29 replies to this topic

[chiprince007]

I want my Shia Brothers to post here word of ur first IMAM hazrat ALI ra declaring him self as the IMAM of Muslims and declaring that there would be 11 imams after him.

this is not an unfair question. If he ra really was the imam he would have declared it and also would have declared the what imam is and what are his qualities etc etc. Since hazrat Muhammad pbuh and Quran does not explain the imamat system ( the whole 12 imam system not the word imam) so its a must that first Imam would have enligten us about it if its true ....

[Mowali]

I hope you are in the best health and Iman.

This (Ali ) is my brother, my trustee and my deputy [caliph] after me, so listen to him and obey him."

Tarikh, al Tabari, vol 2 p319
al Sirah al Halabiyah, vol 1 p 311
Shawahid al Tanzil, vol 1 p 371
Kanz al Ummal, vol 15 p 15
Tarikh, Ibn Asakir, vol 1 p 85
Tafsir, Ala al Din al Shafi'i, vol 3 p 371
The Life of Muhammad by Hasanyn Haykal, First Edition (Section on: And admonish your nearest, your kinsmen)

[Aliya]

In 'Ikmal-ud-Din' a tradition, through 'Jabir-il-Ju'fi', is narrated from 'Jabir-ibn-'Abdillah' thus: "I said: 'O Messenger of Allah we have known Allah and His Apostle; then who is 'Ulul-Amr', those that Allah has made their obedience the same as your obedience?' Then, the Prophet (p.h.u.h.) said: 'O' Jabir! They are, after me, my successors and the guides of Muslims; the first of them is Ali ibn Abi Talib; then (Imam) Hassan, and (Imam) Husayn; then Ali ibn Husayn; then Mohammad ibn Ali; known in the Turah as Baqir, whom you will see, O' Jabir! When you visit him, give my regards to him. After him, there is Sadiq, Ja'far ibn Muhammad; and after him Musa ibn Ja'far; then Ali ibn Musa; then Muhammad ibn Ali; then Ali ibn Muhammad, then Hassan ibn Ali; and after him (there comes) Al-Qaim, whose name and epithet is the same as mine. He is Allah's Authority on the Earth and His Remainder amongst His servants. He is the son of (Imam) Hassan-ibn-Ali (al-'Askari). This is the very personality by whose hands Allah will open the Easts and Wests of the worlds and this is the very personality who will be absent from his followers and those who love him, in which his mastership cannot be proved by a statement of anyone except for the one whose heart Allah tests for Faith."

Jabir said: "I asked him: 'O' Messenger of Allah will his followers avail of him during his occultation?' He answered: 'Yes. By the One Who appointed me to prophethood, they will seek brightness from his light and will avail by devotion in his absence the same as the availing of people from the (glow of) sun when clouds cover it...'

(Ikmal-ud-Din, vol. 1, p. 253, with nearly similar meaning in Yanabir-ul-Mawaddah, p. 117)

Al-Juwayni also narrates that the Messenger of Allah (s) informed: "I and Ali and Hasan and Husayn and nine of the descendants of Husayn are the purified ones and the inerrant."
[Al-Juwayni, Fara'id al-Simtayn, Mu'assassat al-Mahmudi li-Taba'ah, Beirut 1978, p. 160.]

Edited by Aliya, 07 April 2004 - 01:32 PM.

[FriendlyGuy]

To be clear: It was Prophet Muhammad who decalred Imam Ali to be Imam of Muslims, and declared that there would be 11 imams after Imam Ali. It was declared multiple multiple times in a variety of sitautions.

I'm sure another Brother or Sister can provide you with a specific quote from teh Quran as well.

The Quran does not explain the Prophethood either, yet you believe in it. Why should the Imammat be unique?

[Mowali]

Imam Ali has made many declarations in Khutbul Bayan, Nahjul Balaga, etc, but would that be any use to a sunni?

I guess not.

[Mowali]

Vol 9, Book 89. Judgments (Ahkaam) Hadith 329. (Sahih Bukhari): Narrated By Jabir bin Samura: I heard the Prophet saying, "There will be TWELVE Muslim rulers (who will rule all the Islamic world)." He then said a sentence which I did not hear. My father said, "All of them (those rulers) will be from Quraish."

Sunni 12 "Imams"

1. Abu Bakr
2. Umar
3. Uthman
4. Ali
5. Mu'awiya (LA)
6. Yazid bin Mu'awiya (LA)
7. Abdul Malik bin Marwan (LA)
8. Walid bin Abdul Malik bin Marwan (LA)
9. Sulayman bin Abdul Malik bin Marwan (LA)
10. Umar bin Abdul Aziz
11. Yazid bin Abdul Malik bin Marwan (LA)
12. Hasham bin Abdul Malik bin Marwan (LA)

Taken from Sharra Fiqa Akbar, by Mulla Ali Qari, p 176

[chiprince007]

OK Half of u like always have answered to a wrong question, i am not asking what Hazoor pbuh said i am asking why didnt he declared him self the SPEECH ............


I do not believe in what Hazoor said to Jabir and to Kamal and to nasir and to bubbly. they can very well be lying . Due to the condradictions lets put all those ahadits said to a single person in a bag. they can very well be lying or some other person be lying i mean common havent we already cought 1000s of fabricated ahaditss ?????????????

Why would Hazoor pbuh explain all the imamat system to jabir only ?????????????????? were the imams only for jabir.

We are blessed with some words of Hazoor which no shia or sunni can deny and those are usually his speeches at the mosques and at a gathering of muslims which were said in vitness of hundreds of muslim. those are the only ahadits no one can deny.

Imamat speech is not a kind of speech that can be said to one person like jabir lol. if u know hazoor pbuh style to use adress the muslim ummah and teach them new laws and forbade things in a congression after the prayer , in jummah prayer etc etc.. now u think such a big thing as IMAMAT can only be said to jabir. ??????????????????????????

and yea back to the orignal question which no one answered

where is ali ra saying am i am your imam follow me and 12 after me ?????

it is a must for him to say and to declare. Can a imam be an imam who did not even invited any one toward him ????????????? what kind of passenger of imam would not even invite any one towards him and away from kufr ????? ??????


SO LONG FOR 15 years olDs hahahhah

[chiprince007]

[edit] would dat make any difference to u if i tell what even u have been believing abt us is not even close to the TRUTH. it wont yea keep on. Pretty soon u will add Iblees , Shaitan , Namrood , Firon , and Abu Jahl to ur Imams list and fool ur shia brothersss i don care do what ever u will be questioned no me ....

[Moderators note : slandering shia and personal attacks not accepted - you are suspended for 3 days

Edited by Abdulhujjah, 07 April 2004 - 03:20 PM.

[Socrates]

Quote

We are blessed with some words of Hazoor which no shia or sunni can deny and those are usually his speeches at the mosques and at a gathering of muslims which were said in vitness of hundreds of muslim. those are the only ahadits no one can deny.

Yes you are right.

Narrative of Ghadir Khom said:

The Farewell Pilgrimage
Ten years after the migration (hijrah), the Messenger of Allah [peace and blessings be upon him and his Progeny] ordered to his close followers to call all the people in different places to join him in his last pilgrimage. On this pilgrimage he taught them how to perform the pilgrimage in a correct and unified form.

This was first time that the Muslims with this magnitude gathered in one place in the presence of their leader, the Messenger of Allah [s]. On his way to Makkah, more than seventy thousand people followed Prophet [s]. On the fourth day of Dhu'l-Hijjah more than one hundred thousand Muslims had entered Makkah.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

  Date
The date of this event was the 18th of Dhu'l-Hijjah of the year 10 AH (10 March 632 CE).

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

  Location
After completing his last pilgrimage (Hajjatul-Wada'), Prophet [s] was leaving Makkah toward Madinah, where he and the crowd of people reached a place called Ghadir Khumm (which is close to today's al-Juhfah).  It was a place where people from different provinces used to greet each other before taking different routes for their homes.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Revelation of Qur'anic Verse 5:67
In this place, the following verse of the Qur'an was revealed:

"O Apostle! Deliver what has been sent down to you from your Lord; and if you don't do it, you have not delivered His message (at all); and Allah will protect you from the people ..." (Qur'an 5:67)
The last sentence in the above verse indicates that the Prophet [s] was mindful of the reaction of his people in delivering that message but Allah informs him not to worry, for He will protect His Messenger from people.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Sermon
Upon receiving the verse, the Prophet [s] stopped on that place (the pond of Khumm) which was extremely hot. Then he sent for all people who have been ahead in the way, to come back and waited until all pilgrims who fell behind, arrived and gathered. He ordered Salman [r] to use rocks and camel toolings to make a pulpit (minbar) so he could make his announcement. It was around noon time in the first of the Fall, and due to the extreme heat in that valley, people were wrapping their robes around their feet and legs, and were sitting around the pulpit, on the hot rocks.

On this day the Messenger of Allah [s] spent approximately five hours in this place; three hours of which he was on the pulpit. He recited nearly one hundred verses from The Glorious Quran, and for seventy three times reminded and warned people of their deeds and future. Then he gave them a long speech.

