1 reply to this topic

[ImamAliTrueSuccessor]

Salam this is what Sayed Kamal Al Haydari said when he was telling people what you need to no before you debate in the topic of Shia and Sunni

sadly, recently i have received many inquiries from the dear viewers about why i would not debate this man.
By Allah, if we would find a man who KNOWS the scientific method (of debate) and what it means, then we would certainly debate them!
but, be assured - with all due respect -  i could not even find anybody who knows the names of our (shia) books.
How does he want to debate me when he does not have a clue about our books?\
How does he want to debate with me when he does not know which hadith (tradition) is authentic and which is not accepted in our books?
just how?!
They need to adopt the method that you see we demonstrate to you.they need to get somebody who has studied the legace of ahlulbayt and their books very well.
And they need to use these books as proof for the arguments they put forth... it is Then that we will debate them.
I honestly say this to all the dear viewers and listeners; whoever wishes to debate or discuss the teachings of ahlulbayt, then they must study there books for 10 or 20 years or so from all fields.
Once they know our foundations, then we can debate with them.
Just as i am doing now.I am speaking and arguing according to the school of the sahaba (companions) and the ummayad school of thought.
For example,i always turn to the groups that each narrator belongs to.For instance,Ibn.Hajar al Asqalani is from the Ummayad nation..so is Al Thahabi, but Al Nisai'i is not from them.
He (the debator) must also recognise that in the school of thought of Ahlulbayt there are different wings(or
sections), and it is not fair that he points to the beleifs of a certain individual and says that ALL Shia believe in this,    X2
This shows to you that the speaker (who claims all this) is ignorant. It shows that the speaker is either an ignorant,
or a liar who wants to misguide the general Muslims (Sunni brothers into hating us).
They always direct their speech to the general Muslims - i.e. Sunnis - if you are really capable, then direct your speech to our scholars. Then you will find the answer with us

[kish_mr2008]

hi . what do think :?