174 replies to this topic

[Waiting for HIM]

Salam,

Ramadhan Kareem and congratulations on the birth anniversary of the 2nd Imam -

I am asking a question from all of you momineen brothers and sisters on SC, do you think Shia Chat's been hijacked by wahabies who post here with Shia pseudonyms?

Test in case, not a day goes by when there are threads initiated by certain SC members (you all know the names) with topics such as:

1. Spread doubt about the knowledge of Aimah using one or two zaif Hadith
2. Spread rumors about the ismah of Aimah using one or two zaif Hadith
3. Syeda Fatima Zahara Batool Tahira has been called contaminated with najasat.
4. Prophet of Islam has been called illiterate and not a born Muslim
5. Most authentic and oft repeated history of Hijra, Shab Abi Talib, Badr, Ohod, Ghadeer, and Karbala has attempted to be distorted
6. Quran, Hadith, Nahjulbalagha is routinely doubted,
7. Same people ridicule Shia Marajae of today and in the same breath seem to worship the Shia Marajae of the past
8. When argument and ego allows, the equation flips in #7 above, and suddenly the Shia Marajae of today become the darling and the ulema of the past are ridiculed

More so do you think even some mods have been compromised too? (Mods don't ban me on this comment, you ain't the Chief Justice of Pakistan with their new wave of court contempt cases on every voice of objection

Test in case, People get banned on almost everything on SC but I have yet to see a ban on any of the offensive commentators from among the Ahlulbayt Offenders on SC. Offensive comments have ranged from being offensive to normal Shia SC members all the way to Prophet and Aimah . Again no need to name names, but there seem to be some who are very obviously ignoring (tantamount to shielding) some offenders even when their posts are reported repeatedly.

Lastly, and I don't need a poll for this, but does it seem to you if it's the time for a Shia Chat-II, where Shias on revived Shia Chat could share thoughts, ideas, and knowledge freely without being hounded by a pack of closet wahabies.

Thoughts? Comments?

Wassalam and happy fasting.

[Haydar Husayn]

[Murtada]

Shahr Ramadaan and mawlid 'Imaam al Hasan mubaarik to you as well.
I think you are mistaken in assigning the "wahabi" label. May Allaah ÓÈÍÇäå æÊÚÇáì lay infinite curses on the "wahabis."
You probably understand differences occurred between the early and later 'ulama. They supported their differences with ahaadeeth of the ma'sumeen and the ayaa of the Quraan. If someone brings up an opposing viewpoint than yours and says this is the hadeeth or the tafsir of the ayaa from the Quraan that led me to believe this; why not have an intelligible discussion?

[Al-Afasy]

[macisaac]

Lastly, and I don't need a poll for this, but does it seem to you if it's the time for a Shia Chat-II, where Shias on revived Shia Chat could share thoughts, ideas, and knowledge freely without being hounded by a pack of closet wahabies.

[Ali_Hussain]

[89jghur32]

[Logic]

Wow the entire clique is here and they have finally discovered internet memes. Welcome to the glorious world of internet!

[Al-Afasy]

Wow the entire clique is here and they have finally discovered internet memes. Welcome to the glorious world of internet!

Brother, he did ask for our thoughts and comments...

[89jghur32]

Brother, he did ask for our thoughts and comments...

Yeah man, we're just giving some feedback... No intelligible discussion here. We'll save that for SCII or shall I say SC Reloaded *in a Terminator voice*.

[Logic]

Brother, he did ask for our thoughts and comments...

Daunting task there so instead you posted someone view of funny. Gotcha!

[DPRK_Guy]

Waiting brother, I think you are forgetting Vali Fakih doctrine.

[HellHound]

Welcome to Memeland Central Folks! It has now been officially integrated into SC!

[Ali_Hussain]

Welcome to Memeland Central Folks! It has now been officially integrated into SC!

I don't think you are posting at that point, but its been done

http://www.shiachat....shiachat-memes/

Though we could merge the two

[Kaniz e Zahra]

Edited by Kaniz e Zahra, 03 August 2012 - 04:29 PM.

[Propaganda_of_the_Deed]

Lastly, and I don't need a poll for this, but does it seem to you if it's the time for a Shia Chat-II, where Shias on revived Shia Chat could share thoughts, ideas, and knowledge freely without being hounded by a pack of closet wahabies.

[Ruq]

Hehehehe i love that kids expression.

[struggling_On]

C'mon Op, Just have a laid back attitude, that's really "in" today's world from religion to everything else. People have freedom of speech don't forget there are ignorants too in masses they also have the same freedom,

[La fata illa Ali]

Shahr Ramadhan hunger-anger has been spewing on SC for the last couple of weeks and I say ya'll should take a sabbatical for the rest of the month.

[struggling_On]

Gotta love this kid, he is cute and intelligent.........

[Waiting for HIM]

Wow this was easy, I really didn't need to name names

On a serious note, banned veterans of Shia Chat are more in numbers than the current folks attempting to conquer hearts and minds in here. So any suggested domain names for the Shia Chat rebooted?

[HellHound]

Bro I think you've blown this WAAAAAAY out of proportion... The people you are referring to as "closet" wahabbis are yours and my brothers and sisters in Islam. Yes, they have beliefs which are... unorthodox and stand out from the mainstream and popular view, but they are nowhere near being Sunnis, let alone wahabbis...

bro HH for example, I have disagreements with him regarding Taqleed, and a few other historical matters like the Tafsir of Surat Tahreem. But he and I talked it out and agreed to disagree for the most part. I see him as my brother in faith and I'm sure he sees me in much the same way.

You gotta take a chill pill mate. Don't turn into something like me, because I have a history of opening such topics in the past lol...

[Haydar Husayn]

On a serious note, banned veterans of Shia Chat are more in numbers than the current folks attempting to conquer hearts and minds in here. So any suggested domain names for the Shia Chat rebooted?

I suggest GhaliChat.

[Kaniz e Zahra]

I suggest GhaliChat.

I knew your response in advance,at least it won't be muqqassir chat.If 99%Shias in the world are Ghaalis then we'll decide the names for tiny miny minority.

Hellhound now you see this name giving is not one sided.

Edited by Kaniz e Zahra, 03 August 2012 - 07:21 PM.

[Haydar Husayn]

I knew your response in advance,at least it won't be muqqassir chat.If 99%Shias in the world are Ghaalis then we'll decide the names for tiny miny minority.

Hellhound now you see this name giving is not one sided.

If I cared about what the majority thought, then I would be a Sunni.