The following is a part of his speech which has been widely narrated by the Sunni traditionists:

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

  Tradition of the Two Weighty Things (thaqalayn)

The Messenger of Allah [s] declared:

"It seems the time approached when I shall be called away (by Allah) and I shall answer that call. I am leaving for you two precious things and if you adhere to them both,  you will never go astray after me. They are the Book of Allah and my Progeny, that is my Ahlul Bayt. The two shall never separate from each other until they come to me by the Pool (of Paradise)."

[See also: Hadith al-Thaqalayn: A Study of its tawatur]

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Acknowledgement of Authority
Then the Messenger of Allah continued:

"Do I not have more right over the believers than what they have over themselves?" 
People cried and answered:

"Yes, O' Messenger of God."

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Text (nass) of the Designation
Then followed the key sentence denoting the clear designation of 'Ali as the leader of the Muslim ummah.  The Prophet [s] held up the hand of 'Ali and said:

"For whoever I am his Leader (mawla), 'Ali is his Leader (mawla)."
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

  [In some narrations the word used was wali rather than mawla - with the same implication] 
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Prophet [s] continued:

"O' God, love those who love him, and be hostile to those who are hostile to him."

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

These were the key parts of the speech of the Prophet [s]. There are also more detailed versions of this sermon which are recorded by many Sunni authorities.
'Coronation' of Imam 'Ali [a]
[under development]
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Revelation of Qur'anic Verse 5:3
Immediately after the Prophet [s] finished his speech, the following verse of the Qur'an was revealed:

"Today I have perfected your religion and completed my favour upon you, and I was satisfied that Islam be your religion." (Qur'an 5:3)

The above verse clearly indicates that Islam without clearing up matter of leadership after Prophet [s] was not complete, and completion of religion was due to announcement of the Prophet's immediate successor.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Hassan b. Thabit's poetry
Immediately after the Prophet's speech, Hassan b. Thabit, the Companion and poet of the Messenger of Allah [s], asked for his permission to compose a few verses of poetry about Imam 'Ali [a] for the audience. The Prophet [s] said: "Say with the blessings of Allah". Hassan stood up and said: "O' people of Quraysh. I follow with my words what preceded and witnessed by the Messenger of Allah [s]. He then composed the following verses at the scene:

He calls them, (on) the day of Ghadir, their Prophet
In Khumm so hear (and heed) the Messenger's call,
He said: "Who is your guide and leader? (mawlakum wa waliyyukum)"
They said, and there was no apparent blindness (clearly):
"Your God, our guide, and you are our leader
And you won't find from among us, in this, any disobedient,"
He said to him: "Stand up O' Ali, for I am
pleased to announce you Imam and guide after me (min ba'di imam(an) wa hadiy(an)),
So whomever I was his leader (mawla), then this is his leader (mawla)
So be to him supporters in truth and followers,"
There he prayed: "Allah! Be a friend and guide to his follower
And be, to the one who is Ali's enemy, an enemy"

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Oath of Allegiance
After his speech, the Messenger of Allah [s] asked everybody to give the oath of allegiance to 'Ali [a] and congratulate him. Among those who did so was 'Umar b. al-Khattab, who said:
"Well done Ibn Abi Talib! Today you became the Leader (mawla) of all believing men and women."
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Number of Companions in Ghadir Khumm
Allah ordered His Prophet [s] to inform the people of this designation at a time of crowded populous so that all could become the narrators of the tradition, while they exceeded a hundred thousand.
Narrated by Zayd b. Arqam: Abu al-Tufayl said: "I heard it from the Messenger of Allah [s], and there was no one (there) except that he saw him with his eyes and heard him with his ears."
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Revelation of Qur'anic Verse 70:1-3
Some Sunni commentators further report that the first three verses of the chapter of al-Ma'arij (70:1-3) were revealed when a dispute arose after the Prophet [s] reached Madinah. It is recorded that:
On the day of Ghadir the Messenger of Allah summoned the people toward 'Ali and said: "Ali is the mawla of whom I am mawla." The news spread quickly all over urban and rural areas. When Harith Ibn Nu'man al-Fahri (or Nadhr Ibn Harith according to another tradition) came to know of it, he rode his camel and came to Madinah and went to the Messenger of Allah [s] and said to him: "You commanded us to testify that there is no deity but Allah and that you are the Messenger of Allah. We obeyed you. You ordered us to perform the prayers five times a day and we obeyed. You ordered us to observe fasts during the month of Ramadhan and we obeyed. Then you commanded us to offer pilgrimage to Makkah and we obeyed. But you are not satisfied with all this and you raised your cousin by your hand and imposed him upon us as our master by saying `Ali is the mawla of whom I am mawla.' Is this imposition from Allah or from you?" 

The Prophet [s] said : "By Allah who is the only deity! This is from Allah, the Mighty and the Glorious."

On hearing this Harith turned back and proceeded towards his she-camel saying: "O Allah! If what Muhammad said is correct then fling on us a stone from the sky and subject us to severe pain and torture." He had not reached his she-camel when Allah, who is above all defects, flung at him a stone which struck him on his head, penetrated his body and passed out through his lower body and left him dead. It was on this occasion that Allah, the exalted, caused to descend the following verses:

"A questioner questioned about the punishment to fall. For the disbelievers there is nothing to avert it, from Allah the Lord of the Ascent." (70:1-3)

References for the above are:
al-Shaykhلnي al-Qلdirي, Mahmْd b. Muhammad b. `Alي, al-Madanي
(d. 1050 AH/1640 CE)

Sirلt al-sawي fي manلqib ءl al-nabي
Manuscript,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S204 Abْ Nu`aym, Ahmad b. `Abd Allلh, al-'Isfahلnي
(d. 430 AH/1039 CE)

Hilyat al-Awliyل'
Beirut: Dلr al-kutub al-`ilmiyyah (10 vols), 1988 CE

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S253 al-Baydلwي, Nلsir al-Dيn `Abd Allلh b. `Umar, Abْ al-Khayr al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 685 AH/1286 CE)

Tawلli` al-anwلr
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S285 al-`Aynي, Mahmْd b. Ahmad b. Mْsل b. Ahmad, Badr al-Dيn Qلdي al-Qudلt al-Hanafي
(d. 855 AH/1451 CE)

`Umdat al-Qلrي Sharh Sahيh al-Bukhلrي
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

O245 Abْ al-Hasan Sharيf
(d. 0 AH/622 CE)

Diyل' al-`ءlamيn
Manuscript,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

T31 Sulaym b. Qays, Abْ Sلdiq al-Hilلlي al-`ءmirي al-Kْfي
(d. 80 AH/699 CE)

Asl Sulaym b. Qays
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S306 Ibn Sلn (or Sinلn), Ahmad Jalabي b. Yْsuf b. Ahmad, Abْ al-`Abbلs, al-Qarmلnي al-Dimashqي
(d. 1019 AH/1610 CE)

Akhbلr al-duwal wa لthلr al-'awwal
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S325 al-`Imلdي, Hلmid b. `Alي b. Ibrلhيm b. `Abd al-Rahيm, al-Hanafي al-Dimashqي
(d. 1171 AH/1758 CE)

al-Salلt al-fلkhirah bi al-ahلdيth al-mutawلtirah
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S297 Ibn Hajar al-Haytamي, Shihلb al-Dيn Ahmad b. Muhammad b. `Alي, Abْ al-`Abbلs al-Sa`dي al-Makkي al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 974 AH/1567 CE)

Al-Sawل'iq al-Muhriqa
Cairo: Maktabah al-Qلhirah, 1955 CE

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S354 `Alي Jalلl al-Dيn al-Husaynي al-Misrي
(d. 1350 AH/1931 CE)

al-Husayn
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S185 al-Dلraqutnي, `Alي b. `Umar b. Ahmad, Abْ al-Hasan (or al-Dلrqutnي)
(d. 385 AH/995 CE)

Al-`Ilal
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S163 Ibn `Abd Rabbih, Ahmad b. Muhammad b. `Abd Rabbih, Abْ `Umar al-Qurtubي
(d. 328 AH/940 CE)

Al-`Iqd al-Farيd
Cairo (7 vols), 1940-65 CE

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S308 al-`حdrْs, Shaykh b. `Abd Allلh b. Shaykh b. `Abd Allلh, al-Husaynي al-Yamanي
(d. 1041 AH/1632 CE)

al-`Iqd al-nabawي wa al-sirr al-Mustafawي
Manuscript,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S319 al-Muqbilي, Sلlih b. Mahdي b. `Alي b. `Abd Allلh, Diyل' al-Dيn al-San`لnي
(d. 1108 AH/1697 CE)

al-'Ahلdيth al-mutawلtirah
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S164 al-Husayn b. Ismل`يl b. Sa`يd, Abْ `Abd Allلh al-Muhلmilي al-Dabbي
(d. 330 AH/942 CE)

al-'Amلlي
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S304 Jamلl al-Dيn `Atل' Allلh b. Fadl Allلh, al-Husaynي al-Shيrلzي
(d. 1000 AH/1592 CE)

al-'Arba`يn fي fadل'il Amيr al-Mu'minيn
Manuscript,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S292 al-Suyْtي, Jalلl al-Dيn `Abd al-Rلhmلn b. Kamلl al-Dيn Abي Bakr, al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 911 AH/1505 CE)

al-'Azhلr fي mل `aqdahu al-shu`arل' min al-'ash`لr
Manuscript,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S320 Ibn Hamzah al-Harrلnي, Ibrلhيm b. Muhammad b. Muhammad Kamلl al-Dيn al-Hanafي
(d. 1120 AH/1708 CE)

