Saiyidina Umar Farooq radiyallahu anhu embraced Islam in the early period of Makkan life. Prophet Muhammad s.a.w and his followers were already leading a miserable life there, how would they provide security to the reverts against the pagans of Makkah. Don't forget that was the time when Quraysh boycotted them and they had to live in the Sheb of Abi Talib. According to us, even Hadrat Abi Talib died at kufr, he was not a believer, so in this case the Prophet of Islam took shelter in the house of a disbeliever??
Hadrat Musa alayhis salam was raised in the house of a cursed kafir called Pharaoh of Egypt, so?
I have a quota of only two posts today, so I will have just one more reply after this.
Secondly, you should find the meaning of the word 'LOGIC' in the dictionary, it doesn't mean 'APPLE or BANANA'.
And lastly, it's really ridiculous how you guys question the bravery and courage of Saiyidina Umar r.a.
blah blah blah......i can answer all your ridiculous assertions but lets stick to the topic.....i have proven from your references the cowardice of Umar, how he ran away from battles, now instead of sounding all high and mighty just disprove me WITH REFERENCES.
P.S. Abu Talib is a muslim in our belief and only ignorant sunnis and maloon nasibis call him Kaafir...but that is a debate for a different time.
and yeah since you mentioned sheb Abi Talib, please do mention how your 1-2-3 helped the besieged family during the seige or do discover how they abandoned the family during that period.
Enjoy using your LOGIC of APPLE or BANANA ...but i will prefer solid references.