[Abdaal]

004.159
And there is none of the People of the Book but must believe in him before his death; and on the Day of Judgment he will be a witness against them;-
Accoding to the shias what is the purpose Prophet Isa returning? U guys will have the 12th Imam so what is the purpose of Prophet Isa(as) ?

[sayed_ali]

004.159
And there is none of the People of the Book but must believe in him before his death; and on the Day of Judgment he will be a witness against them;-
Accoding to the shias what is the purpose  Prophet Isa   returning?  U guys will have the 12th Imam so what is the purpose of Prophet Isa(as) ?

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

They will come together at the same time and fight the forces of Evil. The purpose of Prophet Isa is to convert the christians onto the side of good and to tell them that he was not slain on the cross.

[Abdaal]

any Shia hadith to support that. Also do u have hadith to support that they will come at the same time.

[kadhim]

Actually, strictly speaking, they're not supposed to come at the same time. Imam Mehdi is supposed to precede Nabi E'esa by some amount of time. Imam Mehdi is supposed to start the revolution, calling and gathering momin behind him. And then, at the peak of things, Nabi E'esa is to appear and kill the dajjal.

[inuit]

any Shia hadith to support that. Also do u have hadith to support that they will come at the same time.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

There is a whole chepter in Hyat ul Qolub of Allama Majlasi Alay Rahma – a must read book

[Abdaal]

Actually i read some stuff online about the Shia Mahdi like 6 years ago. I was really interested in finding out about the Shia version of Prophet Isa . Can someone give me some info on that because i don't have the access to the Shia sources.

[Jat]

Good question Abdaal,i wonder too what according to Shia view Hazrat Isa will do bcoz for them Imam Mahdi will punish the Sahaba(astaghfirullah) ! ! !

[inuit]

Good question Abdaal,i wonder too what according to Shia view Hazrat Isa will do bcoz for them Imam Mahdi will punish the Sahaba(astaghfirullah) ! ! !

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

If Sahabi did something wrong - should nt be punished?

[Abdaal]

Although ur responded in a very cunning manner i am still wondering what the day of judgement is really for ?

[inuit]

Although ur responded in a very cunning manner i am still wondering what the day of judgement is really for ?

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

day of judgement is the day of judgment - cant one be punished before that?

[Abdaal]

Yes in our graves. But in Sunni Islam once a person is dead he/she doesn't come back to life and get punished again. Anyway back to the topic.
Can u shias bring me hadiths that support the return of Prophet Isa . I want ur answers to have details with supporting Shia hadithes.

[inuit]

Yes in our graves. But in Sunni Islam once a person is dead he/she doesn't come back to life and get punished again. Anyway back to the topic.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Do you [edit: Believe] Those Sahabas (Abu Bakar Umar, Usman & Mawiah) who will be punished by Imam Mehdi(AS) are dead?

Edited by inuit, 06 January 2005 - 09:08 AM.

[highlander]

I really really dont understand how you guys actually believe this. subhanallah.

[Abdaal]

Inuit this topic is about Prophet Isa . Since u shias believe ur so guided i would really like an answer.

[Abdaal]

Logic i am little ignorant about the Shia beliefs to why Prophet Isa is returning. I hope u can provide me some hadithes on this...so our other topics can be a little bit more fair. I've already read the hadith about praying behind Imam Mahdi . i want to see hadith taht deal with the purpose of his return.