Al-Bayلn wa'l-ta`rيf
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S269 Ibn Kathيr, `Imلd al-Dيn Ismل`يl b. `Umar b. Kathيr b. Daw', al-Qarashي al-Dimashqي
(d. 774 AH/1373 CE)

Al-Bidلyah wa'l-Nihلyah fي al-Ta'rيkh
Cairo: Matba`at al-Sa`لdah (14 vols), 1932-

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S211 Mas`ْd b. Nلsir b. `Abd Allلh b. Ahmad, Abْ Sa`يd al-Sijzي (al-Sijistلnي)
(d. 477 AH/1084 CE)

al-Dirلyah fي Hadيth al-Wilلyah (Kitلb al-wilلyah)
Manuscript,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S292 al-Suyْtي, Jalلl al-Dيn `Abd al-Rلhmلn b. Kamلl al-Dيn Abي Bakr, al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 911 AH/1505 CE)

Al-Durr al-Manthْr
Tehran: Matba`at al-Islلmiyyah (6 vols), 1377/1957

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

O246 al-Qatيfي
(d. 0 AH/622 CE)

al-Firqat al-nلjiyah
Manuscript,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S284 Ibn al-Sabbلgh, Nْr al-Dيn `Alي b. Muhammad b. Ahmad, al-Ghazzي al-Mلlikي
(d. 855 AH/1451 CE)

al-Fusْl al-muhimmah li ma`rifat al-a'immah
Beirut: Mu'assassat al-A`lamي, 1408/1988

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S342 Ahmad b. Zaynي b. Ahmad Dahlلn al-Makkي al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 1304 AH/1887 CE)

al-Futْhلt al-Islلmiyyah
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S283 Ibn Hajar al-`Asqalلnي, Shihلb al-Dيn Ahmad b. Nْr al-Dيn `Alي, Abْ al-Fadl al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 852 AH/1448 CE)

Al-Isلbah fي tamyيz al-sahلbah
Cairo (with Ibn `Abd al-Barr's al-Istي`لb on the margin), 1328/1939

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S179 Ibn Hibbلn, Muhammad b. Hibbلn b. Ahmad, Abْ Hلtim al-Bustي al-Tamيmي al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 354 AH/965 CE)

Al-'Ihsلn bi Tartيb Sahيh Ibn Hibbلn
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S238 Ibn al-Shaykh, Yْsuf b. Muhammad, Abْ al-Hajjلj al-Balawي al-Mلlikي
(d. 605 AH/1209 CE)

Alif bل'
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S255 Ibrلhيm b. `Abd Allلh, al-Wassلbي al-Yamanي al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 650 AH/1252 CE)

al-'Iktifل fي fadl al-'arba`ah al-khulafل'
Manuscript,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S133 Ibn Qutaybah, `Abd Allلh b. Muslim, Abْ Muhammad al-Dيnawarي
(d. 276 AH/889 CE)

Al-Imلmah wa'l-Siyلsah
Cairo: al-Halabي (2 vols), 1388/1969

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S208 Ibn `Abd al-Barr, Yْsuf b. `Abd Allلh b. Muhammad, Abْ `Umar al-Namarي al-Qurtubي
(d. 463 AH/1071 CE)

Al-Istي`لb fي ma`rifat al-ashلb
Cairo: Maktabah Nahdah (3 vols), 1960

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S292 al-Suyْtي, Jalلl al-Dيn `Abd al-Rلhmلn b. Kamلl al-Dيn Abي Bakr, al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 911 AH/1505 CE)

al-'Itqلn fي `ulْm al-Qur'لn
Beirut: Dلr al-kutub al-`ilmiyyah, 1407/1987

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S222 Razيn b. Mu`لwiyah, Abْ al-Husayn al-`Abdarي al-Sarqastي al-Andulasي
(d. 535 AH/1141 CE)

al-Jam` bayn al-Sihلh al-sittah
Manuscript,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S136 al-Tirmidhي, Muhammad b. `حsل b. Sawrah b. Mْsل, Abْ `حsل al-Tirmidhي
(d. 279 AH/892 CE)

Al-Jلmi` (also called al-Sahيh or al-Sunan)
Cairo: Dلr Ihyل' al-turلth al-`arabي, n.d.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S292 al-Suyْtي, Jalلl al-Dيn `Abd al-Rلhmلn b. Kamلl al-Dيn Abي Bakr, al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 911 AH/1505 CE)

al-Jلmi` al-saghيr
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S226 Muhammad b. `Alي b. Ibrلhيm, Abْ al-Fath al-Natanzي
(d. 555 AH/1160 CE)

al-Khasل'is al-`Alawiyyah
Manuscript,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S150 al-Nasل'ي, Ahmad b. Shu`ayb b. `Alي b. Sinلn b. Bahr, Abْ `Abd al-Rahmلn al-Khurلsلnي al-Nasل'ي
(d. 303 AH/916 CE)

Al-Khasل'is fي fadl `Alي b. Abي Tلlib
Majma` Ihyل al-Thaqلfah al-'Islلmiyyah, 1419 AH

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S157 al-Dْlلbي, Muhammad b. Ahmad, Abْ Bishr
(d. 320 AH/932 CE)

al-Kunل wa'l-asmل
Haydarabad (2 vols), 1904

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S314 `Abd al-Haqq b. Sayf al-Dيn, al-Shaykh al-Dihlawي
(d. 1052 AH/1642 CE)

al-Lama`لt fي sharh al-Mishkلt
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S283 Ibn Hajar al-`Asqalلnي, Shihلb al-Dيn Ahmad b. Nْr al-Dيn `Alي, Abْ al-Fadl al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 852 AH/1448 CE)

al-Matلlib al-`لliyah bi zawل'id al-masلnيd al-thamلniyah
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S281 al-Maqrيzي, Taqي al-Dيn Ahmad b. `Alي b. `Abd al-Qلdir, Abْ al-`Abbلs al-Husaynي al-Hanafي
(d. 845 AH/1441 CE)

al-Mawل`iz wa al-'i`tibلr bi dhikr al-khutat wa al-'لthلr (al-Khitat)
Cairo, 1324 AH

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S266 `Abd al-Rahmلn b. Ahmad, al-'Ayjي al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 756 AH/1355 CE)

al-Mawلqif
Manuscript,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S225 al-Shahrastلnي, Muhammad b. `Abd al-Karيm, Abْ al-Fath al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 548 AH/1153 CE)

Al-Milal wa'l-Nihal
Cairo: al-Halabي, 1968

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S225 al-Shahrastلnي, Muhammad b. `Abd al-Karيm, Abْ al-Fath al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 548 AH/1153 CE)

Al-Milal wa'l-Nihal
London: Kegan Paul (as "Muslim Sects and Divisions", translated by Kazi and Flynn), 1984 CE

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S297 Ibn Hajar al-Haytamي, Shihلb al-Dيn Ahmad b. Muhammad b. `Alي, Abْ al-`Abbلs al-Sa`dي al-Makkي al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 974 AH/1567 CE)

al-Minah al-Makkiyyah fي sharh al-qasيdat al-hamziyyah
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S95 Ibn Abي Shaybah, `Abd Allلh b. Muhammad b. Ibrلhيm b. `Uthmلn, Abْ Bakr al-`Absي al-Kْfي
(d. 235 AH/850 CE)

Al-Musannaf
Karachi: Idلrل al-Qur'لn wa al-`ulْm al-Islلmiyyah (15 vols in 16 parts), 1987 CE

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S180 al-Tabarلnي, Sulaymلn b. Ahmad b. Ayyْb, Abْ al-Qلsim al-Khamي (al-Lakhamي ?)
(d. 360 AH/971 CE)

Al-Mu`jam al-Saghيr
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S180 al-Tabarلnي, Sulaymلn b. Ahmad b. Ayyْb, Abْ al-Qلsim al-Khamي (al-Lakhamي ?)
(d. 360 AH/971 CE)

Al-Mu`jam al-Kabيr
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S250 Fadl Allلh b. Abي Sa`يd al-Hasan, al-Shلfi`ي al-Tْrbashtي
(d. 660 AH/1262 CE)

al-Mu`tamad fي al-Mu`taqad
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S267 al-Kلzarْnي, Sa`يd al-Dيn Muhammad b. Mas`ْd b. Muhammad
(d. 758 AH/1357 CE)

al-Muntaqل fي sيrat al-Mustafل
Manuscript,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S276 Ibn Khaldْn, Walي al-Dيn `Abd al-Rahmلn b. Muhammad, al-Hadramي al-'Ashbيlي al-Mلlikي
(d. 808 AH/1406 CE)

