maula dha mallang, on 08 June 2010 - 09:34 AM, said:
stop making up hadiths to suit your agenda, abu hurraira. it doesnt impress me.
Stop paying khumms to your marjas, so they can make your mourn more. If you want to mourn then watch Hollywood movies based on the holocaust.
did not kill umar because at that moment the muslim ummah was fractured, confused, and attacked from all sides both within and without (eg attackers from byzantine were marching as it occured, a fake prophet called mohalamine was claiming prophethood) and fitnah was at an all time high. if Imam ali
had killed umar, it would have meant civil war and the destruction of the muslim ummah and the end to the prophets mission.
the father ali's actions at the burning house saved islam
the son hussains actions at the burning desert of kerbala saved islam.
Again you are running away.. What about the other pro Ali Sahabis ? Why didn't they kill Umar
. As for fake Prophets in your creed declaring imamate is worst.
As for the objective shias do you really think Umar
was worst then Uthmaan
? Do you think he was equal or worst then Muwaiyah and Yazid ? Abu Lulu was kaffir, and if he had done something in service of Deen then that honour would have gone to Pro Ali Sahabis. He was no shia. He was a Persian who only gave the Ummavis a greater chance to get into power.
Recall Nahj al-Balaghah when Imam Ali
tells Muawaiyah that he looked for 100's of opportunity to become a shaheed, but Allah (swt) has not willed it.
abbas110, on 08 June 2010 - 04:34 PM, said:
MODERATORS: could you please clean this silly thread and warn Abdaal to spill his venom elsewhere, preferably at some other forum.
Stop praising Abu lulu. He had no connection to Imam Ali
or the Ahlul Bayt
. You are making up stories to suit your nafs.
Edited by Abdaal, 21 June 2010 - 05:36 PM.