36 replies to this topic

[islam313]

who is the biggest leader in the shia world today

[YariAzQuran]

We may not see the sun when it is behind the clouds, but it is nevertheless the sun that sustains us. Likewise, the Imam of our time - Imam Mahdi (aj) - is sustaining and leading the ummah today. I don't think that there's any doubt that Sayed Ali Khamenei is next on that list - regardless of anyone's views on him and his government.

[Quranist]

problem is true leader is always not accepted by mass(majority)

[Follower]

Sayyed Ali Khamenei.

[awaiting_for_the.12th]

Ayatuallah Khamanei is Wali-Amr-AlMuslimeen. Be it sunni or shia

[Martyrdom]

Imam Mahdi(ATF)

[khadimahulubayt]

What do you mean by biggest leader? in what way/shape/form?

[AliHussainFaraji]

Imam Mahdi (AF)

[GreyMatter]

Ayatollah Khamenai and Ayatollah Sistani.
I say both are, in their right way.

[khameneivoter]

as salam aleikom

regarding to the current situation in the world and the fact that iran is the only shia state at the moment, Imam Khamenei is by logic and common sense the most important leader in the shia world. he is attentive, speaks clearly against oppression and arrogance and is an active fighter for shia rights!

[Hasan0404]

Syed Ali Sestani and Syed Ali Khamenai. May Allah prolong their lives.

[Follower]

I've changed my reply: the biggest leader is the nafs, because most of us don't seem to want to follow anything else.

Wallahu A'lam

[GodBlessAli]

Sistani is 82. Khamanei is 73. The more authoritative one is Sistani, although I am a Muqallid (in Taqlid) of Khamanei. While Imam al-Quaimm (aj) is the greatest human alive at the moment!

[DoubleAgent4]

Mushu, on 13 August 2012 - 06:22 AM, said:

Syed Ali al-Sistani.

awaiting_for_the.12th, on 13 August 2012 - 07:53 AM, said:

Ayatuallah Khamanei is Wali-Amr-AlMuslimeen. Be it sunni or shia

*facepalm* I've lost the will to live after seeing the comments. I agree with Zulfiqar14's post though.

[JawzofDETH]

Personalities come and go, our Imaam Al-Mahdi is our leader.

[Hot hot]

No doubt mehdi a.s is our biggest leader but what about the ordinary humanpeople like us do we have only sistani and khamenei ?
Whose the young leader In Shia world today ?

[khameneivoter]

the problem of Hz Imam mahdi(as) is, that his eminence is not leading "active" the ummah, that means we cant see his action and his commands directly, so that the question about Imam mahdi(as) is the biggest leader are an uncorrect answer is. we have to be focused on the leaders this time and sure we cant compare any of them with imam mahdis(as) unique role as a leader but after his role as a unique leader, Imam khamenei is playing a significant role in bringing the day closer of hz imam mahdi(as) coz i have not seen any leader this time who spoke more open and more clearly, what the matter of the ummah is. supporting the islamic revolution and supporting imam khamenei means that we are supporting the strength of the islamic ummah and the return of hz. imam mahdi(as) inshallah.

[JawzofDETH]

Then if Sistani And Khamenei (Rah) have to both pass on tomorrow, then when asked who is your leader what would you say?

Was-Salaam

Edited by JawzofDETH, 18 August 2012 - 07:19 AM.

[khameneivoter]

JawzofDETH, on 18 August 2012 - 07:19 AM, said:

Then if Sistani And Khamenei (Rah) have to both pass on tomorrow, then when asked who is your leader what would you say?

Was-Salaam

who has ever the same qualities like Imam khamenei, there is always a great leader outside this world!

[awaiting_for_the.12th]

Hawraa29, on 14 August 2012 - 02:44 PM, said:

*facepalm* I've lost the will to live after seeing the comments. I agree with Zulfiqar14's post though.

*facepalm* (i could never understand why people be all dramatic with internet lingo, its not like it does any effect on the reader) Well good thing you know how to end it.

[Follower]

Quote

Then if Sistani And Khamenei (Rah) have to both pass on tomorrow, then when asked who is your leader what would you say?

Brother, the concept of leadership is central in Islam, even to the point where even if two believers travel together one of them should be the leader.

The likes of Shaheed Sayyed Abbas al Musawi, Marhum Sayyed al Khomeini and Sayyed Musa al Sadr (whose news we await eagerly) were also leaders before, and alhamdulillah others took over after them.

Quote

Well good thing you know how to end it.

Inappropriate comment to a sister in faith.

[awaiting_for_the.12th]

Follower, on 19 August 2012 - 04:21 AM, said:

Inappropriate comment to a sister in faith.

She lost the will to live so i humbly gave my opinion. When there is so much to live for how can someone lose hope. I am so confused.
If you still don't pick up sarcasm, then i can add the sarcasm-o-meter next time.

[Tima]

Imam Mahdi. We don't need anyone else. He's not dead.

[mistiq]

its really strange. i think we are forgetting the most basic point about leadership of Muslim or Shiite community. if by leader you mean Vali-ul faqih you should keep in mind that most of great Mujtahedin of Shia doubt that Khamenei is the right one. you can find it simply by reviewing their sayings.

[khameneivoter]

Tima, on 20 August 2012 - 03:11 PM, said:

Imam Mahdi. We don't need anyone else. He's not dead.

thats nonsense, sorry. are u agree with me that imam mahdi(as) is the most educated person in the world? if we would follow your logic then we would not need any other islamic teacher in the world because he could never teach or educate us like imam mahdi(as)can. imam mahdi(as)isnt active leading us at the moment, thats a fact, so as long we dont have a alive leadership, we should get guided by the most competent leaders we have and nobody is saying imam khamenei is replacing imam mahdis(as) position-aouthubillah....