Al-Muqaddima
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S103 Ibn Hanbal, Ahmad b. Muhammad b. Hanbal b. Hilلl b. Asad, Abْ `Abd Allلh al-Shaybلnي al-Marwazي
(d. 241 AH/855 CE)

Al-Musnad
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S193 al-Hلkim al-Naysلbْrي, Muhammad b. `Abd Allلh b. Muhammad, Abْ `Abd Allلh Ibn al-Bayyi`
(d. 405 AH/1015 CE)

al-Mustadrak `alل al-Sahيhayn
Haydarabad: Dل'irat al-ma`لrif al-nizلmiyyah (4 vols), 1334-42 AH

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S294 al-Qastallلnي, Shihلb al-Dيn Ahmad b. Muhammad b. Abْ Bakr, Abْ al-`Abbلs al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 923 AH/1517 CE)

Al-Muwلhib al-ladunniyya bi al-minah al-Muhammadiyya
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S317 Muhammad b. `Abd al-Rasْl b. `Abd al-Sayyid b. `Abd al-Rasْl, al-Shلfi`ي al-Barzanjي al-Husaynي
(d. 1103 AH/1692 CE)

al-Nawلqid li al-rawلfid
Manuscript,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S237 Ibn al-'Athيr, Majd al-Dيn Abْ Sa`لdلt al-Mubلrak b. Muhammad, al-Shaybلnي al-Jazarي al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 606 AH/1210 CE)

Al-Nihلya fي gharيb al-hadith
Cairo: Dلr 'Ihyل' al-kutub al-`arabiyyah, n.d.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S343 Yْsuf b. Ismل`يl al-Nabhلnي al-Bayrْtي
(d. 1350 AH/1931 CE)

al-Sharf al-mu'abbad
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S224 `Iyلd b. Mْsل, Abْ al-Fadl al-Yahsabي al-Sabtي al-Qلdي
(d. 544 AH/1149 CE)

al-Shifل' bi ta`rيf huqْq al-Mustafل
Scotland: Madinah Press Inverness (as "Muhammad Messenger of Allah", translated by Aisha Bewley), 1991 CE

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S224 `Iyلd b. Mْsل, Abْ al-Fadl al-Yahsabي al-Sabtي al-Qلdي
(d. 544 AH/1149 CE)

al-Shifل' bi ta`rيf huqْq al-Mustafل
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S299 al-Sharbيnي, Shams al-Dيn Muhammad b. Ahmad, al-Khatيb al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 968 AH/1561 CE)

al-Sirلj al-munيr fي tafsيr al-Qurلn
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S192 al-Bلqillلnي, Muhammad b. al-Tayyib b. Muhammad b. Ja`far b. al-Qلsim, Abْ Bakr
(d. 403 AH/1013 CE)

al-Tamhيd fي radd `alل al-madhلhib
Cairo: Dلr al-fikr al-`arabي, 1947 CE

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S118 al-Bukhلrي, Muhammad b. Ismل`يl b. Ibrلhيm, Abْ `Abd Allلh al-Ju`fي
(d. 256 AH/870 CE)

al-Ta'rيkh al-kabيr
Haydarabad: Dل'irat al-Ma`لrif al-`Uthmلniyyah, 1361-65

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S210 al-Wلhidي, Abْ al-Hasan `Alي b. Ahmad b. Muhammad b. `Alي b. Mattawayh, al-Naysلbْrي
(d. 468 AH/1076 CE)

Asbلb al-Nuzْl
Dلr al-Diyلn li-Turلth, n.d.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S339 Shaykh Muhammad b. Darwيsh al-Hْt al-Bayrْtي al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 1276 AH/1860 CE)

Asnل al-matلlib fي ahلdيth mukhtalifah al-marلtib
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S280 Ibn al-Jazarي, Shams al-Dيn Muhammad b. Muhammad, Abْ al-Khayr al-Jazarي al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 833 AH/1430 CE)

Asnل al-Matلlib fي manلqib `Alي b. Abي Tلlib
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S286 Ibn `Ijlْn, Najm al-Dيn Muhammad b. `Abd Allلh b. `Abd al-Rahmلn, al-'Azra`ي (al-Zar`ي) al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 876 AH/1471 CE)

Badي` al-ma`لnي fي sharh `aqيdat al-Shaybلnي
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

O314 Al-Majlisي, Muhammad Bلqir b. Muhammad Taqي
(d. 1110 AH/1699 CE)

Bihلr al-anwلr
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S329 Shihلb al-Dيn Ahmad b. `Abd al-Qadيr b. Bakrي, al-`Ujaylي al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 1182 AH/1768 CE)

Dhakhيrat al-ma'لl fي sharh `iqd jawلhir al-li'لl fي manلqib al-'ءl
Manuscript,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S204 Abْ Nu`aym, Ahmad b. `Abd Allلh, al-'Isfahلnي
(d. 430 AH/1039 CE)

Dhikr Akhbلr Isbahلn
Leiden: Brill (2 vols), 1931-34 CE

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S214 Ibn Haddلd al-Haskلnي, `Ubayd Allلh b. `Abd Allلh, Abْ al-Qلsim al-Hلkim al-Nيsلbْrي al-Hanafي
(d. 490 AH/1097 CE)

Du`ل' al-hudلt ilل 'adل' haqq al-muwلlلt
Manuscript,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S278 Khwلjah Pلrsل, Muhammad b. Mahmْd al-Hلfizي al-Bukhلrي al-Naqshbandي
(d. 822 AH/1419 CE)

Fasl al-khitلb
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S141 `Abd Allلh b. Ahmad b. Hanbal, Abْ `Abd al-Rahmلn al-Shaybلnي
(d. 290 AH/903 CE)

Fadل'il `Alي
Manuscript,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S257 al-Juwaynي, Ibrلhيm b. Muhammad b. al-Mu'ayyad, Sadr al-Dيn Abْ al-Majلmi` al-Hamawaynي or al-Hamawي al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 722 AH/1322 CE)

Farل'id al-samtayn fي fadل'il al-Murtadل wa al-batْl wa al-sibtayn
Beirut: Mu'assasat al-Mahmْdي (2 vols), 1978

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S283 Ibn Hajar al-`Asqalلnي, Shihلb al-Dيn Ahmad b. Nْr al-Dيn `Alي, Abْ al-Fadl al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 852 AH/1448 CE)

Fath al-Bلrي Sharh Sahيh al-Bukhلrي
Beirut: Dلr ihyل al-turلth al-`arabي, 1408/1988

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S332 Rashيd al-Dيn Khلn al-Dehlawي
(d. 1243 AH/1828 CE)

Fath al-mubيn fي fadل'il ahl al-bayt sayyid al-mursalيn
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S337 al-Shawkلnي, Muhammad b. `Alي b. Muhammad, al-San`لnي
(d. 1250 AH/1834 CE)

Fath al-qadيr
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S307 al-Munلwي, Zayn al-Dيn `Abd al-Ra'ْf b. Tلj al-`ءrifيn b. `Alي, al-Haddلdي al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 1031 AH/1622 CE)

Fayd al-qadيr fي sharh al-Jلmi` al-saghيr
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S318 Burhلn al-Dيn Ibrلhيm b. Mar`ي b. `Atiyyah al-Shabarhaytي, al-Misrي al-Mلlikي
(d. 1106 AH/1695 CE)

Futْhلt al-wahabiyyah bi sharh al-'arba`يn hadيthan li Nawawي
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S261 Nizلm al-Dيn Hasan b. Muhammad b. al-Husayn al-Qummي al-Naysلbْrي, known as al-Nizلm al-'A`raj
(d. 750 AH/1349 CE)

Gharل'ib al-Qur'لn (Tafsيr al-Naysلbْrي)
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

O162 al-Sayyid Hلshim b. Sulaymلn al-Husaynي al-Bahrلnي
(d. 0 AH/622 CE)

Ghلyat al-Marلm
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S312 al-Husayn b. al-Imلm al-Mansْr bi Allلh al-Qلsim b. Muhammad b. `Alي, al-Yamanي
(d. 1050 AH/1640 CE)

Hidلyat al-`uqْl
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S341 Ahmad b. Mustafل al-Qلdayn Khلnي
(d. 1306 AH/1889 CE)

Hidلyat al-martلb fي fadل'il al-'ashلb
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S282 Shihلb al-Dيn Ahmad b. Shams al-Dيn `Umar, Malik al-`Ulamل' al-Zawلlي al-Dawlatلbلdي
(d. 849 AH/1445 CE)

Hidلyat al-su`adل'
Manuscript,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S290 Khawلjah Mullل, Fadl Allلh b. Rْzbahلn b. Fadl Allلh, Abْ al-Khayr al-Khunjي al-Shيrلzي al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 924 AH/1518 CE)

Ibtلl al-bلtil
Manuscript,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S310 Nْr al-Dيn b. Burhلn al-Dيn `Alي b. Ibrلhيm b. Ahmad b. `Alي, al-Halabي al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 1044 AH/1634 CE)

Insلn al-`uyْn fي sيrat al-amيn al-ma'mْn (al-Sيrah al-Halabiyya)
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S331 Muhammad b. `Alي, Abْ al-`Irfلn al-Sabbلn al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 1206 AH/1792 CE)

Is`لf al-rلghibيn fي sيrat al-mustafل wa fadل'il ahl baytihi al-tahirيn
Cairo: Maktabah Mustafل al-Halabي, 1367/1948

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S326 Shلh Walي Allلh b. `Abd al-Rahيm al-Dihlawي
(d. 1176 AH/1763 CE)

Izلlat al-khifل' `an sيrat al-Khulafل
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S237 Ibn al-'Athيr, Majd al-Dيn Abْ Sa`لdلt al-Mubلrak b. Muhammad, al-Shaybلnي al-Jazarي al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 606 AH/1210 CE)

Jلmi` al-usْl fي ahلdيth al-Rasْl
Cairo: Maktabah al-Halawلnي, Matba`ah al-Mallلh, Maktabah Dلr al-Bayلn, 1392/1972

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S293 al-Samhْdي, Nْr al-Dيn `Alي b. `Abd Allلh b. Ahmad, al-Hasanي al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 911 AH/1505 CE)

Jawلhir al­`iqdayn fي fadl al-sharafayn sharaf al-`ilm al-jalي wa al-nasab al-`alي
Manuscript, ??

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S298 Nْr al-Dيn `Alي b. `Abd al-Malik Husلm al-Dيn al-Muttaqي al-Hindي
(d. 975 AH/1568 CE)

Kanz al-`ummلl fي sunan al-aqwلl wa'l af`لl
Halab: Maktabah al-turلth al-'Islلmي (18 vols), 1969-84 CE

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

al-Irbilي, `Alي b. `حsل b. Abي al-Fath, Abْ al-Hasan al-'Irbilي
(d. 693 AH/1294 CE)

Kashf al-ghamma fي ma`rifat al-A'immah
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S248 Muhammad b. Yْsuf b. Muhammad, Abْ `Abd Allلh al-Kanjي al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 658 AH/1260 CE)

Kifلyat al-Tلlib
Tehran: Dلr Ihyل Turلth Ahl al-Bayt (a), 1404 AH

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S347 Muhammad Habيb Allلh b. `Abd Allلh al-Yْsufي al-Madanي al-Shanqaytي
(d. 1363 AH/1944 CE)

Kifلyat al-tلlib li manلqib `Alي ibn Abي Tلlib
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S229 al-Khatيb al-Khawلrazmي, Muwaffaq b. Ahmad, Abْ al-Mu'ayyad al-Makkي, known as Akhtab al-Muwaffaq
(d. 538 AH/1144 CE)

Kitلb al-Manلqib
Tehran: Maktabah Naynawah al-hadيthah, n.d.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S139 Ibn Abي `ءsim al-Shaybلnي, Ahmad b. `Amr b. Abي `ءsim, Abْ Bakr al-Nabيl
(d. 287 AH/900 CE)

Kitلb al-Sunnah
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S307 al-Munلwي, Zayn al-Dيn `Abd al-Ra'ْf b. Tلj al-`ءrifيn b. `Alي, al-Haddلdي al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 1031 AH/1622 CE)

Kunْz al-haqل'iq fي hadيth khayr al-khalل'iq (margin of al-Jلmi` al-Saghيr)
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S204 Abْ Nu`aym, Ahmad b. `Abd Allلh, al-'Isfahلnي
(d. 430 AH/1039 CE)

Mل nazala min al-Qur'لn fي `Alي
Manuscript,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S219 Husayn b. Mas`ْd, Abْ Muhammad al-Farrل' al-Baghawي al-Shلfi`ي (Muhyi al-Sunnah)
(d. 516 AH/1122 CE)

Masلbيh al-Sunnah
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S324 Muhammad Sadr al-`ءlam
(d. 1150 AH/1737 CE)

Ma`لrij al-`ulل fي manلqib al-Murtadل
Manuscript,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S265 al-Zarandي, Jamلl al-Dيn Muhammad b. Yْsuf b. al-Hasan al-Madanي al-'Ansلrي al-Hanafي
(d. 750 AH/1349 CE)

Ma`لrij al-wusْl
Manuscript,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S204 Abْ Nu`aym, Ahmad b. `Abd Allلh, al-'Isfahلnي
(d. 430 AH/1039 CE)

Ma`rifat al-Sahلbah
Unknown edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S245 Muhammad b. Talhah, Abْ Sلlim al-Qarashي al-Nasيbي al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 652 AH/1254 CE)

Matلlib al-sa'ْl fي manلqib ءl al-Rasْl
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S314 `Abd al-Haqq b. Sayf al-Dيn, al-Shaykh al-Dihlawي
(d. 1052 AH/1642 CE)

Madلrij al-nubuwwah
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S236 Fakhr al-Dيn al-Rلzي, Muhammad b. `Umar b. al-Hasan, Abْ `Abd Allلh al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 606 AH/1210 CE)

Mafلtيh al-Ghayb (Tafsيr al-kabيr)
Beirut: Dلr al-Fikr (32 volumes in 16), 1981 CE

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S275 Nْr al-Dيn `Alي b. Abي Bakr b. Sulaymلn, Abْ al-Hasan al-Haythamي al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 807 AH/1405 CE)

Majma` al-Zawل`id wa-Manba` al-Fawل'id
Cairo: Maktabat al-Qudsي (10 vols), 1353

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S301 Jamلl al-Dيn Muhammad Tلhir al-Fitannي al-Gujrلtي
(d. 986 AH/1578 CE)

Majma` bihلr al-'anwلr fي gharل'ib al-tanzيl wa latل'if al-'akhbلr
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S103 Ibn Hanbal, Ahmad b. Muhammad b. Hanbal b. Hilلl b. Asad, Abْ `Abd Allلh al-Shaybلnي al-Marwazي
(d. 241 AH/855 CE)

Manلqib `Alي b. Abي Tلlib
Manuscript,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S212 Ibn al-Maghلzilي, `Alي b. Muhammad, Abْ al-Hasan al-Tayyib al-Jullلbي al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 483 AH/1090 CE)

Manلqib `Alي b. Abي Tلlib
Beirut: Dلr al-'Adwل', 1403/1983

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Ibn Shahrلshْb, Muhammad b. `Alي, Abْ Ja`far
(d. 588 AH/1192 CE)

Manلqib ءl Abي Tلlib
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S323 Mيrzل Muhammad b. Mu`tamad Khلn al-Hلrithي al-Badakhshي (al-Badakhshلnي)
(d. 1150 AH/1737 CE)

Miftلh al-najل fي manلqib ءl al-`abل
Manuscript,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S268 al-Yلfi`ي, `Abd Allلh b. As`ad b. `Alي, Abْ al-Sa`لdلt al-Shلfi`ي al-Yamanي
(d. 768 AH/1367 CE)

Mir'لt al-jinلn wa `ibrat al-Yaqzلn
Haydarabad: Matba`at Dل'irat al-Ma`لrif al-Nizلmiyyah, 1338/1920

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S335 Walي Allلh b. Habيb Allلh al-Lakhnawي
(d. 1270 AH/1854 CE)

Mir'لt al-mu'minيn fي manلqib ahl al-bayt sayyid al-mursalيn
Manuscript,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S305 `Alي al-Qلrي, `Alي b. al-Sultلn Muhammad al-Harawي, al-Hanafي
(d. 1014 AH/1605 CE)

Mirqلt al-Mafلtيh fي sharh Mishkلt al-Masلbيh
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S262 al-Khatيb al-Tabrيzي, Walي al-Dيn Muhammad b. `Abd Allلh, Abْ `Abd Allلh
(d. 737 AH/1337 CE)

Mishkلt al-Masلbيh
Damascus: al-Maktab al-islلmي (3 vols), 1961-62

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S336 Haydar `Alي, al-Mawlawي al-Fayd ءbلdي
(d. 1250 AH/1834 CE)

Muntaha al-kalلm
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S172 al-Mas`ْdي, `Alي b. al-Husayn, Abْ al-Hasan al-Baghdلdي al-Misrي
(d. 346 AH/957 CE)

Murْj al-dhahab
Cairo, 1346 AH

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S159 al-Tahلwي, Ahmad b. Muhammad b. Salamah, Abْ Ja`far al-'Azdي al-Hanafي al-Misrي
(d. 321 AH/933 CE)

Mushkil al-لthلr
Haydarلbلd: Matba`ah Dل'irat al-Ma`لrif al-Nizلmiyyah (2 vols in 1), 1915 CE

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S152 Abْ Ya`lل al-Mawsilي, Ahmad b. `Alي b. al-Muthannل' b. Yahyل', al-Tamيmي
(d. 307 AH/919 CE)

Musnad
Damascus: Dلr al-Ma'mْn li al-Turلth, 1984 CE

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S142 al-Bazzلr, Ahmad b. `Amr b. `Abd al-Khلliq, Abْ Bakr al-Bazzلr (not Bazzلz) al-Misrي
(d. 292 AH/905 CE)

Musnad al-Mu`allal
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S265 al-Zarandي, Jamلl al-Dيn Muhammad b. Yْsuf b. al-Hasan al-Madanي al-'Ansلrي al-Hanafي
(d. 750 AH/1349 CE)

Nazm durar al-simtayn fي fadل'il al-Mustafل' wa al-Murtadل wa al-Batْl wa al-Sibtayn
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S199 Ibn Miskawayh, Ahmad b. Muhammad b. Ya`qْb, Abْ `Alي
(d. 421 AH/1030 CE)

Nadيm al-farيd
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S271 Ibn Jلbir al-'Andalusي, Shams al-Dيn Muhammad b. Ahmad b. `Alي, Abْ `Abd Allلh al-Hawلrي al-Mلlikي
(d. 780 AH/1378 CE)

Nafah al-tayyib
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S313 Ahmad b. Muhammad b. `Umar, Shihلb al-Dيn al-Khafلjي al-Misrي al-Hanafي
(d. 1069 AH/1659 CE)

Nasيm al-riyلd fي sharh Shifل' al-Qلdي `Iyلd
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S346 `Abd al-Hamيd b. Mahmْd, al-ءlْsي al-Baghdلdي al-Shلfi`ي al-Darيr
(d. 1324 AH/1906 CE)

Nathr al-la'لlي fي sharh nazm al-'amلlي
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S161 Muhammad b. `Alي, Abْ `Abd Allلh al-Hakيm al-Tirmidhي al-Sْfي al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 320 AH/932 CE)

Nawلdir al-usْl
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S344 al-Shablanjي, Mu'min b. Hasan Mu'min
(d. 1325 AH/1907 CE)

Nْr al-absلr fي manلqib ءl al-bayt al-nabي al-mukhtلr
Cairo: Maktabah Mustafل al-Bلbي al-Halabي, 1367/1948

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S303 `Abd al-Rahmلn b. `Abd al-Salلm, al-Safْrي al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 950 AH/1543 CE)

Nuzhat al-majلlis
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S323 Mيrzل Muhammad b. Mu`tamad Khلn al-Hلrithي al-Badakhshي (al-Badakhshلnي)
(d. 1150 AH/1737 CE)

Nuzul al-abrلr bimل sahh min manلqib ahl al-bayt al-athلr
Bombay, 1880 CE

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S326 Shلh Walي Allلh b. `Abd al-Rahيm al-Dihlawي
(d. 1176 AH/1763 CE)

Qurrat al-`aynayn
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S223 al-Zamakhsharي, Jلr Allلh Mahmْd b. `Umar, Abu al-Qلsim
(d. 538 AH/1144 CE)

Rabي` al-abrلr wa nusْs al-'akhbلr
Beirut: Mu'assasat al-A`lamي li'l-Matbْ`لt (5 vols), 1992 CE

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S300 Diyل' al-Dيn Ahmad b. Muhammad, Abْ Muhammad al-Witrي al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 980 AH/1572 CE)

Rawdah al-nلzirيn
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S328 Muhammad b. Ismل`يl b. Salلh, al-'Amيr al-Yamلnي al-San`لnي al-Husaynي
(d. 1182 AH/1768 CE)

Rawdلt al-nadiyyah fي sharh al-Tuhfat al-`Alawiyyah
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S251 Al-Nawawي, Muhyi al-Dيn Yahyل b. Sharaf al-Dيn b. Hasan, Abْ Zakariyyل al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 676 AH/1277 CE)

Riyلd al-sلlihيn
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S254 Muhibb al-Dيn Ahmad b. `Abd Allلh, Abْ al-`Abbلs al-Tabarي al-Makkي al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 694 AH/1295 CE)

Riyلd al-Nadirah
Beirut: Dلr al-kutub al-`ilmiyyah, 1405/1984

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S338 al-ءlْsي al-Baghdلdي, Mahmْd b. `Abd Allلh, Shihلb al-Dيn Abْ al-Thanل al-Husaynي al-ءlْsي al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 1270 AH/1854 CE)

Rْh al-Ma`لnي
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S240 al-Qarshي, `Alي b. Hamيd
(d. 621 AH/1224 CE)

Shams al-akhbلr al-muntaqل min kalلm al-nabي al-mukhtلr
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S289 Al-Sanْsي, Muhammad b. Yْsuf b. `Umar b. Shu`ayb, Abْ `Abd Allلh al-Talmasلnي al-Husaynي
(d. 895 AH/1490 CE)

Sharh Sahيh Muslim
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S279 Muhammad b. Khalيfah, Abْ `Abd Allلh, al-Washtلnي al-Mلlikي
(d. 827 AH/1424 CE)

Sharh Sahيh Muslim ('Ikmلl al-dيn al-mu`allim)
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S327 Muhammad b. Sلlim b. Ahmad, Shams al-Dيn al-Misrي al-Hafnي al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 1181 AH/1767 CE)

Sharh `Azيzي (hلshiyah of Jلmi` al-saghيr)
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S274 Sa`d al-Dيn Mas`ْd b. `Umar b. `Abd Allلh, al-Harawي al-Taftلzلnي al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 791 AH/1389 CE)

Sharh al-maqلsid
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S277 al-Jurjلnي, al-Sharيf `Alي b. Muhammad b. `Alي, Abْ al-Hasan al-Husaynي al-Hanafي
(d. 816 AH/1413 CE)

Sharh al-mawلqif
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S321 al-Zurqلnي, Muhammad b. `Abd al-Bلqي b. Yْsuf, Abْ `Abd Allلh al-'Azharي al-Zarqلnي al-Mلlikي
(d. 1122 AH/1710 CE)

Sharh al-Muwلhib al-ladunniyyah
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S287 `Alل al-Dيn `Alي b. Muhammad al-Qawshajي
(d. 879 AH/1474 CE)

Sharh al-tajrيd
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S355 Muhammad Mahmْd al-Rلfi`ي al-Misrي
(d. 1350 AH/1931 CE)

Sharh Hلshimiyyلt
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S356 Muhammad Shلkir Khayyلt al-Nabalusي al-'Azharي
(d. 1350 AH/1931 CE)

Sharh Hلshimiyyلt
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S247 Ibn Abي al-Hadيd, `Izz al-Dيn `Abd al-Hamيd b. Hibat Allلh, Abْ Hلmid al-Mu`tazilي
(d. 656 AH/1258 CE)

Sharh Nahj al-Balلghah
Beirut: Ihyل' al-turلth al-`arabي, n.d.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S291 Kamلl al-Dيn Husayn b. Mu`يn al-Dيn, al-Yazdي al-Maybadhي (or al-Maybudي)
(d. 950 AH/1543 CE)

Sharh-i dيwلn al-mansْb ilل al-Imلm `alayh al-salلm (al-Fawلtih)
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S195 `Abd al-Malik b. Muhammad, Abْ Sa`d al-Wل`iz al-Nيsلbْrي al-Kharkْshي (al-Khargْshي)
(d. 406 AH/1015 CE)

Sharaf al-Mustafل
Manuscript (British Library) Or. 3014,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S214 Ibn Haddلd al-Haskلnي, `Ubayd Allلh b. `Abd Allلh, Abْ al-Qلsim al-Hلkim al-Nيsلbْrي al-Hanafي
(d. 490 AH/1097 CE)

Shawلhid al-tanzيl
Tehran: Majma` Ihyل' al-thaqلfa al-Islلmiyyah (2 vols), 1411/1990

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S177 Muhammad b. al-Hasan b. Muhammad, Abْ Bakr al-Naqqلsh al-Mufassir al-Mْsilي
(d. 351 AH/962 CE)

Shifل' al-sudْr
Manuscript,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S132 Ibn Mلjah, Muhammad b. Yazيd, Abْ `Abd Allلh al-Qazwيnي
(d. 273 AH/886 CE)

Sunan
Cairo, 1952 CE

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S351 Ahmad Zakي `Adwي al-Misrي
(d. 1350 AH/1931 CE)

Ta`lيq Kitلb al-'Aghلnي
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S350 Ahmad Farيd Rafل`ي, al-Daktْr
(d. 1350 AH/1931 CE)

Ta`lيq Mu`jam al-'udabل'
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S352 Ahmad Nasيm al-Misrي
(d. 1356 AH/1937 CE)

Ta`lيqah Dيwلn Mihyلr al-Daylamي
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S260 al-Dhahabي, Shams al-Dيn Muhammad b. Ahmad b. `Uthmلn, Abْ `Abd Allلh
(d. 748 AH/1347 CE)

Tadhkirat al-huffلz
Haydarabad: Dل'irat al-ma`لrif al-nizلmiyyah, 1333 AH

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S246 Sibt b. al-Jawzي, Shams al-Dيn Yْsuf b. Qizughlي, Abْ al-Muzaffar
(d. 654 AH/1256 CE)

Tadhkirat khawلss al-'ummah fي ma`rifat al-a'immah
Najaf: al-Maktabah al-Haydariyyah, 1964 CE

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S228 al-Qurtubي, Yahyل b. Sa`dْn b. Tamلm, Abْ Bakr al-Azdي al-Qurtubي, known as Sلbiq al-Dيn
(d. 567 AH/1172 CE)

Tafsيr (al-kabيr)
Manuscript,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S345 Muhammad `Abduh b. Hasan Khayr Allلh al-Misrي
(d. 1323 AH/1905 CE)

Tafsيr al-Manلr
Cairo, 1330 AH

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S269 Ibn Kathيr, `Imلd al-Dيn Ismل`يl b. `Umar b. Kathيr b. Daw', al-Qarashي al-Dimashqي
(d. 774 AH/1373 CE)

Tafsيr al-Qur'لn al-`Azيm
Beirut: Dلr al-ma`rifah, n.d.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S316 Muhammad Mahbْb al-`ءlam b. Safي al-Dيn Ja`far Badr al-`ءlam
(d. 1050 AH/1640 CE)

Tafsيr al-Shلhي
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S295 `Abd al-Wahhلb b. Muhammad b. Rafي` al-Dيn, al-Husaynي al-Bukhلrي
(d. 932 AH/1526 CE)

Tafsيr Anwarي
Manuscript,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S84 al-Qلsim b. Sallلm, Abْ `Ubayd al-Harawي
(d. 224 AH/839 CE)

Tafsيr Gharيb al-Qur'لn
Manuscript,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

O244 Abْ Sa`ْd al-`Imلdي, Muhammad b. Muhammad b. Mustafل al-Hanafي
(d. 982 AH/1574 CE)

Tafsيr Irshلd al-`aql al-salيm
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S201 Al-Tha`labي, Ahmad b. Muhammad b. Ibrلhيm, Abْ Ishلq al-Nيsلbْrي
(d. 427 AH/1036 CE)

Tafsيr Kashf wa'l-bayلn
Manuscript,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S251 Al-Nawawي, Muhyi al-Dيn Yahyل b. Sharaf al-Dيn b. Hasan, Abْ Zakariyyل al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 676 AH/1277 CE)

Tahdhيb al-Asmل' wa'l-Lughلt
Beirut: Dلr al-kutub al-`ilmiyyah (4 vols), 1980 CE

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S283 Ibn Hajar al-`Asqalلnي, Shihلb al-Dيn Ahmad b. Nْr al-Dيn `Alي, Abْ al-Fadl al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 852 AH/1448 CE)

Tahdhيb al-Tahdhيb
Haydarabad: Dل'irat al-ma`لrif al-nizلmiyyah (12 vols), 1325-7 AH

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S330 al-Zubaydي, Muhibb al-Dيn Muhammad Murtadل, Abْ al-Fayd al-Wلsitي al-Hanafي al-Bilgirلmي
(d. 1205 AH/1791 CE)

Tلj al-'arْs min jawلhir al-qلmْs
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S348 Bahlْl Behjat Afandي al-Shلfi`ي, al-Qلdي
(d. 1350 AH/1931 CE)

Ta'rيkh ءl Muhammad
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S292 al-Suyْtي, Jalلl al-Dيn `Abd al-Rلhmلn b. Kamلl al-Dيn Abي Bakr, al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 911 AH/1505 CE)

Tلrيkh al-Khulafل'
Beirut: Dلr al-Ma`rifah, 1417/1996

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S209 al-Khatيb al-Baghdلdي, Ahmad b. `Alي b. Thلbit, Abْ Bakr
(d. 463 AH/1071 CE)

Ta'rيkh Baghdلd
Beirut: Dلr al-kutub al-`arabي (18 vols), n.d.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S231 Ibn `Asلkir, `Alي b. al-Husayn b. Hibat Allلh, Abْ al-Qلsim al-Dimashqي al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 571 AH/1176 CE)

Ta'rيkh madيnat Dimashq (Ta'rيkh al-Kabيr)
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S360 Ahmad b. Muhammad b. al-Siddيq, Shihلb al-Dيn Abْ al-Fayd
(d. 1350 AH/1931 CE)

Tashnيf al-'لdhلn
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S264 Ibn al-Wardي, Zayn al-Dيn `Umar b. Muzaffar b. `Umar, al-Mu`arrي al-Halabي al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 749 AH/1348 CE)

Tatimmah al-mukhtasar fي akhbلr al-bashar
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

O218 Sayyid Shahلb al-Dيn Ahmad
(d. 0 AH/622 CE)

Tawdيh al-Dalل'il `alل tarjيh al-fadل'il
Manuscript,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S296 Ibn al-Dيba`, `Abd al-Rahmلn b. `Alي, Abْ Muhammad al-Shaybلnي al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 944 AH/1537 CE)

Taysيr al-wusْl ilل jلmi` al-'usْl
Cairo: Matba`at Mustafل al-Bلbي al-Halabي, n.d.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S203 `Abd al-Malik b. Muhammad b. Ismل`يl, Abْ Mansْr al-Tha`لlibي al-Naysلbْrي
(d. 429 AH/1038 CE)

Thimلr al-qulْb fي al-mudلf wa al-mansْb
Cairo: Dلd nahdah Misr, 1384/1965

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S259 Al-Mizzي, Jamلl al-Dيn Yْsuf b. al-Zakي `Abd al-Rahmلn b. Yْsuf, Abْ al-Hajjلj al-Kalbي al-Qudل`ي al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 742 AH/1341 CE)

Tuhfat al-ashrلf bi-ma`rifat al-atrلf
Bombay: Dلr al-Qayyimah, 1389/1969

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S242 Ibn al-'Athيr, Abْ al-Hasan `Izz al-Dيn `Alي b. Muhammad b. `Abd al-Karيm
(d. 630 AH/1233 CE)

Usd al-ghلba fي ma`rifat al-sahلba
Cairo (5 vols), 1322 AH

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S242 Ibn al-'Athيr, Abْ al-Hasan `Izz al-Dيn `Alي b. Muhammad b. `Abd al-Karيm
(d. 630 AH/1233 CE)

Usd al-ghلba fي ma`rifat al-sahلba
Cairo (5 vols), n.d.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S293 al-Samhْdي, Nْr al-Dيn `Alي b. `Abd Allلh b. Ahmad, al-Hasanي al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 911 AH/1505 CE)

Wafل' al-wafل' bi akhbلr dلr al-Mustafل'
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S311 Bل Kathيr al-Makkي, Ahmad b. al-Fadl b. Muhammad, al-Shلfi`ي
(d. 1037 AH/1628 CE)

Wasيlat al-ma'لl fي `add manلqib al-'ءl
Manuscript,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S230 `Umar b. Muhammad b. Khidr, al-'Ardabيlي, known as Mullل
(d. 550 AH/1155 CE)

Wasيlat al-muta`abbidيn ilل mutلba`ah sayyid al-mursalيn
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S333 Muhammad Mubيn b. Muhibb Allلh al-Lakhnawي
(d. 1220 AH/1805 CE)

Wasيlat al-najلt fي manلqib al-sلdلt
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S340 Khwلjah Kalلn, Sulaymلn b. Ibrلhيm, al-Husaynي al-Balkhي al-Qundْzي al-Hanafي
(d. 1293 AH/1876 CE)

Yanلbي` al-mawaddah
Unidentified edition,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S141 `Abd Allلh b. Ahmad b. Hanbal, Abْ `Abd al-Rahmلn al-Shaybلnي
(d. 290 AH/903 CE)

Zawل'id Musnad Ahmad b. Hanbal
Manuscript,

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

S215 Ahmad b. Muhammad b. `Alي, Abْ Muhammad al-`ءsimي
(d. 450 AH/1058 CE)

Zayn al-fatل fي sharh sْrah Hal Atل'
Manuscript,

[Aliya]

Brother Youth of Ali, now see you ruined it for Chi by bringing ABUNDANT proof you really expect someone of such limited time (though enough time to hang around here posting on topics that have been discussed many times) to go through all that.... he'll just make up something like he KNOWS it's wrong, but doesn't have time to bring proof. :!!!:

[chiprince007]

hold this debate right here please dont post anymore because i really have to go its my classs time. cant miss an exam. we will continue from here on thursday same time cuz tommarow i don have 1 extra minute. i am no running time out till thurday.
bye

[Mowali]

Brother chirpince007 you can find Imam Ali's saying on calipahte by clicking the below link, enjoy


http://www.al-islam.org/nahj/3.htm

/.../

Beware! By Allلh the son of Abْ Qu<لfah (Abْ Bakr)(2) dressed himself with it (the caliphate) and he certainly knew that my position in relation to it was the same as the position of the axis in relation to the hand-mill. The flood water flows down from me and the bird cannot fly upto me. I put a curtain against the caliphate and kept myself detached from it.

But then again, there is no avail in quoting Imam Ali from Nahjul Balaga, that is why we have been quoting from sunni sources, and you still reject them?

[Socrates]

Aliya, on Apr 7 2004, 06:57 PM, said:

Brother Youth of Ali, now see you ruined it for Chi by bringing ABUNDANT proof you really expect someone of such limited time (though enough time to hang around here posting on topics that have been discussed many times) to go through all that.... he'll just make up something like he KNOWS it's wrong, but doesn't have time to bring proof.

yeah, see how he runs to his class

Its there for others as well Sister aliya, b'coz after all this is a public forum.

[Aliya]

i know, I have to keep reminding myself, when I get frustrated with certain people here, that the ones who post are not the ONLY ones reading the threads. Makes it worthwhile to remember that. Thanks for your public service, brother!

[Socrates]

My pleasure

[chiprince007]

ok I AM BACK AGAIN......

First of ALL I was banned from the site and couldnt figure out the reason of dat even after thinking very hard

NOW dat i am back i saw it AND I AM SO DISAPPOINTED with some of urz cheap tactics. Is there some limit to a personss cheapnesss ??????.

Wasnt it enuf dat i am debating alone with 50 of u guys dat u had to come in and do this to me???

WHAT AM I TALKING ABOUT ??????????

here is what i am talking about.

This person named ABDUL HUJJAH edited my post and got me banned for SLEDRING shias. IF u dont believe me GO UP A LITTLE and read my post and read in the bottom post edited by abdul hujjah


here is what i got banned for

Quote

[edit] would dat make any difference to u if i tell what even u have been believing abt us is not even close to the TRUTH. it wont yea keep on. Pretty soon u will add Iblees , Shaitan , Namrood , Firon , and Abu Jahl to ur Imams list and fool ur shia brothersss i don care do what ever u will be questioned no me ....

[Moderators note : slandering shia and personal attacks not accepted - you are suspended for 3 days

This post has been edited by Abdulhujjah on Apr 7 2004, 03:20 PM

And Wallahi i swear on my muslim hood this is what i actually wrote

Quote

would dat make any difference to u if i tell u dat what ever u have been believing abt us is not even close to the the TRUTH. it wont make any difference to you and u will keep on spreading wierd beliefs about sunnis. Pretty soon u will add Iblees , Shaitan , Namrood , Firon and Abu Jahl to OUR imams list and fool ur shia brothers about what we believe but i dont care do what ever as u will be questioned in the end not me

And this i wrote in rosponse to one of u calling Yazeed a sunni Imam which made me furious.


NOW SISTER ALIYA AND OTHER FELLOW DEBATERSSSS WHAT DO U SAY ABOUT THISS.. Is this ur shia style of debating ??????????. This has happened to me before too but last time person was smart enuf to remove the line which say the post has been edited and had me worried about the wordz i say and cant recall... but this times its clear

This post has been edited by Abdulhujjah on Apr 7 2004, 03:20 PM
This post has been edited by Abdulhujjah on Apr 7 2004, 03:20 PM
This post has been edited by Abdulhujjah on Apr 7 2004, 03:20 PM


and yeaaaa forget about ur 15 year oldzz i have prepared some questions for u which the shia molana at our local bargah couldnt answer and i will post them soon. Ur cheating only make me more determined. and yea if there is any justice in ur chat room which so far i havent seen u should block fitnass like abdul hujjah.. anyways after all u say sunni discussion boards have been unfair to shia brother which i also the case here all da time but no discussion board has dropped down to this level which shiachat.com has droppen tooo...

block me again if ya want i dont care i will just get my answer and stop debating here.
wat a shame guyzzz wat a shame.......

[chiprince007]

Brother YOUTH OF ALI

ok lets say we accept his pbuh last surmon the way u said in ur post, but the problem is we are still stuck at the same place without any progress.


u kno wat a PERFECTION is ?????. any addition or subtraction can only make it worse or less perfect. well this perfect ended without any introduction to shiaism. here is how. even though Hazrat Ali ra was really praised for his deeds by Muhammad pbuh WHERE IS THE PART THERE ARE SOME PEOPLE CALLED IMAMS TO WHOM ALLAHS WORDS ARE REVEALED AND DAT THEY ARE EXACT 12 Etc Etc u kno the usuall shia stuff. SO it was perfected without it ....

secondly Ahl e Bait does not be means the genrations after genration comming from Hazrat Ali ra and Hazrat Fatima ra Dat would be Ahl e Ali . The word used every where is Ahl e Bait. The family of Muhammad pbuh in which lots of people are included including the first 3

here is how

Abu Bakr Father in law to Prophet
Omer Father in law to Prophet
Usman Cousin and 2 times Son in law to prophet
Aisha WIFE of the Prophet

so what makes u think they are not also ahle bait. family includes wife first and son in law later. and what about Usman he is the cousin like Ali and son in law twice while ali is once.

THIRDLY the biggest problem is [Edited Out]E DOUBLE STANDARDSSS

If muhammad praises Ali then its ya ali ya ali ya ali
if muhammad praises some one else and its also backed by quran ( I CAN PROVE IT ) then it dont make any difference its still LA LA LA

DO U EVEN CARE ABOUT WHAT MUHAMMAD THINKS i dont think sooo

If ali is son in law to muhammad then his 11 generation after him are also called ahl e bait
while the closest relatives muhammads WIFE about whom muhammad also said is your mother is not not considered ahle bait

why why why why da double standardsssss. ever think about dat.


For now i will let u answer these and then begin my actuall attack ...

[LightUponLight]

Salam

Sorry to butt in, but I'd like to repeat what brother Ultra-Muslim said regarding the "appointment" of the "12 Imams" a while ago:

If they were appointed to rule....and they didn't...what does that tell you? Can anybody change Allah's will?

And yes, wives are part of Ahlul-Bayt according to 33:31-33

Salam

Edited by Ya Muhammad, 12 April 2004 - 01:20 AM.

[chiprince007]

lolz brother youth of ali lol

the only hard find word Imam from quran in ur quote u know what is it referring to ????

here the word imam does not mean the twelevers it actaully mean Quran it self use ur brain u will find out too ...


what were u thinkinggggg

[LightUponLight]

LoL, I already discussed that with him in another thread:

Inna nahnu nuhyeealmawta wanaktubu ma qaddamoo waatharahumwakulla shay-in ahsaynahu fee imamin mubeenin (36:12)

No Youth, this verse is NOT referring to your "Imam."

I will give you 6 different translation of that verse to prove my point:

Khalifa
We will certainly revive the dead, and we have recorded everything they have done in this life, as well as the consequences that continue after their death. Everything we have counted in a profound record.

Yusuf Ali
Verily We shall give life to the dead, and We record that which they send before and that which they leave behind, and of all things have We taken account in a clear Book (of evidence).

Pickthal
Lo! We it is Who bring the dead to life. We record that which they send before (them, and their footprints. And all things We have kept in a clear Register.

Shakir
Surely We give life to the dead, and We write down what they have sent before and their footprints, and We have recorded everything in a clear writing.

Sher Ali
Surely, WE alone give life to the dead, and WE write down that which they send forward and that which they leave behind; and all things WE have recorded in a clear Book.

"Progressive Muslims"
It is indeed Us who resurrect the dead, and We record what they have done and left behind. And everything We have counted in a clear ledger.

I think I've discussed this before with someone. By saying that that verse refers to your Imams, you are giving them RELIGIOUS duties, something which they did NOT have. The role of a caliph/duty comes into play AFTER the demise of the Prophet (saw).

Face it. You CANNOT go to Al-Quran, open it up, and justify any of your beliefs.

Salam

[chiprince007]

Brother ya muhammad if Allah choose some one nabi imam etc he takes responsibility and protection of them also, after facing hardship and strugle there comes a time when they win. look upon any massenger of Allah every body struggled but no one got killed no one. their protection was in allahs hands

so either they failed or its just not true.. ifact the history showsss the first 3 imams were themselves not aware of the fact that they were actually imams of dat status and one of the 12.

[LightUponLight]

It's sister

No, I meant that if the 12 Imams were actually appointed to rule politically, they would have ruled, but they didn't, hence they were not appointed.

Salam

[muntadher]

Quote

so either they failed or its just not true.. ifact the history showsss the first 3 imams were themselves not aware of the fact that they were actually imams of dat status and one of the 12.

rubbish. im just wandering, have you ever read Nahjul Balaghe or the story of Karbala? i dont know who taught you that the Imams didnt know they were the Imams. Could you please show some respect to Imam Ali ?

Quote

Face it. You CANNOT go to Al-Quran, open it up, and justify any of your beliefs.

I think that you should speak for yourself. I cannot believe how you justify not praying or going to Hajj. just out of curiosity, do you fast or is it not mentioned in your interpretation of the quran?

wasalam